AdventAI

SABBATH-SCHOOL COLLECTIONS: ARE THEY WRONG?

By Eld. Littlejohn

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 31, No. 42., October 17, 1883

[We had supposed that the question of Sabbath-school contributions had been settled long ago. But as some have requested that an article be published in this double number, giving reasons for the course so generally pursued among our schools, of making this collection upon the Sabbath, we can perhaps do nothing better than to reprint the excellent article of Eld. Littlejohn, published some months ago in the Review.—Ed.]

Having received a letter from a friend of the cause who is somewhat troubled on account of the practice of taking up collections in our Sabbath-schools on the Sabbath day, I have thought best to reply through the Review to some of the points which he makes, as in doing so the minds of others may also be relieved.

I suppose that it will be conceded that more money can be raised by weekly contributions or collections than in any other way. It will also be admitted that there is less labor connected with the collection of a given amount of means by weekly contributions than would necessarily attend the raising of an equal amount in any other manner. While, therefore, these two considerations should weigh nothing in the argument if the practice under consideration is really unscriptural, they should be taken into the account if that practice cannot be objected to from the moral point of view; since it is important to the cause of God that the amount of money raised should be large, and that the raising of the same should be accomplished with as little trouble as possible.

It should be remembered also, that no coercion is attempted in this matter. Those only are asked to donate on the Sabbath who feel that they could do so without violence to their consciences. Should any prefer to make their contributions on a week day, there is not the slightest objection to their doing so. Perhaps, indeed, it might be well to encourage to a certain extent the latter method for a time on the part of those who favor it, as it would give them a fair opportunity to prove by the liberality of their donations that they did not object to the common methods simply from a desire to escape the necessity of giving at all.

Before discussing the question upon its merits, it might be well for a moment to look at the objection raised on the ground of consistency. Some seem to be annoyed over the idea that the new plan is in conflict with the former teachings of our ministers. It is said that the latter have formerly made a point against the orthodox churches on account of their Sunday collections, that is, they have taught that those churches were doing wrong, from their standpoint, in passing the contribution box on Sunday. That such has been the case in some instances, cannot be denied. But suppose we were to admit that it had been true of every minister in our denomination. Would it necessarily follow from that admission that we should persist in denouncing Sabbath collections after we had become satisfied they could be defended upon principle? I think that no considerate person will answer this question in the affirmative. It has never been claimed that Seventh-day Adventist preachers are infallible. Many of them have changed their views from time to time on different subjects. Were they to refuse to do so again, when convinced that they have been wrong, it would be greatly to their discredit. Consistency may be desirable, but truth is indispensable.

But again: it is not a fact that all of our ministers have heretofore taken a position that it would be wrong to take up a collection on a holy day. While some have doubted the expediency of thrusting a contribution box in the face of poor worldlings whenever they come into the house of God, as is done by some orthodox churches, they have nevertheless felt that there was no harm in giving those who desired to do so an opportunity to contribute to the cause of God on the Sabbath or any other day. In other words, they have objected to the manner of taking the collection, rather than to the morality of the collection itself.

The impression seems to have gained ground with many that there is something intrinsically corrupt in money. Somehow they have obtained the idea that to touch it on the Sabbath is to become polluted. This, of course, is not true in fact. Gold and silver, or paper currency, really have about them no more taint of corruption than have wood, earthen ware, or precious stones. A communion set of silver would be no more free in this particular than are gold and silver coin. When, however, we engage in the communion on the Sabbath, we handle the former almost with a sense that it is of itself sacred. This comes of its association with the emblems which typify the body and blood of Christ. Very much the same feeling, it seems to me, should take possession of our minds in handling money which is being donated to the cause and work of God. It is devoted to a sacred use, and therefore the sight of it should inspire holy thoughts.

Having seen that there is nothing necessarily contaminating in the substances of which money is made, it may be remarked that when it is given to the cause of God in all sincerity of purpose, there is not only in such an act nothing objectionable in and of itself, but that it is also one purely religious in its character. Most of us are wedded more or less strongly to riches. And it is only when we are in a highly religious state of mind, that we are willing to devote some portion of our means to purposes which will bring us back nothing in return. The mental condition of one who is deliberately placing a portion of his hard-earned money in the contribution box, differs as widely from that in which he usually invests it in worldly affairs, as a frame of mind suitable to prayer differs from one which is adapted to the transaction of secular affairs. This is illustrated by the high commendation by the Saviour, of the widow who gave her “two mites.” We all feel instinctively that when she placed those mites in the treasury, and took her chances of coming to want, she was moved by an impulse which was in the highest degree devotional. That impulse was born of love to God, and its execution was as fully an act of worship as prayer or any other exercise of the mind could be. But if this be true, then the act in which it found expression was purely a religious one, and in no wise objectionable when performed on the Sabbath. Indeed, resting upon the Sabbath is an act very similar in its character to that of contributing to the cause of God on that day. In the one case we give to God our time; in the other we give to him our money, which is the product of time and labor.

