AdventAI

REFORMATION MARRIED BY TRADITION.

By W. N. G.

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 15., April 11, 1895

It is a notable fact that in every special reformation which God has inaugurated for the benefit of his people, and through them for the benefit of the world, the results have come far short of the possible consummation. The Lord’s people have not attained to the high spiritual standing, or received the great measure of blessing, or reflected the good influence upon the world, that he designed they should. The question arises, Why is it that the work of reformation has always stopped short of what might have been accomplished?

It would seem that the spirit of reformation is “weak through the flesh.” The history of every reform movement which the Lord has inaugurated upon the earth shows that it was shorn of complete triumph by the interference of human tradition. The Spirit of the Lord, by which alone true reform can be instituted and carried on, has been invariably hindered by the unwillingness of those engaged in the work to relinquish all previous error and be led into all truth. Such is the tenacity with which the human mind clings to preconceived opinion. Such is the antipathy to an acknowledgment of entire dependence for wisdom upon a higher Source.

A few instances will suffice to illustrate the position here assumed. Going back to the deliverance of Israel from Egyptian bondage, we learn that God designed to do a great work for them and with them. This design is prefigured in the promise made at Sinai: “If ye will obey my voice indeed, and keep my covenant, then ye shall be a peculiar treasure unto me above all people; for all the earth is mine; and ye shall be unto me a kingdom of priests, and an holy nation.” Ex. 19:5, 6. As “a kingdom of priests” they were to minister before God and to the world to bring the people of the nations to a knowledge of salvation. But scarcely had they entered into covenant relation with God, preparatory to disseminating the light of truth imparted to them, when their minds reverted to the idolatry of Egypt. And when God would introduce amongst them a system of diet reform, their appetites longed for the “fleshpots of Egypt.” The errors of their former life which the Lord, their leader in the great movement, designed they should leave off entirely clung so closely to them that even on the border of the promised land great numbers of them proposed to return to Egypt in a body. Thus, while being piloted by the Lord in person, the entrance into Canaan was delayed thirty-eight years. And they never did fully subdue even the land that was to be their special inheritance, because they never fully forsook their former errors.

The reformation under Ezra and Nehemiah, on the return from Babylonian captivity, was greatly hindered and was but a partial success, for like reasons. So, also, the reformation in connection with our Lord’s ministry upon the earth. The people who “heard him gladly,” and “wondered at the gracious words which proceeded out of his mouth,” and praised God on account of the wonderful miracles which were performed by him and in his name, were kept from accepting him as the Messiah by the traditions of the elders. Even his chosen twelve, up to the day of his return to heaven, could not give up the traditional idea that the principal mission of the Messiah was to deliver the Jewish nation from the Roman yoke and make of it the leading nation of earth. Thus the people of Jerusalem did not know the things that belonged to her peace in the day when the Lord again designed to make that the place fromp. 2 whence, and them the people by whom, the Gospel should go out to the world. But tradition stood in the way of a full knowledge of the truth. Said the Lord to that people, “Full well ye reject the commandment of God, that ye may keep your own tradition.” Mark 7:9.

Coming on to the time of Luther, we find a repetition of the same hindering cause. Although proclaiming with great power the leading Reformation tocsin, “The just shall live by faith,” Luther himself could not be persuaded to lay aside all the errors of the Roman Church, whose apostasy he so emphatically denounced. To the last he clung to the fallacious dogma of transubstantiation (the real presence of the body of Christ in the eucharist), and some of his co-reformers clung with equal pertinacity to other Roman errors, while the great majority still held to the doctrine of man’s inherent immortality and to the Sunday sabbath and other church festivals. Thus the Reformation left Protestantism in a measure burdened with papal tradition, to the great detriment of the progress of reform.

Not only was the Reformation robbed of its possible complete victory by the retention of these papal traditions, but these errors, as in the past in Roman hands, became bones of contention and causes of persecution in Protestant hands. So long as the church retains purely traditional dogmas as fundamental doctrine, so long she retains the elements of strife and persecution. The only true reformation is a return “to the law and to the testimony” (Isa. 8:20),—“the Bible and the Bible alone” in fact as well as in theory,—as the only rule of faith and practice.

