BY W. A. COLCORD.
Truth never becomes less such by repetition, and repetition is often necessary before a truth makes a due impression upon the minds of men. Referring to an experience in the life of Luther illustrating this fact, D’Aubigné observes that “it is frequently necessary that a truth should be repeatedly presented to our minds in order to produce its due effect.” It is for this reason that we present again and again thoughts upon the important subject of the province and limitations of civil government and man’s relationship thereto, in connection with his responsibility and allegiance to God, his Maker.
Much confusion, suffering, and sin have resulted from a lack of a proper understanding of this question. But He who spake as never man spake laid down a rule which is so simple and plain that none need err in determining where to draw the line between what is duty to God and what to earthly governments.
A test question was once put to Christ by those who sought to entangle him in his talk, and find whereof they might accuse him. The Jews were then unwillingly under tribute to Cæsar. Coming to Christ, they asked, “Is it lawful to give tribute to Cæsar, or not?” Had he said, Yes, they would doubtless have seized upon this as an occasion for taking offense; for, as already stated, they were unwillingly paying taxes to Cæsar. Had he said, No, they would have had grounds upon which to prefer charges against him before the Roman Government. Whichever way he answered it, it would seem, would involve him in difficulty. To the Jews it no doubt appeared that they had propounded to him a question which he could not answer without putting an argument into their hands which they could use against him. But he answered them so wisely, and in a way that appealed so strongly to their reason and common sense, that they marveled, and left him, and went their way. Perceiving their wicked intent, he said: “Why tempt ye me, ye hypocrites? Show me the tribute money. And they brought unto him a penny. And he saith unto them, Whose is this image and superscription? They say unto him, Cæsar’s. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” Matt. 22: 18–21.
Thus did Christ silence the Jews, and answer what in their estimation would be to him a most puzzling question. And herein is couched a principle by which, if applied, no one need ever be at a loss to know what he ought to render to God and what to civil government. The first and only thing necessary to ascertain is that of ownership. The only question to be settled is, Whose is it, God’s or Cæsar’s? Let this once be determined, and the duty to obey or not to obey, or to whom obedience is to be rendered, is at once apparent.
To illustrate: Suppose a government should attempt to enforce upon its citizens the ordinance of baptism. While no one would deny that baptism is a Christian ordinance, commanded in the Scriptures, and that its practice is perfectly proper on the part of those who believe in Christ, the enforcement of it on the part of the government would be condemned as quite out of place. And why so?—Simply because it is an institution which does not belong to civil government. Baptism pertains to God. Men are baptized for the remission of sins; but sin is a violation of God’s law, and can therefore be remitted only by God.
Suppose, again, that the government should attempt to compel men to celebrate the ordinance known as the Lord’s supper; this would likewise be regarded as an unwarranted assumption of power, because, as the name of the sacrament itself shows, it belongs to the Lord, and not to the government.
Likewise with the enforcement of Sabbath observance. The Sabbath is the Lord’s, and its observance is to be rendered to the Lord. The principle underlying the observance of this, as well as all other days devoted or set apart for religious purposes, is stated in Rom. 14: 6: “He that regardeth the day, regardeth it unto the Lord; and he that regardeth not the day, to the Lord he doth not regard it.” Therefore, for the government to attempt to enforce the observance of the Sabbath or any other religious institution, or for any ecclesiastical power or organization through the government to attempt to do so, is for it to seek to compel men to render to themselves that which belongs to God. It is usurpation and robbery, and an attempt to compel men to commit idolatry. And any man who observes any such institutions because of such requirements, has no more discharged his duties to God than the man who owes his neighbor a certain amount has canceled the debt by paying the specified sum to another.
It is evident, therefore, that the question of ownership at once determines to whom obedience in any particular case is to be rendered, whether to God or to the government. And if there is to be a distinction made here, it must also be evident that the realms, or jurisdictions, of God’s and Cæsar’s are entirely separate and distinct. While the subjects are the same, the natures of the two governments are entirely distinct. One is civil, the other religious; one is temporal, the other eternal; one pertains solely to this present world, the other to the world to come; one takes cognizance of acts only as they affect the rights of others, the other scrutinizes the acts themselves, and the prompting motives behind them. The only obligations resting upon men with which civil governments have anything to do are those which exist between man and man. With the duties which men owe to God, Cæsar has nothing to do.
Melbourne, Australia.