MAKING A DIFFERENCE

5%

S. D. A. Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 9, 1887

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 35, No. 10.

Read the full edition

MAKING A DIFFERENCE.

We might as well feed an infant on food suitable for mature manhood, as to attempt to teach a little child by exactly the same means and methods that would best meet the wants of middle life. As we grow older, we seem strangely to forget this self-evident principle, and to imagine the child's mental and spiritual wants to be just like our own. Very few are willing to admit this, but actions speak louder than words. None but those who keep up the constant practice of communing with them can continue through life to enter into the feelings and sympathies of children; and none who have lost this adaptability can be really successful teachers of the juvenile mind. It is because of this fact, that young people often make better teachers for children than do older people, who ought to be possessed of a far better judgment, and a much riper experience. It is for this reason, too, that mothers, as a rule, are so much better teachers than men are.
In teaching, then, we must make a difference, taking into consideration the age, the advantages, the development, the associations and surroundings of every one we teach. And it is not only in teaching that this difference must be made; the same distinction must be kept in mind when we talk or write about methods of instruction.
There are some general principles that hold good in all kinds of teaching, with very little regard to age or circumstances. Such principles must of necessity, however, be very few; and is not this one reason why general dissertations are so dull and tiresome? Let us come to the point, then, at once.
A little child, if he has any lesson at all, must have it taught to him; first, because he cannot read well enough to learn it for himself; and secondly, because he cannot, unaided, hold his mind to a subject long enough to learn a lesson. Parents are the natural teachers of their own children, and especially is this true of the mother; but how often it is the case that the parents are either incapable or negligent. Then the work of instructing falls upon the teachers of the public school and the Sabbath-school.
The first time your little one comes to Sabbath-school, you will have the task—or the pastime, whichever it may prove to be—of teaching him a lesson; and it is to be hoped that you will do it well. Do not teach him formal answers to be repeated to you again, but try to impress upon his heart and mind some simple truth, illustrated by example, and accompanied by tender tones and an unfeigned interest in his welfare. Do not lay any injunctions upon him, saying, “Be sure to remember this,” or “Be sure to remember that,” but leave him free, without a feather's weight of burden upon him. If your truth has reached his heart and interested his thought, he will not easily get rid of it; it will come up in his mind many times during the coming week. If you have not hit the mark, your arrow will fall to the ground, and all your admonitions and injunctions will have no effect but to make him dislike to come again.
When he comes before you on the following Sabbath, see if you can find any trace of your former work, but not by exacting questions, nor in a way to make him feel that he is under censure for not being able to repeat what you said to him the week before; it is very possible you could not do that yourself. Your words may have made an impression that will last as long as he lives, and yet he may not be able to tell you anything about it.
Either before or after teaching the next lesson, manage adroitly and indirectly to repeat the same thoughts you gave him the week before, and do this more than once. On the next Sabbath do the same, until, seeing that nothing you teach him is ever to be dropped, he will begin to get the idea of accumulating the sweet, simple stores of truth you have been imparting to him.
By such a system of management you will in a few weeks bring him where he can be taught the lessons of Book No. 1, provided that he is of any suitable age to be sent to Sabbath-school. As soon as he can read intelligently, he can be taught to learn the lessons for himself. But this transition process must be left for other articles to describe.
Next we will take a class in what will be termed the Intermediate Department of the school. These pupils are expected to learn the lessons for themselves. They can read, and by their previous discipline have learned how to study. Crude specimens, just brought into the school at an age when they cannot be put into classes with beginners, are specialties, and must be treated as such.
The pupils of this grade should make thorough, vigorous use of the Lesson Book, and is it too much to say that the teacher should do the same? Not only should the teacher use the book in preparing the lesson, but it is our opinion that he should use it in hearing the recitation as well. Much has been said, and justly said, against the slavish use of a book or lesson paper in the recitation; but the opposite extreme is as bad in its results, if not worse. There are two very important arguments against ignoring the printed lesson in recitation.
First, the pupils, at the age referred to, ought to have the privilege of reciting the lesson they have learned. The same questions they have used in studying the lesson should be asked them in the recitation, or the same in substance at least. Of course, if a pupil should accidentally chance to answer two questions when asked but one, the teacher should not put the question that has already been answered, but should go at once to the question that touches the next point in the lesson. Again, if an answer is meagre, or shows an evident want of appreciation of the point which the question is meant to bring out, the teacher should by all means put the question in some other form, or ask several intermediate questions, trying in this way to make everything as plain as possible. But as soon as this is done, the regular questions should be resumed again.
Secondly, the average teacher is not competent to extemporize as good questions as the printed ones that have cost the most careful thought of Sabbath-school workers of long experience and mature judgment. In some instances, the questions should be varied to meet the special wants of a class, or of a pupil, but care must be taken that the unity of the lesson is not destroyed. These things do not, however, warrant the practice of dropping the printed lesson altogether, and substitute for it the stumbling, blundering, erratic experimenting of an amateur performer, who has had very little, if any, experience in dealing with minds, or subjects either, and who, perhaps, is not capable of teaching an ordinary country school.
The reasons given above ought to be sufficient, without taking into account the confusion and serious want of unity that must characterize the work of a school where the teaching is done in this way; as well as the fact that under this system no pupil can possibly know when his lesson is learned, or when he is prepared for recitation, for the reason that he can have but a very vague idea of what the recitation will be.
After the lesson has been recited once through, following in the main the printed questions, the teacher may well review it, cross-questioning, and often asking such comprehensive questions that a few of them will cover the entire lesson. This, of course, requires skill, and a beginner will make poor work of it at first; but he may gain an experience in this way, without sacrificing the plans and purposes of the lesson-writer, or losing the valuable help which ought to be afforded by the printed lesson,—the questions that have directed the minds of the class in their Bible study.
We will next consider the most advanced division of the Sabbath-school. This, with us, includes men and women in middle life,—those that formerly constituted the Bible Class, so called. Of these we must speak very guardedly, for want of experience in dealing with mature minds; but it has seemed to us, that, even in this division, the printed lesson ought to serve a better purpose than that of merely affording “something to differ from,” or furnishing a few topics for argument.
The lesson-writer might go through the advanced division of some large schools, at the time of recitation, and not be able to recognize the lesson under consideration, although he had thought hard upon it, and written it with his own hand. Scarcely a question that he had ever penned would be asked in the classes. The different classes would seem to be discussing subjects entirely incongruous in their nature, and he would wonder how they could all spring from the simple, instructive lesson which he had meant to write.
Now if the lesson is to be taken as a mere text, some teachers would do well to “stick to the text” more closely than they do. The course that is pursued makes one feel that the Bible Class has not joined the School, but that the School has joined the Bible Class. This was not the original plan; neither is it a plan that can ever result well.
But as we confess incompetency in these matters, we will let them drop, and confine ourselves to the rank and file of the school, where we are sure that lessons ought to be learned and recited, and where every different grade should have somewhat different treatment, adapted in each to that stage of advancement, and in each preparatory to the next higher;—where pupils should be taught how to help themselves to knowledge, and to think as well as to feel. The field is so broad that we can but just touch it here and there, leaving the development of parts to others, or to other articles at least.