NEEDLESS ILLUSTRATIONS

11%

S. D. A. Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 3, 1887

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 35, No. 31.

Read the full edition

NEEDLESS ILLUSTRATIONS.

We cannot better introduce the subject than by the following selection from the S. S. Times:—
“How much real ability is wasted in the accomplishment of unnecessary tasks! Matthew Claudius tells, with quiet humor, how wonderfully clever his university professor was—so clever that he would demonstrate to his class in half a minute, that a student is not a rhinoceros; ‘for if any student were a rhinoceros, some rhinoceros must be a student; but we know that no rhinoceros is a student, therefore it is clear that no student is a rhinoceros.’ This was demonstration indeed; but a good many besides Matthew Claudius have wondered what the demonstration was worth after it was made. There are not a few reasoners intellectually akin to that professor, in the pulpit, in the theological chair, in the Sunday-school. They can demonstrate—oh, so cleverly—a thousand things which nobody ever dreamed of denying; they can occupy the larger part of a church or Sunday-school session, in showing that there is much reason to believe that goodness is better than wickedness, and that truth is truer than falsehood. But is it not a pity that so much talent, wasted in proving what does not need to be proved, should not be turned into some more useful channel?”
It is probable that the greatest fault with regard to illustrations is that they are not used as often as they are needed, or that they are not well chosen; but there are some who are perpetually illustrating what is entirely plain in itself. Such illustrations do positive harm. The mind has no need of them, and becomes weary by having them thrust in its way.
To this class of illustrations belong those fanciful arrangements of words upon the blackboard that have a common initial, or of sentences that have the same initial word. Such arrangements, with a display of large initials, may serve to catch the attention of careless children gathered in from the streets of a mission school, but it can serve no purpose in bringing out the real thought of the lesson, or impressing the thought of a moral. There is no doubt that such an unusual form of grouping the words may be longer remembered, but they are remembered merely as words. The thought or sentiment they express is not retained, if indeed it was ever received at all. What would be thought of a teacher who should attempt to teach grammar, arithmetic, or history in this manner? It is a good thing to get the eye and the ear of the children, but even this is often done without reaching the intellect or the heart. Many teachers are deceived just here. They really think they are teaching when they are doing scarcely more than to amuse. Now it is much better to do this than not to gain the attention at all; but the permanent good accomplished will be small, unless our pupils are made to think and feel. Unfortunately many of the methods so successful in gaining the attention lead the mind away from the thought instead of preparing it to receive the things we ought to teach. Whatever does not lead the mind hinders it. We should remember that gaining the attention is a means to an end, and not the end itself.
But what we wish to especially impress is that a greater share of these illustrations are needless, and that in teaching, everything needless is positively injurious.
Some teachers make a hobby of charting every lesson on the blackboard. There are complicated subjects that can undoubtedly be made plainer in this way; for although every analysis in order to be valuable must be mental, the marking on the blackboard aids the undisciplined mind in taking a bird's eye view of the entire subject. But to take a narrative as simple as that of the boy in the apple tree, and chart it out before a school, is sheer nonsense. It is not only an unnecessary work, but one that does harm. It soon makes the mind too indolent to retain anything that is not set before the eye, and so in the end defeats the very purpose it is intended to serve. It is an excellent thing to train the mind to comprehend the important divisions of a subject, and to trace clearly the relation of all the subordinate parts to one another and to the leading one. But in order to do this work successfully, the mind must gradually be trained to comprehend and hold these relations from the nature of the thoughts themselves and to retain these relations without the aid of marks.
Thus we have noticed only one or two of the many features of the subject introduced in the heading of this article. More may be brought out at another time.
G. H. B.