THE SEER AND HIS VISION

3%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · May 2, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE SEER AND HIS VISION.

The president of the Pacific Theological Seminary recently read a paper before the Monday Club of Congregational ministers in San Francisco, on “The Province of the Seer,” in which occurred these remarkable expressions:—
The sanction of the seer lies in his value. As it says in Proverbs, “Where there is no vision the people perish.” . . . The sanction of the seer is the highest of them all. He is the saviour of us all. If by any shortage there should be but one prophet in all America it would be profitable that we sacrifice half the people rather than lose him, so that the other half should be saved.
It would be a rather questionable “saviour” whose good offices could be secured only by a sacrifice of half the people. The model Saviour sacrificed himself instead of the people. But a very remarkable part of the proposition is that “it would be profitable that we sacrifice half the people,” etc. Who are “we” that could profitably do that kind of sacrificing?—Presumably those who uphold the seer. Then supposing half of the people should be supporters of the seer and the other half should not, “it would be profitable” for the seer’s adherents to “sacrifice” the other class in order to secure the permanence of the seer’s stay as the saviour of those who sustain him at so great a cost. And this is the theology of the head of a nominally Protestant theological institution!
This may seem at the first glance to be new theology, but it is not new. It is as old as the worship of Baal and Ashtoreth and Moloch. Nor is it new even under the pretense of being Christian theology, for we read in history of the setting up of a seer in Rome (about A.D. 533) for whom the “sanction” of the whole empire was demanded. But his “value” was not appreciated by three of the ten kingdoms then composing the empire. So the imperial government thought “it would be profitable” to “sacrifice” those three kingdoms “rather than lose him,” and they were sacrificed. That is to say, the three kingdoms of the Heruli, the Vandals, and the Ostrogoths were destroyed in order to clear the way for the rule of the bishop of Rome as head (or “saviour”) of all the churches. Not only were these three kingdoms sacrificed in order to firmly establish the Roman seer, but from that time until his influence was weakened by the Reformation scores of millions of opponents were sacrificed for nonconformity to the teachings of this “saviour” who was set up and maintained at so great a cost to the people.
Another remarkable feature of the paper under consideration is the time of its appearance. At the special invitation of the president of the Pacific Theological Seminary, a new “seer,” one Professor Herron, of Iowa, comes to California for the purpose of proclaiming a “political vision of Christ.” The interpretation of this vision is, in short, a “Christian state.” He says “the only way in which Christianity can fully be put to practice is to possess the state.” This “seer” coming to the coast under the quasi auspices of the Congregationalists, one of the Congregational ministers of San Francisco, Dr. C. O. Brown, took decided issue with the doctrines promulgated in the “vision.” Dr. Brown says, “I opposed this man’s coming because I did not want such things said in San Francisco under the auspices of Congregationalism.” It is evident from these facts that the paper on “The Province of the Seer,” read before the Congregational Club, had direct reference to Professor Herron’s mission. His “vision” of a union of church and state is no doubt the one indirectly referred to in the paper when quoting the scripture, “Where there is no vision, the people perish.” And he is the “prophet” (if he should happen to be the only one) of whom it is said, “It would be profitable that we sacrifice half the people rather than lose him.”
This new seer, however, sets up an alleged essential to an understanding of his doctrine, although inviting criticism. In introducing his second lecture in Oakland he said:—
For what I actually say I wish to be held strictly accountable. Nor can what I shall try to say be considered at all justly except from the standpoint from which I speak. It is that of a political and social witness for Christ. No cause of truth can be helped by seeking to judge any one from some other standpoint than that from which he speaks. It can only result in misunderstanding on the part of those who persist in judging him from some other man’s point of view.
This is not exactly a claim to infallibility, but it is closely akin to it. To view from his standpoint is virtually to believe his teaching. We must first accept, then we can view understandingly. The pope of Rome says to his adherents, You must believe because I, as seer of the church, say so; you can only understand truth from this standpoint. Now no one but God has a right to expect a hearer to believe because he says so, and understand afterward. The one who asks us first to come to his standpoint in order to understand a theory fraught with so much import as that presented by Professor Herron, must of necessity claim divine inspiration. And here is an extract from a syllabus of his lecture on “The Christian State the Salvation of the Church”:—
The want of inspiration is the cause of the distrust of the church among the masses. The real heresy on the question of inspiration is that which conceives of God as more interested in the politics of the Hebrews than of the Americans. The one complaint of the Hebrew prophets was that the people would not receive fresh inspiration; that was the fault Christ found with the Jews, and it is the fault of the church to-day. The present social movements are a conviction of sin and a revelation of Christ to the church. Its acceptance or rejection of it is not yet decided. A new union of church and state (inspirational not arbitrary) may be expected. This union is not to be sought as an end, but will be added to the church when it has truly sought God’s kingdom.
