Some years ago I visited a Sabbath-school where all was promptness and punctuality. Everything was conducted in due form, and yet one could not help feeling that there was a lack of depth in the work. No one could say that the questions were not correctly answered, but the lesson did not seem to have taken hold upon the hearts of those who were so glibly reciting it. To this rule, however, there was an exception. A class of elderly people had been set apart as a kind of “invalid corps” because they could not come up to the rigid requirements that the superintendent supposed to be indispensable to thoroughness. They liked the Sabbath-school very much, took great delight in the lessons, enjoyed the success of others, but said that, study as hard as they might, they could not remember the texts that were required of them.
Now it so happened that the writer was asked to teach this very class, on that particular Sabbath. On coming before the class, he was met by the entreaty that he would not ask them the questions, but talk to them about the lesson, giving them all the light he could upon it. All claimed that they had not learned the lesson, but that they had studied much, and had been much benefited by it. One said, “We are so glad to see you, but we are sorry you have been sent to teach our class, and thus find out how poorly we can do.” Another said, “We have heard how thorough you are, and we never can recite to you.” Another, “We have read what you write about giving a synopsis of the lesson, and we can never do that. But I hope you will not think we do not study the lesson.” As this kind of pleading went on, nearly every one in the class was moved to tears. The teacher, too, found it more than he could do to keep his voice from trembling, or hide the moisture that would come to his eyes. Every kindly assurance was given, and extreme leniency was promised. By this means, nearly all the members were induced to try, and the recitation began.
The lesson was introduced in a very incidental way, by asking questions that people at that age would be very likely to answer with ease, and which would not require the repetition of passages of Scripture. The interest manifested in the lesson was surprising. The embarrassment was soon forgotten. It was evident that these people had been thinking on the subject of the lesson. They had drunk deeply of the true spirit which the subject was calculated to inspire. The beaming countenance, the light in the eye, the tone of the voice,—all showed that it was not the mind only, but the heart as well, that was stirred by the truths before them. Illustrative passages, not required by the lesson, came up fresh and new; when they could not repeat the exact words, they knew where to find and read them in their Bibles. Their enjoyment was all the more sweet because so unexpected, and their generous warmth of enthusiasm would have touched a less sympathetic heart than that of the teacher then before them. Whether this quickening of thought strengthened their memory, or whether the Spirit of God came in to help them, may never be known; but certain it is that nearly all the passages required by the lesson were repeated, with none but the most trifling errors. But this was hardly the best of it; for in many instances they could tell the substance, if not the exact words, of all that preceded and followed these passages. They knew the circumstances under which these words were spoken, as far as these conditions are to be known from the Bible alone. They had meditated on these things years before the lessons were written. They also gave a most satisfactory synopsis,—one of the best we ever listened to. The teacher started in first, to show about what was expected, after which it was carried on with a fullness and a zest seldom witnessed.
And yet these veterans thought they ought to be mustered out of the service because they could not give verbatim recitations with all the glibness of the young people who had but little thought or feeling beyond the mere words of the text. These men and women, who really knew more about the lesson than all the rest of the school put together, were content to have their recitations marked imperfect, and regard themselves a failure in the school, simply because their memory was becoming a little treacherous. Their case did not seem to be understood by the officers of the school, who were carrying out faithfully their own ideas of thoroughness. These officers were not wrong in requiring what they did of the younger members; but if these elderly people were to be a part of the school, there was need of closer discrimination in regard to what kind of recitation should be required of them.
A little judicious cross-questioning at the time of general exercises, will show who has a good understanding of the subject of the lesson, and thus will not only encourage the aged, but at the same time tend to cure the conceit of those who find it easy to carry words in the memory, simply because to them they are not burdened with any weight of meaning.
The writer has conducted thousands of recitations, but that described above is among the most satisfactory of them all. Its memory will never fade, and the pleasure it gave has been enjoyed over and over again, times without number.
Showy work is not apt to be deep work. We must learn to look below the surface, and encourage earnest thinking. The letter is good, but the spirit is better; and while both are desirable, we should always regard the latter as of the greater importance. Form should never take precedence of the thing represented by it.
From the incident related above we may learn that the most difficult work is not always the most thorough or the most important. The kind of recitation which they so much enjoyed was far more profitable to them than the one which they dreaded could have been. It was far more thorough than the younger members could have borne. The best and most thorough work is that which brings the greatest good to those concerned,—a work which does not go beyond their powers, but which gives genial and vigorous exercise to those powers, and turns them in the direction of future improvement. G. H. BELL.