CHANGE VERSUS IMPROVEMENT.
By M. B. C.
WASHINGTON IRVING says that, as soon as a Yankee becomes of age, he makes up his mind to settle in life, which means to begin his wanderings. If Irving lived now, I wonder what words the great satirist would use to express his contempt for our national characteristic—our mania for change. There is little about our nation, except the Constitution, which has not radically changed. Indeed, were it not that the Constitution seems almost sacred to American hearts, it would probably have lost much more than it has of the strength and vigor which Jefferson gave it. We see this restlessness in all the avocations of life; and if it were only confined to secular affairs, we might not regard it with so much alarm. But when the mania for constant improvement—i. e., change—breaks out in our Sabbath-schools, we feel constrained to “cry aloud, and spare not.” Why, it has reached such a pass that every time I enter a Sabbath-school, I feel on the tip-toe of expectation to find out what wonderful improvement has been taxing the ingenious minds of the officers since they last met. Of course we should not stagnate; we should not get so deeply into a rut that it is impossible to get out. But on the other hand, a school should be very careful to avoid a nervous restlessness, a longing for the stimulus afforded by change. “But we must keep up the interest of the children,” perhaps you say. If the children cannot be made so infatuated with the beautiful stories of the Bible that their interest will remain unabated from week to week, I hardly see what good will come of their attending Sabbath-school at all. It used to be a very general practice in day schools to offer prizes and rewards of merit for good behavior and diligence in study. But eminent educators, the world over, have cried down the practice as a malevolent evil; for if scholars do not learn from motives of love for study and interest in school work, it will profit them but little; indeed, it will be a positive injury to commit lessons by heart simply for the honor of gaining a prize in the end. If such practices are prolific of pernicious results in day schools, how much more so in Sabbath-schools, where the children should meet for the sole purpose of studying the Sacred Word of God! Everything like emulation should be sedulously avoided. The children should be made to comprehend that a poor lesson, indifferently recited, is a disrespect to God. All sorts of parade are but so many stumbling-blocks in the way of the children. All popular innovations but bury the original object of the school so deeply beneath the evolutions and maneuverings, that one begins to wonder what the original object of the school was. If you have any real improvement to make, make it, in God’s name; but remember that the Sabbath-school is not a proper place to make experiments, and that improvement is not a synonym for change. M. B. C.