STATE RIGHTS

17%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Jun 6, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 22.

Read the full edition

STATE RIGHTS.

Periodically the question of state rights comes to the front in this country, and it takes various turns, according to the nature of the issue. Just now there is great indignation in South Carolina because of the decision of a United States Court that conflicts with the State Dispensary Law and with the established status of voters. This time the general government interferes in behalf of a class supposed to be denied their natural rights, and, as the governor complains, “the doors have been thrown open, and the ballot again placed in the hands of every man, white or black, of the age of twenty-one years.”
We mention this for the purpose of drawing a comparison. A few years ago, when a humble citizen of Tennessee appealed to a United States Court in defense of rights which were denied by the state law, the court declined to interfere. Why this difference? It cannot be laid to the fact that different judges rendered the decisions. In the Tennessee case the question was concerning a religious right, and the appellant was an obscure man, a member of an obscure and unpopular church; hence the U. S. Court did not think it proper to come in between the state and its citizens. In the South Carolina case the right in question is of a political nature, involving a large number of votes; hence its greater importance.
Thus we see that, in the logic of our government judiciary, political rights are more important than religious rights; in other words, a man’s religious scruples are not worthy the notice of the government, especially if his faith is not held by the majority. But in matters political it is worth while to even set aside state statutes. This tendency to ignore the religious liberty of persons in the minority by the general government is shared by state, county, and municipal governments, and is largely due, sad as is the fact, to the church element of our population. The churches have adopted the political principle in their aggressive work; they are appealing to the civil law, which in a republican government is theoretically the voice of the majority; they are making radical claims upon the various law-making bodies on the assumption of representing the majority of the people. They continually make their demands on this assumption, and ignore even acknowledged Bible precedent if that be on the side of a minority. They virtually stand upon the theory that might makes right. Inasmuch as the popular church element has assumed the position that those who hold to unpopular religious doctrines have no rights that the majority are bound to respect, it is but natural that government officials would come to estimate religious rights according to their bearing upon politics. So the man or the church without political influence would have no rights which an august court would care to uphold against a popular law, however unjust.
It appears, then, that any state may pass discriminating Sunday laws, which in actual practice restrict only a few individuals void of political influence, thus abridging the religious liberty of a certain class, and the general government does not interfere with the state’s assumed prerogative. But in the matter of regulating the franchise, or restricting the liquor traffic, the Federal Court sees its way at once to step in and annul the state statutes. Time will show in this country what history attests as to others,—that to abridge the religious liberties of a people, even of a single man, is a sure road to restricted civil rights. The general government assumes to guarantee civil liberty and religious liberty. It smites half the Union in defense of the first, and yields state right to abridge the second. It jealously guards the liquor traffic through its exclusive control of interstate commerce, but it allows freedom of conscience, one of its boasted glories, to be openly put to shame by a state Sunday law.
W. N. G.