On the matter of church amusements the New York Observer has the following, which is worthy of serious consideration:—
“When the church took hold of the idea that it must do something to attract young people, its acceptance of the theory was so hearty and zealous that it rushed at once into an exploration of the whole field of such amusements as should serve the important purpose. But the trouble is that these church amusements are, in one respect, like all other amusements—the interest must constantly intensify or they grow monotonous and cease to attract. The cantata, which had its little run some half dozen years ago, was founded upon the story of Queen Esther, or the melancholy fate of Jephthah’s daughter, and so had a remote biblical reference which might be detected by one who possessed powerful intellect and was at the same time a close Old Testament student.
“But in the course of time these wretched travesties grew monotonous, and now there is the well-marked tendency for the cantata to develop into the operetta, while in the line of outdoor attractions we have arrived at the point of the Sunday-school picnic balloon ascension, where the aeronaut hangs on by his teeth, and it really seems that there is not much beyond left for the church to present except the pugilistic combat or the bullfight. Whether the church of the future will have to choose between these things and the loss of its young people remains to be seen; but it is reasonably certain that if things go on as they have been going in some quarters, the successful church of the next decade will be the one that can secure the services of Henry Irving to impersonate Judas Iscariot for the enlightenment of the Sunday school, and that is financially able to give a grand pyrotechnic representation of the fall of Babylon when that point is reached in the International Lessons.”