AdventAI

IS EASTER OBSERVANCE CONSISTENTLY PROTESTANT?

By Henry B. Maurer

From Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 12., March 21, 1895

BY HENRY B. MAURER.

Part I—History.

“Prove all things.” I Thess. 5:21.

That there may be no misunderstanding, the terms “Protestantism” and “Easter” need to be defined. What is Protestantism? It is a system of religious thought and action which protests. Before it received its name it was known, seen, and felt. It was, is, and ever must be, polemical. Protestants profess to contend for the divine as against the human in religion, “for the faith as it was once for all delivered unto the saints.” Protestantism is synonymous with intelligence, as against the too prevailing practice of believing doctrines, holding tenets, and assuming religious obligations, unintelligently. It claims to be Biblical, as against ecclesiasticism, its motto being, “The Bible, the Bible only, is the religion of Protestants,” in the words of Chillingworth. There is enough in that book, obedience to which demands so much of man’s energy and devotion, that to add extra Biblical practices thereto, unnecessarily increases man’s burdens, and takes his mind and strength from essentials.

Now, what is Easter? It is the feast observed on a specified Sunday each year, in commemoration of our Saviour’s resurrection. It has become, and with increasing momentum each year is becoming, a feature in religious circles, of such elaboration as hardly becomes the simplicity of the Gospel; of so esthetic and spectacular a nature that thousands flock to the churches that day to see the flowers, the tableaux, and to hear the music. If experience and observation could show that any good resulted from this display, or if it could, possibly, be more pleasing or do more honor to Christ, than the same energy and expenditure devoted to spiritual service and benevolence, the custom could no more be criticised than the good motives for its observance are misapprehended by right-thinking men; but history has shown that the tendency and effects of the spectacular in religion is baneful, while the practice of Easter observance is, unconsciously, and yet devoutly, by many, maintained at too dear a cost, other than a pecuniary one, for it is observed at the cost of the vital principles of Protestantism, as shown from two sources,—history and Scripture. By means of a historical and a scriptural argument, I propose to show that Easter observance is not consistently Protestant.

The word “Easter” is derived from Ostera, the name of an Anglo-Saxon pagan goddess. She received special homage in the spring, as nature began to revive or seemed to be rising into life. The transition from a season of bleak winds, cold rains, and hurricanes, which had produced depression of soul, to a season of promise and hope of better things, was an occasion of joy, especially with so demonstrative and emotional a people as the orientals are. We know how hopeful and joyous we feel in the spring. The festival of Easter, therefore, was the most joyous in the year. Among the many customs incident to it, one only now interests us, namely, that of exchanging and engaging in sport with eggs, the symbols of the revivication and the origin of nature, decorated in all imaginable ways. Hence the Easter egg. Such, briefly considered, was the pagan festival of Easter, which, in later and post-apostolic times, was given a Christian semblance. That the word “Easter” occurs in the Acts, does not militate against this view, for it and the presence of such expressions as “town clerk,” “robbers of churches,” etc., betray the inconsistency of the translators (A.D. 1611), who, for the Greek, selected English equivalents from expressions in current use, rather than give a true rendering. “Passover” rather than “Easter” is proper, as it appears in other places.

This festival had taken such deep root among our ancestors, the Anglo-Saxons, that when, in the fifth century, they were Christianized, it could not be eradicated. Rather than not gain them as converts, a compromise was effected. To conciliate these pagans, and yet not to offend the Christians, the old feast was allowed to remain, but was given a Christian aspect. The Jewish Passover, and the commemoration of Christ’s resurrection, occurred also in the spring, about the time of the festival of Ostera, or Easter. Our Lord’s resurrection was sentimentally represented as the beginning of a new creation, the springtime in the spiritual realm, the Easter, as it were, of Christendom, the spiritual world, as the festival of Ostera was to pagandom and the natural world. Between the resurrection and the revivication of nature, between the risen Lord and the rising sun, a sentimental analogy was set up which soon gained acceptance, for, while it was fanciful, it was, to an extent, beautifulp. 7 and inspiring, especially to the oriental mind. In the process of time the heathen aspect of the feast became absorbed by the Christian, and to-day the Easter festival exists in Christendom from such an origin and compromise. Not only this pagan element, but, what concerns us more particularly, a Romish element is inherent in this Easter festival as we now have it.

