What conflicting opinions prevail on the subject of Sabbath-school lessons! The same lesson is often praised by one and condemned by another in the same school. The very mail that brings to the lesson writer letters of commendation and congratulation may bring plenty of fault-finding as well. Perhaps we ought not to call it fault-finding; for those who complain of the lessons undoubtedly think them ill-adapted to their wants.
These difficulties arise partly from the varied conditions of schools and pupils, and the impossibility of suiting any lesson to the needs of every person who may want to study it. But there should be an effort at adaptation on both sides. When the writer has done his best to accommodate the lessons to varied classes of learners, the learners should in turn endeavor to accommodate themselves to the lessons. If the lesson is too short, the more time may be spent in reviewing past work. If it is too long, a little extra time and effort will make it all right. The lesson that is too long for me may be too short for some one else. The peculiarities that displease me may be admired by my neighbor. If there are weak questions, they need not especially trouble us. If any of the questions seem blind, a little more study on the whole subject may make them plain. A generous, appreciative spirit will give us the highest enjoyment of every excellence, and lessen our discomfort at the imperfections we may find.
If any one discovers serious defects in the lessons, or difficulties which proper effort cannot overcome, he should confer kindly but freely with the lesson writer or with those who have the matter of the lessons in charge. No one can be so anxious to have the lessons just right as the lesson writer ought to be. But habitual fault-finding will soon create a spirit that the best of lessons, with the best of teachers, cannot overcome. Let the sentiment once spread through a school that the lessons are unworthy, and the interest of that school is destroyed. If we watch for faults, we may find them in our best friends; and if duly encouraged, this faculty of seeing faults will become so sharp that almost everything will appear in a bad light. Just so it is with the fault-finding spirit towards teachers or lessons.
But real difficulties do arise in teaching the lessons; and it is of those difficulties that we wish to speak. The lessons used among our children are called “progressive,” and they were meant to be so in reality. The writer evidently intended that they should increase in difficulty, gradually but certainly, from the beginning to the end. This is necessary in order to meet the wants of the ever-expanding mind of the child. Otherwise lessons become insipid and ineffective because they do not call the powers of thought into vigorous, healthy action.
But in order that such lessons may be just suited to the wants of a child, he must at the proper age begin at the beginning, be thorough in his work, and continue it without interruption. But if the child has poor lessons for a time, if he attends irregularly, or if the teacher fails in thoroughness, the lessons that would otherwise be a delight soon become too hard, and are looked upon with dread. Children are frequently too proud to be put back, and sometimes the parents share in the same feeling. What is to be done? To meet the wants of such children, the book would have to be revised every month, and it would soon be spoiled for all who are doing regular work.
Again, new pupils sometimes come into school with very little knowledge of any part of the Bible. They are too old to be put with little ones at the beginning of Book No. 1, or at least they would feel humiliated by being put there; and if they are put in classes with those of their own age, they not only find the lesson too difficult, but they are wholly unable to answer questions in review.
Letters often come in from superintendents who find that the children in their schools have been allowed to go on carelessly until they are wholly incapable of mastering the lessons in the grade where they now stand. Such children are unwilling to be put back. If they are asked to take up No. 2 or No. 3 again, they say, “Why, we’ve been over that;” but they can remember almost nothing at all of what they learned there, or pretended to learn. What shall be done in such a case?
Many are ready to say that the right thing to do in the last instance would be to put all these classes back where they belong,—where the lessons are not too long for them,—and allow them to go no faster than they will go thoroughly. But whether this can be done or not depends upon the attitude of the parents and the degree of influence which the superintendent is able to exercise. Very few superintendents can succeed in striking out wholly against the sentiment of the school; but by judicious management and steady faithfulness he may change the sentiment, and bring it more nearly where it should be. It may be that the children can after a little time be made to see that it is for their interest to go back, and that it is the most honorable thing they can do under the circumstances. If not, leave them where they are, divide each lesson into two, require the most complete thoroughness, and ask easy review questions very frequently.
It seems to us that new pupils should, so far as consistent, be examined somewhat on their knowledge of the Bible before being classified. If they are found to be far behind others of their age, do not try to put them back to the beginning, unless there should be enough of them for a class, but put them back part way,—as far as you can without giving them any cause for offense or discouragement. Those who have from any cause fallen behind their grade should perhaps be treated somewhat on the same principle; but they can be treated more thoroughly because their case need not run so far before being corrected.
But what will do most toward effecting a permanent cure for these evils is to cultivate a correct sentiment in the school. Let it be felt by all that the highest point of honor is to be thorough, to be free from all sham or pretense, not to be satisfied with a weekly standing merely, but to aim at a thorough knowledge of all they have passed over, so that they may review with ease and facility at any time, and find real delight in the exercise. Show how beautiful and harmonious the Bible story is, how the Lord has led his people down through the history of the world, and what admirable lessons he has taught us by their experience. Such a spirit in a school will nearly overcome all the lesson difficulties that have been mentioned.
Com.