IS EASTER OBSERVANCE CONSISTENTLY PROTESTANT?
By Henry B. Maurer
WHAT, now, is the answer of Scripture to this question? Since Protestantism claims to be scriptural, and since many who call themselves Protestants observe Easter, and by its means commemorate the Saviour’s resurrection, we surely ought to find some justification in the Bible, either by command or example, for a festival that has become so important in Christendom. No one will deny but that Easter is a great institution, and great institutions must have firm foundations. The Protestant must look for such in the Bible. But so far is the Bible from giving any authority for its observance, that the following challenge of Archbishop Gibbons, “Read the Bible from Genesis to Revelation, and you will not find a single line authorizing the sanctification of Sunday” (“Faith of Our Fathers,” p. 108), applies with equal force to Easter. Not only is there no command, by nothing less than which can so great an institution be justified, but there positively is not the slightest hint, nor the slightest encouragement, by practice and example, anywhere to be found for the commemoration of any Biblical event by means of a day, save the Creator’s rest from his labors. The Acts of the Apostles contains the history of the church from its beginning until about the year 65 or 70. Throughout this entire history there is not to be found the slightest trace of the commemoration either of the death or resurrection of our Lord, save by the two ordinances, baptism and the Lord’s supper. What the intention of our Lord was in instituting these two ordinances, it might be well for Protestants to think of in this connection, and in the light of apostolic example and teaching. Perhaps the necessity of commemorating Christ’s death and resurrection by means of days and feasts is caused by a sense of the evident fitness of such commemoration; but we should “not be wise above that which is written,” by setting up feasts and days, a practice which received divine disapprobation in Old Testament times, and into which those very persons are retrograding who endeavor to exalt the new dispensation by gratuitously, unwarrantedly, and unnecessarily disparaging the old. The necessity of commemorating these events by days would not exist were they still commemorated by the only New Testament means, namely, the ordinances. Hence, Easter observance among Baptists, who still retain the ordinances intact, is a great inconsistency. A pastor of a Baptist Church was shown a newspaper paragraph, stating that the resurrection had not been8 commemorated in his church on Easter Sunday, when he replied, “O, yes it was, for I baptized a number of converts!” So far as Baptists and non-prelatical Christians approximate toward Easter observance, so far they give moral support to that system of feast days and Sundays of various names, of which it is the central point, and, in fact, they give moral support to ecclesiasticism itself. Who has not heard the boast that the dissenters are “coming around all right”? The absence of scriptural authority for such observances has caused another necessity, in order to make them seem consistently Protestant. The Bible must be made to justify these practices in order to make them seem Biblical. As the Bible is our only source of knowledge of divine institutions, an institution that is of human origin can be made to seem to be of divine origin, unless the Scriptures are wrested. Here we have a test. If there be a clear Scripture precept or example for an obligation, it is, of course, consistently Protestant to assume it; but if the Scriptures must be strained and unnaturally and forcibly interpreted in support of a practice, it is to be rejected. Any deviation from this rule opens a breach that lets in all the absurdities of Rome. Now let us examine all the texts that are pressed into service by the observers of Easter. The first texts belong to a series containing the expression “first day of the week.” The first objection to these texts is that if they were literally translated they would not contain the expression “first day of the week,” since it does not occur in the Greek. “The first [day] from the Sabbath” would be correct, and if the English Bible so had it, one great means of supporting Easter observance would be wanting. Again, those texts do not say that Jesus then arose. All the information given in them pertains to the discovery that the resurrection had occurred, but they do not say when. They give us accounts of several visits to the tomb, the earliest of which was “now late on the Sabbath” (Matt. 28:1), from which it appears that if it was discovered “late on the Sabbath” that Jesus had arisen, he could have arisen neither in the morning nor on the first day—all sentimental analogies, the teaching of hymnology, and prevailing theories to the contrary notwithstanding. The phrase “as it began to dawn” is another mistranslation, since between “in the end of the Sabbath” and “the dawn,” several hours of darkness intervened. In Luke 23:54 the same Greek word is more correctly rendered “drew on.” Another argument, supposed to be found in John 20:19-23, is that Jesus met with his disciples to commemorate his resurrection. No such idea is implied, for it is distinctly stated that with closed doors the disciples were together “for fear of the Jews,” and when the women told them of the empty tomb, Luke says, “Their words seemed like idle tales.” While they were in this state of mind Jesus appeared, not to commemorate, but, on the contrary, to prove the truth of the resurrection. Unbelief concerning the resurrection is hardly a preparation of heart and mind for its commemoration. Concerning this very matter, the Master said to his disciples, “O fools, and slow of heart to believe.” Another text impressed into this service is 1 Cor. 16:1, 2, from which it is argued that the apostle here refers to public gatherings on the first day of the week in commemoration of the resurrection. No such meaning can be taken from it. Light is thrown on the subject by comparing with the English rendering that found in other versions. The Latin has it, “Let each one of you at his own house lay up, putting away,” etc. Tyndale renders it, “Let every one of you put asyde at home, and laye uppe.” The Syriac Peshito: “Let every one of you lay aside and preserve at home.” Three French versions: “At his own house, at home.” The Dutch version is the same. The Italian has it: “In his own presence at home.” Spanish: “In his own house.” Portuguese: “With himself.” Swedish: “Near himself.” Douay Bible: “With himself.” Mr. Sawyer: “By himself.” Beza: “At home.” Wycliffe: “Let each one of you keep (or lay up) at himself” (Pickering’s edition, 1848). Gaultiere: “Put aside at home.” Here are eighteen translations which will not admit the idea of a public assembly or collection; but each one was to reckon up his accounts, and lay aside by himself according to his ability, and have it ready, as Paul, in his haste to relieve the sufferers at Jerusalem, might come unexpectedly. Another such proof text is Rev. 1:10, containing the expression “the Lord’s day.” In whatever sense John uses it, surely the expression can no more apply to a commemoration of the resurrection than to the commemoration of the finished work of the creation. If, in Revelation, the phrase “Lord’s day” is used to designate the commemoration of the resurrection, how does it happen that in John’s Gospel, written some years afterwards, the expression never occurs, nor the slightest hint concerning such a day as now this expression is quoted to support? Nowhere do we again meet with the expression “Lord’s day.” In view, therefore, of the silence of Scripture concerning such a commemoration by means of a day or festival, in view of the forced and unnatural interpretations placed on certain texts to support it, the answer of Scripture, like that of history, is that Easter observance is not consistently Protestant. There are many whose zeal for existing forms is willfully not according to their knowledge of Scripture and of history, to both of which they lend a deaf ear, so as not to be disturbed in their usages. So long as the dignity of a system is maintained, what matters it if the Bible suffer violence, and history offers instruction in vain.—Sabbath Recorder.