Before this amalgamation of these two festivals, a bitter controversy prevailed among the Christian churches as to whether, on a particular day of the week, or a particular day of the month, the resurrection should be commemorated. Neither Christ nor any of the apostles, by word or example, gave any encouragement to commemorate the resurrection, except by the ordinance of baptism, which, by its beautiful imagery and striking symbolical significance, represents his death by an immersion and his resurrection by an emersion, as taught in Rom. 6:4 and Col. 2:12. All of this the Romish Church has destroyed, as must be clear from the unused baptisteries in the European cathedrals, found there to this day, and in this work many Protestants to-day have taken part, as is also clear from the concessions of their candid scholars. Jesus or his disciples did not hint at the commemoration of any event recorded in Scripture, by means of a day, save the resting of Jehovah from the work of creation. So the practice of observing a day in commemoration of the resurrection, being of purely human origin, was the cause of strife. Truth, among its lovers, promotes peace and loveliness; error engenders discord and bitterness. The church at Jerusalem, and all the Asiatic churches, had fixed upon the 14th of Nisan, or April, as the date of our Saviour’s death, and his resurrection three days later.

The church at Rome and the Western churches determined that the Crucifixion had taken place on the preparation day, the day before the Sabbath, that is, Friday, the resurrection two days after, or, as it is called, the third day, or Sunday after the full moon on or next after the 21st of March. According to the practice at Jerusalem, the commemoration of the resurrection would fall on a different day of the week each year, while, according to the Roman plan, it would fall on Sunday. This soon became the cause of bitterness. Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, of martyrdom fame, visited Rome, representing the Eastern churches, to effect an agreement. The Western Church would not yield, while the Eastern Church did not, as it ought not, give up its position, for, being the older church, whose center was Jerusalem, where the Christian religion began and was first established, they surely were better qualified to know, if the resurrection should be commemorated at all, when it ought to be. This futile attempt at agreement was, later on, followed by another, when Polycrates, bishop of Ephesus, visited Rome, over which Victor was bishop at the time. He was informed that the Eastern churches would be excommunicated if they did not speedily adhere to the Romish or Western practice. This was the first serious transgression of the tranquillity of Christendom, and, mark you, what is now known as Easter observance was the cause. Many of the best Christians in the Western churches sympathized with Polycrates, but already favor was passing from the people to the priests, who determined such matters. To the threatened excommunication, Polycrates replied: “I, my brethren, who have lived five and sixty years in the Lord, who have conversed with my brethren over the whole world, who have read through the whole Scriptures, am nothing moved by the terrors [excommunication] which are held over us, for I know that it has been said by those who are far my superiors, ‘We must obey God rather than men.’”

From the fact that it was in the center of political power, wealth, and commercial influence, the church at Rome grew in power among the churches, as Rome became powerful among the nations. Ecclesiastically the Romish Church gained control over other churches, as, politically, Rome became the mistress of the world. So in this contest between the churches of Jerusalem and Asia and that of Rome and the West, if priority of existence, the prestige that belonged to Jerusalem and Palestine, the right and the truth (though these at this time were in the minority) had not been overcome by might, the question would not have been settled in favor of Rome as it was in A.D. 325, at the council of Nicaea, over which Constantine, the prince of pagans, presided. Hence this Romish element, which, as we have seen, was afterward combined with the pagan element, gave us the present Easter.

After the Reformation, the Lutheran and the Episcopal Churches only retained this festival. In this day the Presbyterian Church in some localities still seem to resist the introduction of the practice, while the Baptist and Methodist Churches are allowing it to gain admittance and to make headway among them.

When, now, the pagan origin of this festival, Christianized by uniting with it the commemoration of the resurrection, is recalled; when it is remembered that in a controversy those who, though in the minority, had right and truth, priority of existence, the prestige of coming from Jerusalem on their side; when it is remembered that, contrary to the anniversaries of all other events, which fall on a different day of the week each year, as does the Passover to this day, synchronous with which was the Crucifixion, the Romish Church determined that the anniversary of the resurrection should fall on the same day of the week each year; and when, finally, it is recalled that arrogantly Rome ruled it over the world then, as she does no less now over Protestants in this and a few other matters,—the answer of history is, “Easter observance is not consistently Protestant.”

(Concluded next week.)