The evangelistic work of the Wesleys, Whitefield, and others, was accompanied by great spiritual awakening and the special blessing of God, from which much good resulted. But many of the traditions of the Church of England were still held by the leaders in the work, who were by no means united as to what should be the form of creed or government the new movement should adopt. Traditional dogma comes in for large consideration in all of the many factions which have grown out of the Wesleyan reformation. And the divisions are all the result of varying traditional lines.

Another noted revival movement is one that has taken place in our own generation—1840–1844. It is not yet far enough in the past to be generally recognized as a “reformation,” yet no religious movement ever gained anything like its proportions in so short a time. As yet, however, it is too much like a prophet in his own country to receive the honor due to it. A mistake was made by those foremost in the work, and the multitudes of followers naturally fell into it. Therefore the scoffers of the same generation must needs give vent to their scoffing. They are either ignorant or willfully forgetful of the fact that the disciples of Christ, even his own chosen companions, made fully as great a mistake when they supposed he would then set up his kingdom. This movement was not confined to America, it extended to Europe and to Asia. The preaching of Wm. Miller and his associates and collaborers was with great power, and their followers were characterized by great humility and brotherly love. It was not a denominational move; although Mr. Miller was a Baptist, the judgment message which he proclaimed was accepted by thousands of all denominations and those of no denomination. It was a general awakening, one which called forth much study of the Scriptures, and resulted in thousands of conversions.

But the permanent good that might have been done was largely curtailed by a mistake. To the warning of the coming judgment (Rev. 14:6, 7) was added the error that the Lord was coming to the earth in 1844. The spiritual revival of that time is still bearing the reproach of that error; but how came such an error to fasten on to the work of reformation? In the same way that traditional errors clung to the minds of reformers in the earlier reformations. The mistake of proclaiming that the Lord would come to the earth in 1844 was the result of mingling church tradition with the real burden of the revival message. The Lord directed the messages, “The hour of his judgment is come” and “Babylon is fallen,” but the interpretation that the Lord would come in 1844 was the outgrowth of tradition.

Mr. Miller computed the 2,300 days of Dan. 8:14 correctly. No one at that time or since has been able to overthrow his conclusion that the work of cleansing the sanctuary, spoken of by the prophet, began at the time specified (1844). But just here the hand of tradition was interposed. It was generally held in all the churches, and is yet so held, that the sanctuary to be cleansed is the earthly sanctuary, or the earth itself, which is to be purified by fire. It was generally believed in the churches that the general judgment would be here upon the earth, and that the Lord would descend for that purpose. It was not understood that the cleansing of the sanctuary was a part of the anti-typical work of Christ in the heavenly sanctuary, of which the Jewish sanctuary with its ministration was a type, or figure. See Heb. 8:1–6; also chapter 9. In the type the cleansing of the sanctuary was a judgment work at the close of the year. Every year the work of salvation was typified in the worldly sanctuary, closing up with the day of atonement or typical judgment. So in the heavenly sanctuary the real High Priest makes the true atonement, and the cleansing of the sanctuary in his work must be the judgment of his people, the blotting out of their sins, or their names, according as the record shows. This was the work in the type. See Lev. 16; 23:27–29.

But the tradition of the church was that the atonement was made on the cross, that the judgment must be on the earth, and that the cleansing of the sanctuary was the purifying of the earth. Together with the great truths that the leaders in that revival held forth, the foregoing and other popular traditions were retained as doctrine, and led to erroneous conclusions. Hence the reformation which God designed, in the warning of approaching judgment and of the spiritual fall of the Babylon churches, fell short of possible results through the errors of church tradition. The mistake of 1844 was not a mistake of the spirit of reformation, and was not an evidence that the hand of the Lord was not in the movement, but it was a further and striking illustration of the fact that no reformation can be complete without an entire discarding of all tradition, a return to the word of God alone, and a humble submission to the guidance of the Holy Spirit, which alone can properly interpret the word and lead the obedient servant into all truth. A true reformation can only be conducted by such as will come out entirely from “Babylon” and her traditions, and “keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.” Such a reformation is necessary in order that the people of God may be “found of him in peace, without spot, and blameless.” W. N. G.