PERSECUTION IN RHEA COUNTY, TENNESSEE.
By W. N. G.
In the Dayton (Tenn.) Republican of the 9th inst. we have an account of the trial of several of our brethren on charges of violating the iniquitous Sunday law of that state. We append some extracts from the proceedings:— The Seventh-day Adventists’ trials were held Tuesday and Wednesday, before Judge Parks, at the Circuit Court. They were all charged with carrying on the common avocations of life on Sunday, contrary to the law, and their names and the character of the work done, as elicited by the testimony of Wright Rains, the principal witness against them, are given below. They were all, nine in number, found guilty. William Burchard, digging well, in one case, and pulling fodder in another. W. J. Kerr, painting house. Dwight Plumb, building addition to his house. M. C. Sturdevant, sawing stove wood and building wire fence around flower bed. Elder G. W. Colcord, superintending carpentering work in his house. E. S. Abbott, selling goods. William Wolf, rolling windlass at the well Burchard was digging. Prof. I. C. Colcord, carrying lumber across several fences to be used in carpentering work about his house. Henry Burchard, helping dig a well. There were indictments against three others—A. F. Harrison, E. M. Plumb, and B. L. Deffenbacher. No arrests were made in these cases, the parties being in other states. The case against N. B. England was continued, at his request, as he had only lately come from North Carolina and was not prepared for trial. There were in all the unlucky number of thirteen Adventists indicted. George Smith, who is not an Adventist, was also charged with the same offense, the prosecutor named in the indictment being C. R. Wilson. When Smith’s case was called, Wilson failed to prosecute, and the case was dismissed. The Adventists did not employ a lawyer, but all addressed the juries. Attorney General Fletcher did not prosecute any further than develop the testimony from witnesses. The remarks of Brother William Burchard, on the trial of his first case, are reported as follows:—2 (194) I would just like to say that I am indicted for violating the Sabbath. I plead not guilty. I have been keeping the seventh day for four and one-half years. I have found out that the Bible says that the seventh day of the week is the Sabbath. I obey the laws of the land, but when they conflict with the law of God, I obey the law of God; when they do not, I obey the laws of the state. The Bible says: “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates; for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.” The state says the first day of the week is the Sabbath. God created the heavens and the earth, and when other gods contravene, I obey the God of heaven. I will read Acts 5:29: “Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men.” Acts 4:19: “But Peter and John answered and said unto them, Whether it be right in the sight of God to hearken unto you more than unto God, judge ye.” I count this a case against me on account of my belief. I read in Rom. 10:17, “So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.” I believe in the Bible; my faith is that the seventh day is the Sabbath; so it is a case about my belief in the Bible. I was born and raised in Rhea County, Tennessee, and have never been in court before. The Supreme Court of the state of Tennessee has decided that it is the commitment of more than one act that constitutes a nuisance. They have only one offense against me. In charging the jury in this case, Judge Parks is reported to have said:— Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant, William Burchard, is charged in the indictment with carrying on the common avocations of life on Sunday, the same not being an act of real necessity or charity. To this charge he pleads “not guilty,” and you are sworn to try the issue. It is a violation of the law of the state to unnecessarily perform the labor on Sunday in such a way as to disturb the worship of others, or in such a way as to affect the morals of the community. The carrying on of ordinary business or any kind of secular labor on Sunday, if so conducted as to attract public attention, is indictable under the laws of the state. It is not necessary to show that any person was disturbed by such act; it is sufficient if the act was done in such a public manner as to be open to the observation of the public. A single act of work on Sunday is not a nuisance in the eyes of the law unless that act be done in some peculiarly flagrant manner. One act is indictable, if it is done in this manner, if it will tend to corrupt the public morals. The question for you to determine is whether the work performed by the defendant in this instance is of such a nature or character as to have come under this head. You are the exclusive judges of the evidence and credibility of the witnesses. Take the case and render such verdict as you think is warranted by the law and under your oaths. The following named persons were convicted: Elder G. W. Colcord, Prof. I. C. Colcord, William Burchard, Henry Burchard, Dwight Plumb, W. J. Kerr, William Wolf, E. S. Abbott, M. C. Sturdevant. They were, for each case, fined $2.50 and costs; but the judge said that, as it was their first conviction, and in view of the peculiar character of the cases, he would suspend the fines, leaving the judgment in force for the costs only. Of course the defendants declined to pay, and were all sent to jail, excepting William Ross, whose father paid his costs for him. In an editorial reference to the trial, the Republican says:— We are not, or should not be, living in an age of religious persecution. Yet eight of our best citizens are being kept in the county jail because as Seventh-day Adventists they conscientiously violated a bad law that says they MUST observe the first day of the week as the sabbath instead of the seventh. A good community has been disorganized; a splendid school, that has been diffusing the rays of knowledge among the people, has been broken up. The remedy is to change the law, and do it as quickly as possible. THE REMARKS OF JUDGE PARKS.
