AdventAI

QUEER THEORIES CONCERNING EARTHQUAKES.

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 35, No. 19., May 11, 1887

In the course of a lecture delivered recently before the Rigaku Kyokai, or Science Society, of Tokio, on the causes of earthquakes, Prof. Milne classified the theories as to the cause of these phenomena into three kinds—unscientific, quasi-scientific, and scientific. Modern-science theories occupied the main part of the lecture, but we will follow him only in the two former ones.

In the first class, the unscientific, he included the explanations of the negro preachers of Charleston after the late earthquakes there, that they occurred in consequence of the wickedness of the population. The Mussulmans of Java recently prayed to the volcanoes there to cease their shakings, at the same time promising reformation of life.

That earthquakes are the direct result of man's wickedness is an idea that has always been common. About 1750, earthquakes were felt in many parts of Europe, which were widely attributed to that cause, and innumerable sermons were preached, inculcating the lesson that if mankind would live better lives there would be no more earthquakes. In 1786, after a shock at Palermo, the people are recorded to have gone about scourging themselves, looking extremely humble and penitent.

The Professor then passed on to the myths which attribute earthquakes to a creature living underground. In Japan it is an “earthquake insect” covered with scales, having eight legs; or a great fish having a certain rock on his head which helped to keep him quiet. In Mongolia the animal was said to be a frog; in India, the world-bearing elephant; in the Celebes, a world-supporting hog; in North America, a tortoise. In Siberia there was a myth, connected with the great bones found there, that these were the remains of animals that lived underground, the trampling of which made the ground shake. In Kamchatka the legend was connected with a god, Tull, who went out hunting with his dogs. When the latter went out to scratch themselves, their movements produced earthquakes. In Scandinavian mythology Loki, having killed his brother Baldwin, was bound to a rock, face upward, so that the poison of a serpent should drop on his face. Loki's wife, however, intercepted the poison in a vessel, and it was only when she had to go away to empty the dish, that a few drops reached him, causing him to writhe and shake the earth.

The lecturer had no means of collecting the fables of the southern hemisphere, but they would be worth knowing for comparison. As to quasi-scientific theories, these endeavored to account for earthquakes as parts of the ordinary operations of nature. It was supposed, for instance, that they were produced by the action of wind confined inside the earth. The Chinese philosophers said that Yang, the male element, entered the earth and caused it to expand and shake the ground in its efforts to escape. Its effects would be more violent beneath the mountains than in the plains, and therefore earthquakes in the north of China, which was mountainous, were said to be more violent than those in the south. It was supposed that when the wind was blowing strongly on the surface of the earth there was calm beneath, and vice versa. Aristotle and many other classical writers attributed earthquakes to wind in the earth.

Then comes the theory of electrical discharges, which was advocated in 1760 by Dr. Stukely, as well as by Percival and Priestley. This theory is held by some in California at the present time,—that the network of rails protected the State against any dangerous accumulation of electricity. But Mr. Milne showed that the laying down of rails in Japan did not have that effect. He thought the electric phenomena which sometimes attended earthquakes were their consequences, not their causes. Earth currents unquestionably accompany earthquakes, but, as has been said, they appear to be the consequences, not the causes of the latter.

Next came the chemical theories, which were very strong in Europe up to the beginning of the present century. It was imagined that under the ground were certain substances, such as sulphur, niter, vitriol, which, by their action upon each other, resulted in violent changes, giving rise to vapor, the sudden production of which, in certain cases, would shake the ground.

It was not until 1760 that Dr. Mitchell, who wrote a good deal on the subject, first threw out the theory that earthquakes were connected in some way with volcanoes, because they were most frequent in volcanic countries. He observed that large quantities of steam were given off from volcanoes, and came to the conclusion that an earthquake was produced at the time that an attempt was made to form a volcano; that steam got in between certain strata, and, as it ran between them, caused pulsations. Prof. Rogers, about the same time, in North America, endeavored to show that it was steam.—Nature.