AdventAI

ILLEGALITY OF THE CONDEMNATION OF CHRIST.

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 24., June 20, 1895

Dr. Hamburger, a prominent Jewish rabbi of Germany, has written a book entitled “Jesus of Nazareth,” in which he takes occasion to dispute the New Testament records of the cause of the persecution and execution of Christ. The author denies that Jesus was a victim of his opposition to the religious doctrines of the Jewish priesthood. But in showing that it was impossible to have him put to death on the ground of blasphemy, or on religious grounds of any kind, he, no doubt unwittingly, emphasizes the wickedness of the Jewish council in their illegal proceedings. He seems to imagine the council incapable of an illegal act, and cites a number of points in the proceedings, as recorded in the Gospels, that were illegal according to Jewish law. We quote as follows from an extract translated for the Literary Digest:—

“It would have been impossible to sentence the Christ to death on such grounds. According to Talmudic law, the only blasphemy punishable by death consisted in uttering Jehovah’s name with an accompaniment of curses, that is, cursing the Almighty. Mishner Sanhedrin, VII, 5. But Jesus is not accused of having done this. If Jesus called himself God, and this was misunderstood, he nevertheless could not be punished for it, as the mortal nature of all men is so evident that it is not necessary to find punishment for one who calls himself divine. Sanhedrin S., 61 b. Besides, Christ recites the Jewish articles of faith, recognizes God as his God and the God of his ancestors, and this alone should have been sufficient to free him from the accusation of having called himself God or God’s Son in an anti-Jewish sense. Mark 12: 29, 30. The charge of blasphemy could not possibly be proved against him, and the traditional account of his trial does not agree with the requirements of the Talmudic Code. A charge of blasphemy could only be preferred before a full conclave of the Sanhedrin, which numbered seventy-two members, and formed the highest court in all secular and religious disputes. Gemara Sanhedrin S., 61 b. The case could only be heard in the temple and in the daytime (15² Rashi Sanhedrin S., 41 a), could only lead to a conviction and sentence on the following day (Misna Sanhedrin, IV, 1, Gemara Sanhedrin, 32); and the verdict could not be published before three more days had passed, to allow time for the defense. But even if the sin of blasphemy had been committed, no sentence could be pronounced, and, more than that, no charge could be preferred against the accused unless the witnesses deposed under oath that the accused persisted in his blasphemy after having been warned three times. The Jews extended this clause to all other capital crimes, and this led to a practical exclusion of death sentences, especially as the sentence had to be executed by the witnesses. In conclusion it must be mentioned that nobody could be sentenced upon his own assertions, as the Jewish law allowed for suicidal intentions and melancholia. Maimonides Sanhedrin, XVIII, 6. All the requirements of the case as cited here are wanting in the evangelical accounts. The judges did not sit in open court in determining upon such cases of blasphemy, being desirous to prevent a public repetition of that blasphemy. The accused had to make his statements before the lawyers ere he was confronted with the tribunal. Tosephta Sanhedrin, X, 11.”

The believer in the New Testament records will not be shaken by the fact that they show up the wicked conspiracy of the Jewish rulers and expose the illegality of their acts under pretense of judicial trial. But this new apologist’s presentation of the Jewish law only emphasizes what Christians already knew, that every step in the proceedings by which the Son of God was condemned and executed was glaringly illegal and infamously cruel—the result of pride, jealousy, and hatred. Christ himself had foretold the event (Matt. 20: 18, 19; Mark 10: 33, 34; Luke 18: 31-33), and Peter, who had been an eyewitness, speaking by direct interpretation of the Holy Spirit, charges the crime of killing the Prince of life to the Jews (Acts 2: 22, 23; 3: 13-15). The fact that the acts charged to the Jewish council were illegal is not evidence that the charge is unfounded, and Dr. Hamburger’s defense will but magnify their guilt in the minds of all who choose to believe the word of God.