THE DOCTOR'S SABBATH QUESTIONS

2%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · May 2, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE DOCTOR'S SABBATH QUESTIONS.

[EDITOR SIGNS: While holding a series of meetings at ——, N. Y., the subject of “The Sabbath of the Lord” was presented, and quite an interest in the subject was awakened in the village. This led to a council of ministers and the doctor of the place. A list of questions called “clinches” was arranged and presented to me by the doctor. So many have desired to have the questions, together with the scriptures and pith of the argument used in their answer, that I decided to put them in print. Hence I send them to you, that if you think best they may be inserted in your journal. A. E. PLACE.]

THE QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS.

1. PLEASE state where the Bible states that the Sabbath was a memorial of creation.
“He hath made his wonderful works to be remembered; the Lord is gracious and full of compassion.” Ps. 111:4. “Thy name, O Lord, endureth forever; and thy memorial, O Lord, throughout all generations.” Ps. 135:13. “And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it; because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.” Gen. 2:2, 3.
2. Does the Bible state that every seventh day from the creation was set apart for a sacred or any other use?
Yes. The Sabbath that was blessed and sanctified was the seventh day. Gen. 2:3. That day was given to Adam, and through him to every man. The definition to “sanctify” is to “set apart,” “separate,” “appoint.” Compare with Mark 2:27, “The Sabbath was made for man.”
3. Did Adam have a Sabbath given to him?
Yes. See answer to question 2.
4. What was the period of time from Adam to Moses?
About 2,369 years.
5. Does not the Bible tell us that there was no law from Adam to Moses?
No; it tells us there was a law. Note carefully 1 John 3:4 and Rom. 5:12-14: “Sin is the transgression of the law,” and death comes by sin. “Death reigned from Adam to Moses,” but death reigns only where sin reigns, and sin reigns only where the law is transgressed. Read also Gen. 4:7-11; 3:5; 13:13; 15:16; 50:17; 26:5.
6. How could there be a Sabbath day if there was no law?
There could not be, but there was a law, as shown above.
7. Does Moses or any of the prophets point to any Sabbath being kept before the one in the wilderness?
Yes. Gen. 2:3; Ex. 5:4, 5. The word “rest” in Ex. 5:5 means in Hebrew “keep Sabbath.” This shows that Moses carried a Sabbath reform message to the Israelites before they left Egypt.
8. Did God ever bless or sanctify the Sabbath he gave to Israel?
Yes; in the beginning. At least thirty days before Israel came to Sinai (compare Ex. 16:1 and 19:1), it is stated that the Israelites kept “the seventh day.” Ex. 16:30. Afterward, when the law was spoken on Sinai, God says that he “blessed” and “hallowed” (sanctified) the seventh day, the very day they kept before they came to Sinai. Compare Ex. 16:30 with chap. 20:11.
9. Did Christ ever bless it?
Yes; Christ was the one who spoke the law on Sinai, and he said he was Lord of the Sabbath. He was the active agent in the work of creation. John 1:1-3, 10, 14; Col. 1:14-17. He worked six days, rested the seventh day, and blessed it, because that in it he had rested. Gen. 2:3; Ex. 20:8-11.
10. How long had the world existed before the gentiles had a Sabbath?
“The Sabbath was made for man” (Mark 2:27) long before such distinctions as Jew and gentile were known.
11. Did Christ ever declare the gentiles to have a Sabbath?
Yes; gentiles are men. See question 10, and Isa. 56:1-8.
12. Was the Sabbath a sign that God had sanctified Israel?
Yes, and “forever.” See Ex. 31:12, 13; Eze. 20:12, 19, 20.
13. Did Christ countenance the seventh-day Sabbath after his resurrection? If so, where do you find it in the Bible?
Yes. Acts 13:14, 27, 42, 44; 16:12, 13; 17:1, 2; 18:4, 11, etc. Bear in mind that it was the Spirit of Christ that inspired this record written by Luke; hence it is truly the word of Christ. See Matt. 24:15.
14. Did not Christ keep the Christian sabbath on the first day of the week after his resurrection, and did not once keep the old Jewish Sabbath? If not, how do you explain John 20:9-29.
