AdventAI

It is impossible to overestimate the importance of right motives. Every act and every great work is colored by the motives that prompt it. We will not talk about the motives that should actuate the teacher. One who is fitted to take such an important trust is supposed to know that his motives should be the same that gave such sweetness and power to the Saviour’s mission on earth. At least, it should be his constant aim to cultivate such a spirit.

But the means used in gaining the attention of children, and in getting them to learn their lessons, may sometimes awaken motives that it is not wise to encourage. Pride, for instance, is a powerful motive, but a dangerous one. A child may be too proud to fall below the average recitation of his class, and for this reason may make considerable effort; but he is satisfied with the standard of his class, no matter how low that may be. It is not real excellence that he is striving for, but merely to escape the disgrace of falling below his fellows.

Another child is ambitious. He is not satisfied with an average standing, but must be first, or be miserable. It matters very little to him how poorly he does, so long as he is the hero of his class; and he takes no pleasure in doing well, so long as another equals or excels him. Such a spirit is the germ of as hateful an ambition as ever actuated an Alexander, a Cæsar, or a Bonaparte.

Now a teacher must not be too abruptly severe on such motives; for by so doing he might sink his pupil into an apathy from which it would be hard to awaken him. But these motives must be supplanted by better ones, or the child who possesses them will never be truly useful. He will never get a genuine love for Bible study in this way. When he no longer has any one to strive with, he will take no further interest in study.

What we want is to create such a relish for sacred truth that our children will come to delight in it, and form a life-long habit of searching it, to learn their duty to God and to one another. Now in order to do this, we shall have to be very careful about the motives which we stir. If we are not, we may kindle fires which will by and by burn all too fiercely, and which we shall find it impossible to quench.

A child who is moved by pride or ambition, will be tempted to use unfair means. He soon comes to care less for the truths of the lesson than he does for the name of having it. Then he will begin to study more and more with a view to the recitation, and continually less for the good he might get from the Sacred Word. In a little while, the Bible will no longer appear to him a holy book. His answers will be pert and flippant, but destitute of thought or feeling. Finally he will stoop to cheating, rather than fail of gaining the coveted standing in his class. He will, if he can, get a sly peep at his book, whenever he fears it may be necessary; and almost invariably he will study the lesson very diligently just before coming to the recitation, but drop the entire subject from his mind as soon as the recitation is over.

But one of the worst results from these unworthy motives is that of leading the child to take more pleasure in the failure of his fellows than he does in their success. This result is sure to follow; for the standard of the ambitious pupil is a relative one, and the lower his classmates fall, the higher he stands above them. How contrary such a spirit is to the Bible precept, “In honor preferring one another”!

The “Class Record” is a good thing; but it may be so used as to foster pride and ambition. It seems to me that as soon as the class record is in any way made public, it operates powerfully in this direction. For this reason I believe it should never appear in any way that can create rivalry among classes, or among the members of a class. The teacher should keep the record to himself, only so far as it becomes necessary to have it transferred to the Secretary’s book in making out the general report of the school, or to submit it to the inspection of those officers who may thus be enabled better to understand the condition of the school, and to render assistance to the teachers. This general use of the records does not set one class at strife with another, nor one pupil in competition with another; but on the other hand, it unites all in a common effort for the general reputation and good of the whole school.

We feel compelled to remonstrate against the custom of publicly reporting the amount of money donated by each class. Such a custom can hardly fail of creating a spirit of rivalry among the classes. With such a spirit in our schools, the best effect of giving is lost. True feelings of generosity are smothered, or crushed out by the cruel usurpers—pride and ambition. The custom is contrary to the teachings of the Saviour, who showed that the value of a gift depends, not upon the amount given, but upon the motive, and upon the degree of sacrifice which the gift requires.

Besides all this, it is an unfair custom. The members of one class may be mostly from rich families, while those of another may be mostly very poor; but the public display of the record makes no allowance for these circumstances. In a case of this kind the poor class would naturally suffer from discouragement, or smart under a sense of the injustice of being thrust into hopeless competition with the rich; but the greater harm would undoubtedly come to the class that might be puffed up with self-satisfaction and a feeling of superiority when they had not in the sight of Heaven given half as much as the other class. But one may say, “Such a case could not occur, because the poor invariably give more than the rich.” Very well, then the system induces the poor to give more than they are able to give, and makes the rich satisfied with giving far too little.

We would not say that none but the very highest motives should ever be employed; but we should certainly use the highest that can be made to take any effect; and it is better to wait a little for the good effect of higher motives, than to reach immediate results by appealing to motives that are somewhat questionable. A good character, like the oak, strikes its roots too deeply to make an instant display upon the surface; and many who might be among the noblest of earth pass entirely unrecognized. Let us remember the injunction, “See thou hurt not the oil and the wine.”