IN our last number we had much to say on the matter of Sunday laws, and yet we wish to say a word further, briefly stating our position:—
1. We do not oppose Sunday laws because we do not believe Sunday to be a sacred day. We would oppose a Sabbath law just as strenuously and persistently were it proposed to legalize Saturday. God’s cause does not need the power of the civil arm to carry it forward. God’s institutions, the observance of which is due to him, do not need the secular power to promote, preserve, or protect them. The religion of Christ can stand alone. He has promised, and will vouchsafe according to that promise, all power in heaven and in earth, if need be, to those who will labor in his way and will believe his promises.
2. We do not oppose Sunday laws because we are observers of the seventh day. We have consistently and persistently opposed them in the past, whether granted exemption or not, and we will continue to show the intrinsic evil of such legislation, and the wrong principles on which it is based. We ask no exemption from a law which is based on wrong principles. It is of itself evil. The only just exemption from such a law is exemption for all; that is, such a law should not exist.
3. Those who talk about protecting men in the observance of a day of rest are deceived in regard to what is needed. Every man in this broad land may observe Sunday as holily as he can, and the law, outside of Sunday legislation, will protect him in that observance. The seventh-day Sabbath has no place in the civil law above that of other days, yet the seventh-day observers keep it as faithfully, and, according to their opponents, better than first-day people generally keep Sunday. The laws of all our states, we believe, guard well the right of worship. If one lose his situation because he observes the day, well; conviction, conscience, and duty are worth more than wages; and if it went so far as even to include starvation, it were better to die in a good cause than to prosper in a bad one. He who would stultify conscience in such a matter would do it in others also if there were no danger of detection. And, besides, there are few employers who would turn off a faithful man for such a cause. The argument is the last one Christians should use, in view of the teachings of Christ.
4. The enforced Sunday-law idleness is often a thousand times worse than the labor. Men now can rest and worship God on the first day of the week without a law if they desire, and no law can compel them to do otherwise. But many of those who have no conscience in the matter are better at work; they commit less sin at labor than they would to be idle with vicious companionship. To such a class the Sunday law would prove a curse instead of a blessing.
5. A Sunday law limits the freedom of the Sunday keeper; for he may afterward be convinced that it is his duty to observe the sixth day or seventh day and work the first day. But there faces him the very law that he helped to place upon the statute book, and which he cannot transgress without becoming a criminal, although he may be a better man than before. We desire to save him from his own folly.
6. The Sunday keeper and Sabbath keeper have equal rights before God, each to observe his own day as a holy day, and this is just and proper. But the Sunday law demands that after the Sabbath keeper has rested one day to his God, he shall give another out of regard to his neighbor’s religion. He is thus taxed one-sixth of his time, or sixteen and two-thirds per cent of his income, in order to honor by law a religious institution in which he does not believe. Is this justice?
7. The law asked, however shrewdly the asking may be worded,—is always and ever for the religious institution. It is not the man, or the physical rest, or the sanitary regulation, or the temperance measure, or the poor workingman; it is the day, the religious day. A law protecting the day does not protect the men or the classes opposed to the day. We believe in protecting and conserving the rights of all men and women. Institutions of religion should be left solely with God and the devotees of the religion.
8. Such a law is diametrically opposed to the Golden Rule as stated by Christ. It is not doing by others as we would that others should do by us if circumstances were reversed. The matter is not a question of numbers or of majorities. It is a question of conscience and of right. The observance of the Sabbath lies wholly between man and his God. Doubtless it would be good for all to rest and worship on one certain day of the week, which we will not now argue, but that is no reason why civil law should enforce rest. It is doubtless good for all to be Christians, to be baptized, to come to the Lord’s table in communion, but that is no reason why law should enforce these things. They are beyond the purview of human government, and so also is Sabbath legislation. The only Sabbath law is that the day shall be kept “holy.” Only he who is holy can keep the day holy. But as law cannot makep. 3 man holy, it has no right to even attempt to enforce the divine law. In God’s sight Sabbath “desecration” is a matter of the heart and life, and not of mere outward deed. To compel the outward deed, contrary to the motive and animus of the life, is to make men hypocritical and to harden them in sin. That there is law against murder and theft is no argument; for the law in this case is not to make men good, but to protect the rights of others. How we observe Sunday or the Sabbath, however, if equal rights of others are not contravened, is not a matter between man and man but between man and God.
9. Our contention is against all legislation in behalf of religion or religious institutions. That good men, earnest men, God-fearing men, are in this movement, we freely admit, men who are actuated by unselfish motives, but are led by wrong principles. And herein lies the danger. All this present demand for legislation—municipal and state—seems to many reasonable, mild, and tolerant, because good men are in it, and so did legislation in the first centuries; but the first step necessitated the second, and the second the third, till the world found itself in the midnight of the Dark Ages, and the best of its blood was poured out an offering to the demon of religio-political legislation. Popular Christianity is making the same demands to-day, is moving forward in the same course, as it did in the fourth century. Legislators and judges are blinded by religious persecution and prejudice; bigotry holds sway in our churches; and the chains of tyranny are being forged in this land to bind liberty as she was bound in the Dark Ages. These chains were dissolved by the best blood of our fathers. Will the people—will Christians, will men—consent—not to say seek—to forge and bind them again on the free men and women of America? What will California do in this matter? M. C. W.