For a solution to this scripture compare John 20:19 with Mark 16:14. The only reason given in the word of God why Christ met with his disciples on the first day of the week is that he might have living witnesses to the fulfillment of his word. “And the third day [he does not say anything about its being the first day of the week] he shall rise again.” Luke 18:33; compare with chap. 24:45-48.
15. Did not Christ and the Father ratify the Christian sabbath by the Holy Spirit on Pentecost?
No; they ratified Pentecost, not Sunday. The best authorities disagree concerning the day of the week on which Pentecost fell that year. Prof. H. B. Hackett, D. D., says, “It is generally supposed that this Pentecost fell on our Saturday.” Olshausen says, “The fiftieth day, it appears, fell upon Saturday.” Dean Alford says, “The question on what day of the week this Pentecost was, is beset with difficulties.” Dr. Albert Barnes says, “It is impossible to determine the truth on this subject, nor is it of much importance.”
16. Was not the first day of the week the Lord’s day? and were not the apostles and disciples at Jerusalem endued with power from on high on that day?
No; the Lord’s day was the day that he “sanctified” (Gen. 2:3) and called “my holy day” (Isa. 58:13). See also on question 15.
17. How many times does the term “day of our Lord” occur in the Bible?
That term or its equivalent occurs about sixteen times. Joel 2:1 is a sample.
18. How many times does “Lord’s day” occur in the Bible?
Once; Rev. 1:10.
19. Was not the vision of John given on the Christian sabbath?
No, not if by that you mean Sunday. Christ has called himself Lord of but one day, and that is the Sabbath, or seventh day. See Mark 2:28; Isa. 58:13; Ex. 20:8-11.
20. Does not the Greek, from which our New Testament is translated, wherever you find the word “week,” have “sabbath”—thus, “Very early in the morning, the first day of the week,” would read, “the first day of the Sabbath”?
Yes, the Greek term is “sabbath;” but it never reads, “the first-day sabbath.” The Greek Sabbata means in some instances “week;” thus, “the first of the sabbath,” “the second of the sabbath,” “the sixth of the sabbath,” and “the Sabbath.”
21. Please read and explain Acts 20:7 and 1 Cor. 16:1, 2.
Dr. John Kitto says, “The evening of the first day of the week would be our Saturday evening.” Conybeare (“Life of Paul,” vol. 2, p. 206) says, “It was the evening which succeeded the Jewish Sabbath.” Others give the same testimony. It is the only record in the New Testament of a meeting held on the first day of the week, excepting that on the day of the resurrection. We have already given the record of eighty-four meetings held by Paul on the Sabbath. See question 12. The disciples broke bread every day. See Acts 2:46. Can the holding of one meeting, or any number of them, on the first day of the week change God’s word, which says that “the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God”? In 1 Cor. 16:2 the phrase rendered “by him” is unquestionably an idiomatic Greek expression for “at home.” See Luther, Barnes, Matthew Henry, Robinson, Greenfield, and all Greek lexicographers.
22. If your days are from sunrise to sunrise, how often does your seventh day come in Spitzbergen?
Just as often as the first day of the week comes. But the day is not from sunrise to sunrise, but from sunset to sunset. Compare Lev. 23:32 with Mark 1:32. When the sun is at the Tropic of Cancer, within the North Frigid Zone, it seems to pass in a circle around the horizon every twenty-four hours, hence is seen in the east at 6 o’clock A.M., in the south at noon, in the west at 6 P.M., and in the north at midnight, or what is midnight to us. When the sun is over the Tropic of Capricorn, each day and night in the North Frigid Zone can be clearly discerned by the variation of light and darkness. This is the testimony of all northern explorers. But at any point on the earth’s surface where it is possible for men to live, they can keep a faithful record of the days and weeks without a chronometer. And there the Lord will be present with his laws and power to enable all who desire so to do, to keep his Sabbath and to obey him in all things.
Conclusion—“To the law and to the testimony” (Isa. 8:20) with every argument presented.