The Jewish priests sacrificed on the Sabbath day, placed the shew-bread in its proper position on the table, after having removed therefrom that which had been there the previous week, and performed other work in connection with the temple service. Christ makes mention of that fact, and vindicates them from all blame. Matt. 12:1-7. The principle from which this is done is found in the distinction between acts which are done purely for the glory of God, and those which are put forth to advance our own secular interests.

Scripture proof is of course higher than any other. More or less weight, however, may with propriety be attached to the practices of the Jews in the days of Christ. It is admitted by all that they were extreme rather than lax in their ideas of Sabbath sanctity. The Saviour reproved them for superstitious extravagancep. 177 in that direction, but never for looseness. It was the fashion at that time to discuss critically every act which might be put forth on the Sabbath. Walking on the grass was not considered allowable, because it resulted in bruising the same, and was therefore a sort of threshing, which was forbidden. The application of ointment to a wound was thought not to be allowable, because it might result in healing. Indeed, the matter was carried so far by some of the doctors of the law, that they decided it to be wrong for a person to eat an egg which the hen had laid on the Sabbath day. In the midst of all this fanatical nonsense, however, it will be seen from the following that they were in the habit of contributing to the support of the poor regularly on the Sabbath day: “It was a regular custom among Jews to make their collections for the poor on the Sabbath day, that they might not be without the necessaries of life, and might not be prevented from coming to the synagogue. For the purpose of making this provision, they had a purse which was called ‘Arneki shel tsidekali,’ ‘The purse of the alms,’ or what we would call the poor’s box.”—A. Clarke, Com. on 1 Cor. 16:1, 2

Had our Saviour been disturbed as much by Sabbath collections as some of our good brethren seem to be, it is quite probable that he would have left on record a condemnation of the Sabbath desecration which took place every Sabbath day in the synagogue, and in the very temple of God itself. The absence of any reproof under the circumstances furnishes presumptive evidence that the practice itself was not wrong.

In order to avoid all unnecessary labor in the matter, our brethren should see to it during the week that the money which they propose to give is collected, and placed in the purse, or pocket-book, where it will be easy of access on the Sabbath day.

Some have said that they can see no difference between purchasing a cow with money placed in an envelope on a week day and handed to the seller on the Sabbath, and the act of a Sabbath-school teacher who gives to the superintendent, on the Sabbath, an envelope containing money for Sabbath-school uses. The errors of these persons consist in two things; first, in a mistaken notion that the handling of money under all circumstances produces defilement; and secondly, that there is no difference between working for one’s self on the Sabbath, and working for the Lord on the Sabbath. Concerning the first error, we need say no more than has been said above. As it regards the second, it is enough to remark that the minister works harder on the Sabbath than on any other day of the week, and yet is blameless, as all agree. The basis of this agreement is the admission that it is always right to work directly for God. Carrying this principle into the decision of the question before us, its settlement becomes easy.

When a man either buys or pays for a cow on the Sabbath day, he commits a sin, because the act is one of a secular nature. There is in it not one element of religion. The purchase of his cow in no wise advances the cause of God. He takes the Lord’s time, and appropriates it to his own uses. On the other hand, when he puts money in the Sabbath-school collection box, or in an envelope, as the case may be, he performs a work which is not in the least secular in its nature. The act is a religious one. It does not advance his worldly interests one particle, but it does advance the interests of the cause of God.

With these remarks we must close. As we do so, we wish to repeat what has been said above about compulsion. No man is compelled to contribute on the Sabbath day, and we hope that those who are allowed to make their donations on a week day, if they prefer so to do, will not attempt to interfere with those who prefer to make theirs on the Sabbath. If the Saviour was not disturbed by the Jewish practice of alms-giving on that day, we see no good reason why our friend cannot be reconciled to the idea of allowing those who desire so to do, to place their contributions in the collection made on the Sabbath.