The Uncertainty of Constitutional Guaranty.—

25%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Apr 18, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 16.

Read the full edition

The Uncertainty of Constitutional Guaranty.—

Whether an act be constitutional or unconstitutional depends not so much upon the wording of the Constitution as upon the opinions or whims of the Supreme Courts. Lawyer W. R. Davis, of this city, illustrated this point in a recent lecture before a class of university law students. This was not the point he purposely illustrated, but the following sentence in his remarks had that effect:—
“There are some brief points in the Constitution [of the United States] as applied to the jurisdiction of courts, where as many as ten different constructions have been placed, involving the contentions of the profoundest judges and lawyers of the country.”
So we see there is great uncertainty in any appeal to so-called courts of justice for protection in the matter of supposed constitutional rights. The Constitution is, practically, no more or less than the opinion, or perhaps the prejudice or expediency, of the Supreme Bench.