The sentiments expressed by Judge Parks in pronouncing judgment upon the defendants in the foregoing cases, are interesting, as showing that his private judgment was somewhat at variance with the judgment which he felt constrained to utter officially. We here reproduce his remarks in full, as reported by the Republican:— In these cases the defendants have been adjudged guilty, after a fair and impartial trial by jury, of violating that day which is recognized by the law of our state as the sabbath, and it now becomes my duty, painful though it be, to pronounce judgment upon them. While our sympathies are with the defendants, and while they perhaps have good grounds for their faith, yet this is a temporal not a spiritual court, and we cannot pass upon questions of belief. The only questions we have to deal with are, “What is the law?” and, “Has the law been violated?” The law is plain, and it is not only our sworn duty to enforce it but to encourage respect for all law in general. As individuals we may each have our own opinions as to the justice of a law, yet as public officials intrusted with its enforcement, our duty is unequivocal. A coördinate branch of the government is intrusted by the people with law-making power, and when this power is exercised within constitutional limits, the judiciary can do nothing but enforce the law thus enacted. The Supreme Court of this state, whose decisions must be taken as final by the lower courts, has passed upon this question, and we cannot rightfully reverse its decisions. If I were to express my private feelings, however, I might say that there is nothing I regard with more concern or solicitude than an encroachment of legislative enactment upon the personal rights of the individual in matters of conscience. That there is a limit in these matters beyond which legislation cannot rightfully go will be conceded by every man. Where is that limit? This is a question which even the enlightened civilization of the nineteenth century, it seems, cannot answer. Human laws are of necessity imperfect. One class of individuals will claim that their rights are encroached upon in this way, another, in that way, and so on. This arises from diversity and shades of opinion. These questions, it seems, cannot be settled to suit everybody. As touching the questions at the bar, the large majority of the people honestly and conscientiously believe that secular labor on Sunday is a desecration of the true sabbath, and that this tends to corrupt public morals. That this belief pervades the people at large is fully evidenced by the several laws we have prohibiting various things as tending to desecrate that day. These laws would not exist but for public sentiment in their favor. The masses for hundreds of years have thought, and they still think, that public morality requires the observance of the day which has been recognized practically by all Christian denominations as the sabbath. As to the constitutionality of these laws it is true that grave doubts are entertained by many who adhere to Sunday as the sabbath. While every man is guaranteed the right to worship as his conscience dictates, and while no law respecting the establishment of religion can be passed, yet this has always been interpreted to mean that no particular creed or form of religion shall be prescribed, and that church and state shall remain divorced. All our laws recognize Christianity in general as the basis of our civilization, and laws for its protection have always been regarded as in keeping not only with the Constitution, but with public policy. Sunday is and for a long time has been recognized by nearly all Christian denominations as the sabbath, and it is for this reason, no doubt, that the laws which protect that day have always been acquiesced in as constitutional. They have never been regarded as laws which prescribe any particular belief, but as laws which protect the unanimous belief of nearly all Christian denominations. But here we have a respectable element of Christian believers, who are honest, inoffensive, law-abiding citizens in all matters not conflicting with their sense of duty, who believe they are under divine command to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath. As a matter of abstract individual right, can they be required to observe another day also? Their position is not that of the person who claims that as a matter of personal liberty he has the right, if he chooses, to run an open saloon on Sunday, or to do any like act. That is not a matter of conscience—this is. They claim that it is not only their right but their duty under divine command to observe the seventh day. Calling them “cranks” does not settle the question. If there were only one of them he would be entitled not only to his belief, but to the exercise of that belief, so long as in so doing he does not interfere with any natural right of his neighbor. A man cannot kill another and excuse himself by claiming that he believed he was carrying out God’s will in so doing, because this would deprive his victim of a natural right, namely, the enjoyment of life. Do the defendants, in keeping the seventh day and working on the first, thereby interfere with any natural right of their neighbors? Or is it an artificial right created by statute? Has any power but the divine will the right to establish any one day as Sabbath? If the day has been set by divine edict, but two or more persons honestly differ as to what day was appointed, can the dispute be settled by legislative enactment? These are grave questions upon which no opinion is now ventured, but they go as to the justice of the law, and not as to what the law is. There can be no dispute as to what the law is, and our duty is plain, and we must follow it. If the law is wrong, the remedy is not to be found in the courts. The consensus of Christian sentiment favors Sunday observance, and while the law commands its observance the courts will enforce the law. While the judge states a number of facts and extensively-accepted propositions out of which Sunday laws have grown, it is noticeable that he does not give these facts and propositions as reasons why such laws ought to exist; nor does he give them as reasons for his judgment in the cases before him,—that is based solely on the fact that the law exists. It is a fact that “these laws would not exist but for public sentiment in their favor;” but the judge very emphatically declares that he “regards with concern” the “encroachment of legislative enactment upon the personal rights of the individual in matters of conscience.” It may be added, as a matter of fact, that “public sentiment” is a very uncertain basis for legislative enactment. One day public sentiment sang, “Hosanna to the Son of David: Blessed is He that cometh in the name of the Lord;” and in less than a week the sentiment of that same public was, “Away with him, away with him, crucify him.” And it is worthy of notice that the latter sentiment was instigated by the rulers of the