LIMIT OF OBEDIENCE TO CIVIL GOVERNMENT.
By W. A. Colcord
WHILE we have seen that civil governments have no right to attempt to enforce those things even which God himself has commanded to be observed as religious duties, another important fact remains to be stated, and that is that when these governments not only enter the realm of religion, and assume to legislate upon men’s duty to God, but enact laws directly contrary to the express commands of God, men are under no obligation whatever to obey such laws. Why this is so is evident. We are God’s first. He created us, and therefore he has first claims upon us. This truth is well expressed by James Madison in his “Remonstrance” against an attempt to establish religion and enforce religious instruction upon the people in the state of Virginia during the latter part of the eighteenth century. He said:— It is the duty of every man to render to the Creator such homage, and such only, as he believes to be acceptable to Him. This duty is precedent, both in order of time and in degree of obligation, to the claims of civil society. Before any man can be considered a member of civil society, he must be considered as a subject of the Governor of the universe; and if a member of civil society who enters into any subordinate association must do it with a reservation of his duty to the general authority, much more must every man who becomes a member of any particular civil society do it with a saving of his allegiance to the Universal Sovereign. We maintain, therefore, that in matters of religion no man’s right is abridged by the institution of civil society, and that religion is wholly exempt from its cognizance. Another writer has truly said:— To protect liberty of conscience is the duty of the state, and this is the limit of its authority in matters of religion. When the laws of men conflict with the word and law of God, we are to obey the latter, whatever the consequences may be. This is not anarchy. It is loyalty to God, loyalty of the highest type. “We ought to obey God rather than men,” is the verdict of Scripture. President Fairchild, in his “Moral Philosophy,” rightly observes that obedience is to be rendered to all human governments, in subordination to the will of God. It is too obvious to need discussion that the law of God, the great principle of benevolence, is supreme, and that we ought to obey God rather than men in any case of conflict between human law and the divine. There are cases so clear that no one can question the duty to refuse obedience. In all times and in all lands such cases have arisen. Yes, in all times and in all lands such cases have arisen. In Russia, in Prussia, in England, and even in America, the boasted land of civil and religious liberty, and in the nineteenth century, cases of this kind have arisen. In nearly all governments upon earth are found laws requiring the observance of, not the seventh, but the first day of the week as the Sabbath. In the year 1892 the ecclesiastical leaders of apostate Protestantism in the United States, through the aid of Roman Catholicism, and by means of threatening petitions and boycotting measures, secured from the general government of that country9 a law to this effect—a law the nature of which that government had, up to that time, steadfastly refused to pass. As the result of the enforcement of these laws, already men have been fined, imprisoned, worked in chain gangs, and even banished. Here, then, is a conflict between human law and the divine. God’s law says observe the seventh day; human law says observe the first. But, as of old, our duty is still plain. “We ought to obey God rather than men.” Here, in the language of Mr. Fairchild, is a case “so clear that no one [after becoming intelligent upon the subject] can question the duty to refuse obedience.” No one is under any obligation to keep any Sunday law on earth; in fact, obedience of this kind is sin. It is a duty to refuse obedience, and all who are loyal to God will, as fast as they become intelligent upon the question, and duty is made plain, do so. And right here, on this very point, is coming the test of loyalty to God for this generation, as the world-wide agitation of the Sabbath question and the enforcement of Sunday observance plainly show. But the question is sometimes asked, Ought we not to obey the powers that be? In the words of another, we answer: “Yes, when they are in harmony with the higher powers that be. God made this law for all the universe. He created man; he gives us the bounteous provisions of nature, holds our breath and life in his hand. He is to be recognized, his law honored, before all the great men and the highest earthly powers.” Let every one, therefore, who desires to stand clear from idolatry, and to prove himself loyal to God, see to it that he render to Caesar only that which is Caesar’s, and to God that which is God’s.