AdventAI

What Is a Failure?

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 33, No. 48., December 16, 1885

I DON'T know how many of my readers are familiar with the names of the two French writers, Erckmann and Chatrian; but they are very famous in France and Europe, and pretty well known in all the civilized world. They write stories together; you will often hear of a book by “M. M. Erckmann—Chatrian,” showing that it was written by both together. Their stories are remarkable for purity and beauty. Some years ago the two had just finished a romance intended for one of the Paris papers. Before sending it to the printer, M. M. Erckmann—Chatrian re-read it together. A shade of disappointment settled upon their faces; the romance was not satisfactory, to the authors at least. “Shall I tell you what I think about it?” suddenly remarked Chatrian. “It is lame. We have made a mistake. This romance represents a considerable sum of money; after we have expended it, we shall be none the richer, and will have incurred the responsibility for a commonplace work. I am only too well aware that it has cost us much time and labor to cover these sheets with ink; but what avails it? One’s expectations cannot always be realized; and, just now that we are both in bad humor, let it be settled in this wise: You set out immediately for the Vosges for a much-needed rest. I, of course, am forced to remain in Paris; but before you go, let us burn every leaf of this manuscript, so that, hereafter, we may not be tempted to make use of it in any way.”

“Very well,” responded Erckmann; “to the stake with it at once.”

The doomed manuscript was thrown into the blazing grate, and when the last vestige had disappeared, the two authors shook hands warmly. Now what do you say to this; was it a failure? Yes, the story was a failure, no doubt, but it was that sort of failure that made these men good writers.

It is said by a certain writer, “Every failure is a step to success; every detection of what is false directs toward what is true; every trial exhausts some tempting form of error. Not only so, but scarcely any attempt is entirely a failure; scarcely any theory, the result of steady thought, is altogether false.”

Another writer says that when you have failed in any undertaking, the best way is not to recognize the fact. Indeed, to a brave man there is no such thing as failure. He is simply knocked down, and gets up and goes at it again. He knows it is no disgrace to make a big mistake, or a hundred of them. He tries again, and does the best he can as long as he lives. Even when a whole life seems to have been a failure, a wise man will know better. “If we read history, we will find that the failures have really advanced the world more than the successes. Columbus was a failure, Galileo was a failure, Savonarola was a failure. If those three men had at any time been gifted with second sight, and had seen the place they were to fill in history, it might have consoled them; but no doubt every one of them died of a broken heart, convicted in his own mind of failure.”

What is a failure? Not to do the best you can, is a failure. To dodge the work that belongs to you, is a failure. To get ahead of your neighbor by unfair means, or in any way to gain a point dishonorably, is the meanest kind of failure. Mistakes, misfortunes, accidents—don’t count against you; these happen to the best men; but a failure in pluck or in honesty—a failure in manhood, is something to cry over.—Treasure-Trove.