The Way of a Modern Reformer.
By M. E. K.
When Mr. Theodore Roosevelt, commissioner of police for New York City, first started on his present course to reform the police, and through their efforts the morals of that city, almost every one regarded him as a Puritan of the severest morality. When an officer of the law ascends to that majestic height that he will not allow a descendant of Abraham to sell shoe-strings on Sunday, and prevents icemen from delivering ice for the benefit of sick children on the same day, we naturally expect to find that man without any sympathy for anything approaching a departure from what is now denominated as “civic righteousness.” But Mr. Roosevelt has suddenly developed a surprising degree of consideration for the prize-ring. He has not backslidden; he tells us that he has always favored the ring. Not that he favors indiscriminate slugging by men of low order, but he holds that two gentlemen, for purely athletic purposes, may enter a ring under the auspices of some athletic society, and with five-ounce gloves pound each other to their hearts’ content. Mr. Roosevelt himself graces these occasions with his presence, and applauds the hard hits. He says that he used to indulge in such sport himself while in college. This is probably the reason that he approves of it. What Mr. Roosevelt has done must surely be right for others to do. He never sold shoe-strings on Sunday, therefore that cannot be allowed; he has taken part in prize-ring contests before an applauding audience, therefore that must be right. From the Roosevelt and reform standpoint there is no escaping this logic. What he would do is right; what others would do that he would not do is wrong. Speaking of logic, Mr. Roosevelt sustains prize-ring fighting by a logic as remarkable as his own course as police commissioner. He knows that men are often killed in these brutal shows; in fact, the killing of Pugilist Duffy called forth his report, in which he justifies these contests by the following would-be ingenious comparison: “On the day after the first frosts this year there were reported in the papers thirteen deaths of skaters by drowning, but that did not mean that we ought to give up skating.” Now the difference between skating and fighting with gloves is very obvious. No person goes skating expecting to get hurt or to hurt any one else. If one is hurt, it is purely accidental. When a pugilist enters a ring with gloves, he expects to get hurt himself, and intends, if possible, to hurt his antagonist worse than he is hurt himself. Again, if a person who goes skating was as sure of getting his head thumped on the ice as the man in the prize-ring is sure of getting his head thumped by the fist of his antagonist, skating would be forbidden by law. A man who is so constituted morally that he regards the sale of shoe-strings on Sunday as dangerous to the morals of society, and, after having committed the doer of this terrible crime to the police court and the criminal’s cell, can then, with a serene and happy mind, witness a prize-ring fight, and justify it on the high ground that he has taken part in such sports himself and was benefited by them, certainly presents a combination of qualities which would have added grace to the high office of an inquisitor-general of ancient times. When the most honest actions are considered to be crimes, and punished; and brutality equal to the bull-fights of Spain is honored and protected by our officers of the law, who pose as moral reformers, we may well be alarmed for fear that the glory of true liberty has departed from our land, and that a pious-appearing but cruel and bigoted despotism is fast being enthroned in the temple of American liberty.