professed church of God, and ostensibly for the glory of God. All our laws recognize Christianity in general as the basis of our civilization. Without affirming or denying this proposition, we submit that if it is true, then all our laws are thwarted from their legitimate purpose. Our laws, of right, have nothing to do with Christianity, or any other religion. The non-religious character of our government has been affirmed and reaffirmed, not only by its founders but by their successors. The preamble to the United States Constitution says that it was established “in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves3 and our posterity.” Not a word about recognizing religion of any kind or in any sense. Not only so, but the Constitution provides that no religious test shall be required as a qualification for office or trust. And the eminent Justice Story, of the U. S. Supreme Court, interpreted this provision to mean that “the pagan, Mohammedan, Jew, Christian, and infidel shall sit down in common at the table of our national councils.” Further, on this idea of all our laws recognizing Christianity as the basis of civilization, we will cite James Madison, who said, “Religion is essentially distinct from civil government, and exempt from its cognizance.” Going back to Thomas Jefferson, we quote again: “I consider the Government of the United States interdicted by the Constitution from intermeddling with religious institutions, their doctrines, discipline, or exercises.” No legal recognition there of Christianity as the basis of anything whatever. Going back still further, we find a treaty with Tripoli, formed in the latter part of Washington’s administration, and ratified early in the administration of John Adams, which distinctly affirms that “the Government of the United States is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion.” But it is the boast of the people of this government that we have here the highest type of civilization. And, according to Article VI of the Constitution, a treaty is of equal force with the Constitution itself. Laws for its [Christianity’s] protection have always been regarded as in keeping not only with the Constitution but with public policy. Now to whatever extent such laws are so regarded, it is a positive mistake to so regard them. Civil laws cannot protect Christianity. History abundantly proves that the more the church is “protected” by civil government the more corrupt it becomes. The final culmination of the “mystery of iniquity” into the “man of sin,” the Papacy, was materially hastened by—yes, in a large measure the result of—laws for the protection of Christianity. The establishment of the Spanish Inquisition was a law for the protection of a system that passed for Christianity. It is the so-called legal protection of any religion that gives it power to persecute those who dissent from it. This fact has been well demonstrated in the cases in which Judge Parks has just passed judgment. The Sunday law of Tennessee was ostensibly a law for the protection of Christianity, but do these cases show that such has been the result? Does it protect those Christians who choose to obey the word of God in respect to the Sabbath day? Did it protect those Christians in court when they produced the authority of the Author of Christianity in support of the course for which they were condemned and punished?—Nay, verily. That Sunday law, professedly a law for the protection of Christianity, condemned the very men who most strenuously, at the expense of their liberty, maintained their fidelity to the plain word of the Christian’s God. Christianity can well spare all such “protection.” But what does the Sunday law protect?—It not only protects, but it encourages, the spirit of intolerance, the spirit of persecution for conscience’ sake. Furthermore, whenever its votaries see proper to select a dissenting neighbor for persecution, the Sunday law turns the whole governmental machinery into an auxiliary for carrying on the nefarious work. Is any further evidence necessary to demonstrate that the Sunday law is a union of the church and the state? Is it not a union to the full extent of the power of both? and that, too, for the punishment, not of evil doers, but of a class that even the judge whom it compels to pass sentence is constrained to designate as “a respectable element of Christian believers, who are honest, inoffensive, law-abiding citizens in all matters not conflicting with their sense of duty, who believe they are under divine command to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath.” Mark it well: The Sunday law unites the church and the power of the state as a pair of sleuthhounds to seek out and hunt down for imprisonment the class of citizens above described in the language of Judge Parks. Mark well, too, the characteristic which brings down the heel of the church and of the state upon the necks of these unfortunate victims,—they observe the seventh day as the Sabbath. Mark well: It is the class whose enemies, like the enemies of the prophet Daniel, can find no occasion against them except it be concerning the law of their God, whom the church and the state unite, under the inspiration of the Sunday law, to crush under their feet. Truly did Thomas Jefferson say of religious and civil government that “a connection between them is injurious to both.” The only protection the state can give Christianity is to let it alone,—keep its protecting hand off. True Christianity, that which takes the word of God for a guide, will never interfere with the state; it will always render the state its due in every particular. But it never will give to the state that which belongs to God. True Christianity will always be willing to go to prison or to the stake rather than to rob God. The man who will not do so is not a Christian. And the man or the power that causes him to be punished for faithfulness in upholding the word of God by precept and example is not Christian. The precept of Christ is, “As ye would that men should do to you, do ye also to them likewise.” No Sunday law ever contained such a sentiment as that; hence no Sunday law ever was indicted by the Spirit of Christ. Therefore no Sunday law ever could protect Christianity. The word of God foretells the spiritually powerless condition of apostate Christianity in the last days, which accounts for her frantic efforts to obtain secular power:— “This know also, that in the last days perilous times shall come. For men shall be lovers of their own selves, covetous, boasters, proud, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, unholy, without natural affection, trucebreakers, false accusers, incontinent, fierce, despisers of those that are good, traitors, heady, high-minded, lovers of pleasures more than lovers of God; having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof; from such turn away.” 2 Tim. 3:1–5. They deny the “power of godliness” when they demand the power of civil law to “protect” their “form of godliness.” W. N. G.