Some time ago I read an article in the INSTRUCTOR, in which I supposed was an error of the types, but learn that it was not so. The statement was made that in California the alder is a tree, and only a shrub in the East. I felt confident that I had seen alder trees elsewhere. Referring to Chambers' Cyclopedia, I found the alder set down as a tree thirty to sixty feet in height. Webster also calls the alder a tree. So the alder must be a tree in many parts of the world. I have seen large alder trees in California; the camp-meeting in Eureka, Humboldt county, was held in an alder grove, and the shade was abundant. On inquiry, I find many besides the writer of that article who knew the alder only as a shrub.
I supposed the writer meant the elder, as I have found no evidence that the elder is a tree outside of the Pacific slope. Nothing sooner attracts the eye of a stranger in California than an elder tree. A man told me that he picked five bushels of berries one year from an elder tree standing near his gate. It was in bloom when I saw it, and I thought five bushels not too high an estimate of its crop.
A leading newspaper in San Francisco once referred to the elder trees in California, in contrast with the elder bushes in the east, as evidence of the greater productiveness of their soil, and the influence of their climate. But that evidence is not conclusive. The buckeye grows to be a stately tree in some of the Eastern States; but in California it scarcely deserves the name of a tree. It does not grow much higher than the sumac, but it has much the same habit.
These differences can hardly be accounted for on the score of soil and climate. A tree which is abundant in one State is not found in one adjoining. The chestnut is a splendid tree in New York, Pennsylvania, this, and other States. But I never saw a native chestnut in Michigan, nor in California. On the other hand, the sassafras is a mere shrub in New York and Pennsylvania; I was much surprised on seeing sassafras logs cut for fence rails in Michigan. In the New Orleans Exposition I saw a section of a sassafras tree from Arkansas which was over four feet in diameter. Australia is noted for its large timber; and California for its “big trees.” I saw a stump of a tree which was ten paces across; and some trees are larger than that. No one who never saw them can realize their great size.
There was a certain man who “spoke of trees, from the cedar that is in Lebanon even unto the hyssop that springeth out of the wall.” It would be very interesting to read the account. Can the children of the “INSTRUCTOR family” tell who this man was, and where we learn that he wrote about the trees, and other things? J. H. WAGGONER.