In another lecture he says that he often speaks with a “profound sense of divine compulsion.” Now whether the inspiration of the “vision” of “Seer” Herron is of God may easily be found, not from the standpoint from which he speaks, but from the standpoint of the word of God. The Lord has explicitly designated the test in such matters: “To the law and to the testimony; if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isa. 8:20. Let us then submit this “political vision of Christ” to a brief test in the search light of the Scriptures. From a syllabus of Mr. Herron’s lecture on “The Christian State,” we take this statement:—
The sacrifice of Jesus is the revelation of the universal principle of life; the state, then, must become Christian. Not only must the state become Christian, but Christianity must become political. The religious faith of the people must seek through the state to realize upon earth the kingdom of heaven.
Over against this expression we place these words of Christ:—
“MY KINGDOM IS NOT OF THIS WORLD.” John 18:36.
Mr. Herron tells us that “the judgment day is now—it is here.” This would imply that we are in the last days. With this thought in view let us draw one more comparison. This “seer” says:—
The world is moving quickly toward revolution, but it is the revolution from anarchy to order and from lawlessness to law, and from political atheism to the kingdom of God. . . . Not the least significant fact of this present social crisis in human affairs is the increasing faith in Jesus which comes from the awakening of the social conscience of the world. The social and political revival of Christianity is the most significant fact of modern times, and it promises a new and altogether divine kind of revolution.
In short, he enjoins us to “find our place and work in the millennium already begun.” Now let us contrast this glowing representation with the words of the Spirit by the apostle Paul:—
“Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils,” etc. 1 Tim. 4:1.
So we see that this apostle, speaking by divine inspiration, shows a departing from the faith as the characteristic of the last days, rather than a “revival of Christianity.” And as to the social as well as the religious condition of this time, he again says:—
“This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come. For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good, traitors, heady, high minded, lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God; having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof; from such turn away.” 2 Tim. 3:1-5.
We see by these brief tests that the Scriptures, which are “given by inspiration of God” (2 Tim. 3:16), utter a very different sentiment from that expressed in the visionary theories of “Seer” Herron. And there are scores of his propositions which, when submitted to the same light, meet the same fate. When a prophet so signally fails in a test prescribed by the Spirit of God, it would seem hardly “profitable that we sacrifice half the people rather than lose him.” We will now submit one more expression:—
Christ spent the entire first year of his ministry in trying to get control of the state.
If this is true, it has not been revealed in any of the Biblical records of his acts. And, furthermore, if it is true, he must have changed his mind later on, for we read in John 6:15:—
“When Jesus therefore perceived that they would come and take him by force, to make him a king, he departed again into a mountain himself alone.”
Having demonstrated that this new “seer” is not “a teacher sent from God,” we naturally inquire, What spirit does inspire his “political vision of Christ”? We turn to some significant expressions for reply:—
The redeemed church will express the political faith of the people. Neither Catholicism nor Protestantism is true to its mission now, and a new “Holy Catholic Church” is yet to be realized. The hastening or delaying of this rests only with the Christians themselves.
Of course Mr. Herron would resent any suggestion of favoring a return to the Roman Catholic Church. But we are now looking for the spirit of his inspiration, and to this end we open still another door:—
There has never been a great revolution seeming to break with the past and make a new order of things, from which there has not been a terrible recoil sooner or later. The revolutionized nation or civilization has had to return and connect itself with the good substance of the evil forms from which it revolted. The religious revolution which we call the Reformation was a universal loss as well as a gain, and we are already beginning to see that the future power of the church is involved in our finding some way to reunite our broken fragments, our discordant sects of Christendom, in the true and universal church. The Catholic Church was, after all, a spiritual splendor, and was historic with institutions which Protestantism cannot afford to have done away.
So when our nation and our civilization shall have returned and connected itself with the “good substance” of the past, and the “discordant sects of Christendom” shall have become united in the “true and universal church,” and Christianity shall have “become political,” and “Christian political philosophy” shall have “transformed our conception of international relations,” etc., etc., what will we have?—“A new Holy Catholic Church,” and an “inspirational” union of church and state, a full development of what we already see, in principle, working in some sections of the Union. We will have the full development of the principle already made into law by certain acts of Congress and the decision of the U. S. Supreme Court that “this is a Christian nation.” We will have not exactly the Roman Catholic Church in all its pristine glory, known in Scripture as the “beast whose deadly wound was healed” (Revelation 13), for that will still occupy the Old World; but we will have that other “spiritual splendor,” the fully developed “image to the beast.”
Now we do not believe it necessary to come to “Seer” Herron’s standpoint to understand the salient points of his “political vision of Christ.” We learn from the word of God, from the history of the past, and from the facts and movements of to-day, what his message portends. He tells us that Christ has come; that he is here already; he is here as a “recognized social leader;” he is here as “the leader of human thought,” and “developed in all the political thought.” But Christ has given us a guard against all such sophistry. Concerning his coming again to this world, he says:—
“Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not. For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall show great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect. Behold, I have told you before. Wherefore if they shall say unto you, Behold, he is in the desert; go not forth; behold, he is in the secret chambers; believe it not. For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.” Matt. 24:23-27.
W. N. G.