In a paper called The Standard, printed in Chicago, Ill., there is a department named “Uncle John’s Letter Box,” in which are published questions by the children, and answers by “Uncle John.” And the children are asking some pretty sharp questions. For instance, Eddie Eaton, of Rochelle, Ill., writes to Uncle John:
“We have an Advent neighbor who says that there is no place in the Bible where it speaks of the immortality of the soul. I disagree with her, but as yet have found no place where it does. Please tell me what you think about it.”
We wish Eddie might be suffered to go on and examine the Bible from beginning to end on this subject, without any interference from those whose business it is to doctor a sick divinity, which would soon get well if they would let it alone, and our word for it, he would not find any place which speaks of the soul as immortal. No one would find any such place if he had not such a theory, and did not feel obliged to find something in the Bible to sustain it. But Uncle John thinks “there are places enough where ‘it speaks of the immortality of the soul,’” yet he gives only one, which is this: “These shall go away into everlasting punishment; but the righteous into life eternal.” Matt. 25:46. All the INSTRUCTOR readers have probably noticed before this that this text says nothing about what is called the soul. It speaks of the whole being, and the time when it applies is at the close of the great day of Judgment. One class have life eternal. Why? Because they have been made immortal. The Bible expressly says this in other places. But the wicked have the opposite. Is that eternal life also? It is if they are to live forever. But it is punishment; and a person can suffer a punishment which is everlasting without being all the time in conscious misery. Hanging a man for murder is called capital punishment. Death is the punishment. So it is with the wicked. They suffer the second death. It is called everlasting destruction in another place; but destruction is not an eternal preservation of life.
But Uncle John wants Eddie to ask his Advent neighbor to find a place in the Bible where it says in just those words that there is a God. And then he says we don’t need to be told there is a God, because we know it without. Just so, he says, we know that the soul is immortal without being told. But Uncle John mistakes. The Bible does say, “There is one God,” or, which is the same thing, it says we do well to believe this; and again it says that when we come to God we must believe that he is. Does it anywhere tell us that we must believe or understand that the soul is immortal? Nowhere. And let it be kept in mind that it is not the existence of the soul, but its immortality that is in question. True, the Bible has a good deal to say about God, from which we know that such a being exists. Now if Uncle John’s argument is good for anything, it must have a good deal to say also, not simply about the soul, but about its immortality. But does it say anything in any place about the soul’s immortality, from which we may know that the soul has such an attribute? Not a word. We hope that Advent neighbor will show Eddie how unfair Uncle John’s reasoning is.
Another letter in the Letter Box says: “Will Uncle John please tell a little one who it was that changed the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week; and why it was done; for I have been taught in the Catechism and in the Ten Commandments that the seventh day was the Sabbath. Please inform a child.”
This is not the first child which has beenp. 23 puzzled to know why people do not now keep the day which the commandment tells them to keep. The commandments and the catechism cause a great deal of difficulty. Something must be done. The catechism can be changed. But what about the commandments? They cannot be changed; and that is the trouble. So Uncle John trudges over the old beaten path which Roman Catholics have made before him, to prove that the Sabbath has been changed; that is, Christ rose on the first day of the week, Christ met his disciples on that day, and again after eight days, (which he says was just a week! Will not some of the INSTRUCTOR children count it up and see?) and the disciples were blessed on the day of pentecost, and they met on the first day of the week to break bread, and Paul commanded the churches of Corinth and Galatia to lay by them in store on that day, and John was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day, and the churches founded by the apostles, it is said, kept the day. So no matter about that commandment which God gave in such grandeur from Mt. Sinai; for of course we are to keep this day instead of the other, although that has never been repealed, and this has never been commanded. But Uncle John forgot to say that Christ was probably crucified on Friday, that he met with his disciples on one occasion, when they were out fishing, John 21:1 (which Uncle John, we presume, wouldn’t care to have people do on Sunday), and that he ascended on Thursday; all of which have just as much to do with the Sabbath as his resurrection on the first day of the week does.
We would like to say to that child, that the commandment is right, and she will do best to keep the day which that commandment tells us to keep.
A LOVER OF TRUTH.