If the following canine story, published in the St. Nicholas, be true, one would conclude that the dog referred to in the narrative could count, or else that he possessed some other remarkable trait which enabled him to discern that one of the drove was missing. Is it not possible that he made the discovery in the same manner that we miss one from the family group? Is it by count that we miss father or mother, brother or sister, or any familiar face from the home circle? How is it with the dog? Can the readers of the INSTRUCTOR tell? The story reads:—
“Old Fetch was a shepherd dog that lived in the Highlands of the Hudson. His master kept nearly a dozen cows, and they ranged at will among the hills during the day. When the sun was low in the west, his master would say to his dog, ‘Bring the cows home;’ and it was because the dog did this task so well, that he was called Fetch. He would run to a flat rock and hold his ear down close to it, having learned that he could thus catch the far off tinkle of the cow-bells better than any other way. If he could not hear them, he would range about until he did, and then he was off like a shot in the direction of the sound.
“One sultry day he departed as usual upon his evening task. From scattered, shady, and grassy nooks, he at last gathered all the cattle into a mountain road, leading to the distant barnyard.
“One of the cows was known to be a little perverse, and on that evening she gave fresh evidence of willfulness. A part of the road ran through a low, moist spot bordered by a thicket of black alder, into which this cow pushed her way, and stood quietly. The others passed on, followed some distance in the rear by Fetch.
“As the cows approached the barnyard gate, he quickened his pace, and hurried forward, as if to say, ‘I’m here, attending to business.’ But his complacency was disturbed as the cows filed through the gate. He whined a little, and growled a little, attracting his master’s attention. Then he went to the high fence surrounding the yard, and standing on his hind feet peered between two of the rails. After looking at the herd carefully for a time, he started off down the road again on a full run. His master now observed that one of the cows was missing, and he sat down on a rock to see what Fetch was going to do about it. Before very long he heard the furious tinkling of a bell, and soon Fetch appeared bringing in the perverse cow at a rapid pace, hastening her on by frequently leaping up and catching her ear in his teeth. After leading the cow through the gate in a way that she did not soon forget, Fetch looked after her a moment with the air of one remarking to himself, ‘You’ll not try that trick again,’ and then he lay down quietly to cool off in time for supper.”