It is sometimes almost painful to witness the attempts of those who were themselves among the foremost in the great Advent movement of 1840-44, to entirely repudiate that movement as being of God. The following from the Voice of the West, whose editor was one of the great leaders in that work, illustrates this point:
“Some are puzzled by a specious plea that because God blessed the early Advent movement, therefore the prophetic periods must then have been correctly understood. This fallacious reasoning has deceived some. The same argument, however, would prove the immortality of the soul, because God blessed the great Wesleyan revival in England under men who believed it; transubstantiation, because God blessed the labors of Luther, who held to, and contended for, that error, in the great Reformation that shook the very throne of the ‘Man of Sin.’”
Whatever there may be of “fallacious reasoning” in connection with the above, is certainly on the part of the Voice. The cases cited are not parallel with the Advent movement, and the comparisons, therefore, are not good. There is a great difference between being blessed for an item of religious belief and being blessed in that belief, or while entertaining it; and that difference must be apparent between the cases cited above, and that of the Advent proclamation.
What was the great burden of the Wesleyan revival in England? Was it to teach the immortality of the soul? And was the preaching of this doctrine the means of bringing about that revival? By no means. While this error was among the incidentals of Wesley’s belief, the preaching of Christ and his gospel was the means of saving souls; and the blessing from God experienced by those engaged in the work was not because they believed in the immortality of the soul, but because, even while holding that belief, they labored for the salvation of their fellow-men.
And so of the great Reformation. The cry that “shook the very throne of the ‘Man of Sin,’” was not “transubstantiation,” but “justification by faith.” And this was the message that God blessed, and was