AdventAI

JUDGE PARKS’ REMARKS.

By W. B. G.

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 13., March 28, 1895

WHILE the remarks of Judge Parks in pronouncing judgment against some of our brethren in Rhea County, Tenn., which appear on page 2 of this paper, speak for themselves, there are two points which demand special attention:—

1. “Sunday is and for a long time has been recognized by nearly all Christian denominations as the Sabbath, and it is for this reason, no doubt, that the laws which protect that day have always been acquiesced in as constitutional.”

Note that the judge is too much of a lawyer to say that a recognition of a theory by Christian denominations makes a law supporting that theory constitutional, or that the acquiescence of the masses in the theory that the law is constitutional makes it so. He simply states a probable reason for the acquiescence. Nor does it require a lawyer to see that such conditions do not make a law constitutional. The statement, however, shows how a people may let their rights slip away and entangle themselves in bondage by a drowsy acquiescence in false theories upheld by those in whom they have confidence because of their religious profession. The dangerous position into which the people of this country have been deluded through acquiescence in bad laws because they are religious laws, and because they are designed to uphold that which is extensively recognized by religious denominations, is being shown up by these iniquitous persecutions. And while the acquiescence has gone to that extent that the shackles are no doubt permanently forged so far as there is any disposition of human power to remove them, these things may be a warning to liberty-loving people everywhere to avoid for themselves the spiritual enthrallment that such conditions are likely to entail. Furthermore, such results accruing from a blind acquiescence in civil laws for religious purposes, although upheld by Christian denominations as a protection of Christianity, ought to be a lesson to all that the so-called “Christian denominations” will bear watching when they put on the political harness, as well as other politicians. The cautious manner in which Judge Parks adverts to some of these conditions and assumptions, without indorsing them, should, and no doubt will, attract a closer attention on the part of thinking people to some of the things in which they are passively acquiescing.

2. “Their [the defendants’] position is not that of the person who claims that as a matter of personal liberty he has the right, if he chooses, to run an open saloon on Sunday, or to do any like act. That is not a matter of conscience—this is.”

Here the judge incidentally shows that he has not yet grasped the full meaning of Sunday laws. It is true that the work of the Lord is different from that of the saloon, but Seventh-day Adventists are not seeking special consideration in the matter of the execution of bad laws. The civil government has no more right to deal with the saloon evil from the standpoint of religion, or by means of a distinctively religious law, than it has to deal with Seventh-day Adventists from that standpoint or by means of such laws. Legitimately the civil law has nothing to do with religion in any connection whatever. Any distinction that ever has been made between Sunday and other days of the week, by law or by custom, has been on account of its alleged sacredness. Then any legislation which discriminates between Sunday and the other days is religious legislation. And religious legislation is a union of church and state—a union of state power with church influence, at the instigation of the church, to enforce a church tenet. Any law to close saloons or any other business on Sunday only is delegating the power of the state to enforce a church institution, and is to that extent an establishment of religion, a practical indorsement of the principle of church and state union.

The saloon nuisance is a bald imposition upon the peace and civil welfare of any community every day and night that it continues. It is a civil assault upon the peace of the community just as much as murder, theft, robbery, counterfeiting, etc.—in fact, it includes all of these and more in its results. Yet who ever thought of a law to suppress these crimes on Sunday only? A law closing saloons on Sunday is in no sense a temperance measure—it is a Sunday measure pure and simple. So far from being a temperance measure, it is a legal proclamation by the civil power, at the instance of Sunday adherents, that the saloon, in and of itself, is worthy of legal protection, and they are willing to extend to it the legal indulgence of six days’ freedom every week on condition that it will close on Sunday. Moreover, to emphasize this acknowledgment of the saloon’s legitimacy, those who advocate its restriction on Sunday only will also call for the closing of every other business on that day whenever and wherever they have sufficient influence to secure such action. This of itself is evidence that Sunday closing of saloons does not spring from a genuine temperance sentiment, but is merely an entering wedge to further Sunday legislation. W. B. G.