Under the above heading a writer in the Catholic Mirror of February 16, gives some practical suggestions to Catholics relative to the present move towards “bridging over the stream” between Protestants and Catholics. We commend his remarks to all Protestants who are working for this “Christian unity.” The writer says:—
The question of “Christian unity” is at the present time agitating the minds of Catholics and non-Catholics alike. Deep in its significance and widespread in its consequences, it awakens lively expectations in those who see in it the only resource for a possible maintenance of religious principles among their followers who are surely drifting from them, and, at the same time, it arouses the sympathies of the Catholic universe to the possibilities of the situation, and causes them, after the example of our holy father in his encyclical Præclara, to open their hearts in charity to those sheep which are of but not in the fold, to seek them by word and example, and lead them to the fountain head of unity and peace.
Many of the sects, desirous of establishing unity, have turned their gaze to the Church of Rome, and, acknowledging her as the common mother of all Christian religion, have expressed their desire of meeting her half way in the cause of unity. They practically say, “Why should we be obliged to accept all that she teaches, while she will make no concession in our favor?”
If they would only examine our faith and see how much we hold in common belief, realizing at the same time, from what has been briefly stated above, how impossible it is for the church to change her doctrine, they would not surely make this complaint.
If the Protestant churches have imagined that Rome would in any whit change her plans and methods in order to meet them half way, the hope is a vain one. The ultimate aim of the “common mother” is the same now as it always has been, and that is universal acknowledgment of the Church of Rome and her ways as supreme. The present move is assuredly “deep in its significance,” but Catholics see the true meaning of the significance, which is a trending Romeward by professed Protestants. Of course the “possibilities of the situation” are immense, sufficiently large to open up a boundless “charity” on the part of all Catholics toward the lost sheep.
In addition to this encyclical “Præclara,” the pope has stated, in his encyclical of Dec. 24, 1894, concerning the object of the church to gather all to its fold: “Acting under the inspiration of Apostolic charity, We have for a long time made it the object of Our solicitous thought. . . . It would be the fullest realization of Our vows if it should be given to Us to hasten the arrival of the time promised by God when ‘there will be but one fold and one Shepherd.’”
In the face of these open declarations of Rome’s hopes, which have always been proclaimed, and only recently reiterated, and which are not hid from Protestants, we can only conclude two things,—that the Protestants in the bargain are fondly expecting to come out ahead at the climax, and that the end justifies the means, or that at bottom they have a growing realization of the fact that their followers are “surely drifting from them,” and that refuge and healing lie alone with the old “mother church,” as claimed by Catholics themselves. This is what Rome means by “Christian unity,”—a return in toto to Rome, and if charity is one way to accomplish that end, there are other ways that have been used when she had the temporal power:
But what is included in this idea of unity as it is understood by the Catholic Church?—Temporal, or state power, always. There is one expression in the late encyclical from Rome that has become very familiar, because of the amount of criticism and comment bestowed upon it at large. It is that the church (Catholic, of course) “would bring forth more abundant fruits if, in addition to liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws and patronage of the public authority.” It would seem that the purport of this expression is so plain that no one, even at first glance, can fail of seeing its meaning. And, apparently, no one who has had the courage to speak concerning it, has failed to place it where it belongs. But naturally it is defended by Catholics, and the criticisms upon it are ridiculed by them. Now, having before us the Roman Catholic meaning of “unity,” which has always been defined by that church as the “one fold,” under “one shepherd,”—the church and the pope,—read this defense of the pope’s words, quoted above, by the Sacred Heart Review:—
If the people of this country were all Catholics, it would undoubtedly be for the advantage of the church to be recognized by the laws of the land, and for the civil and ecclesiastical power to work in harmony for the good of all. This is the theory of that passage in the holy father’s latest encyclical, which has been so hastily criticised by some writers who failed to understand it. No one in his senses supposes that the pope looks to a union of church and state in our own country; first, because it is impossible, and next, because it is undesirable. The attempt to get up a popular alarm and agitation on this score is useless and ridiculous.
But if there were one grand unity, and all the people, or only a majority of the people, of this country were in that Catholic unity, how long would it be before that ecclesiastical power would “enjoy the favor of the laws and the patronage of public authority”? Surely the church would not leave untaken anything that would be to her “advantage,” and the church is infallible! A very good elucidation, indeed, of the “theory” of the “holy(?) father’s” words. It strangely coincides with the plain English reading of them. In view of such a clear understanding of the question, as set forth in the first portion of this defense, the latter part is marvelous. We have italicized a portion as being an exceedingly interesting and astonishing deduction from the preceding and other showings in the case.
Surely the Sacred Heart Review does not intend to convey the impression that the astute see of Rome has nothing more important on his hands than a vain hope and fruitless effort after the “impossible”! And, by its own words, it would be worse than inane to desire the “undesirable.” No, indeed! This plain contradiction is but a handful of dust intended for the eyes of Protestants. And it will be well for Protestants to rub well their eyes, and look again. Popular alarm and agitation on this score are not useless and ridiculous. The time is ripe to raise the alarm, and for true Protestants to be aroused when professed Protestants—protestants against Rome—join hands with Rome in any enterprise having for its object the exalting of the “man of sin.”
The principles of the union of church and state are fundamental parts of Roman Catholicism, and when professed Protestants confess the lack of the Holy Spirit, and turn to the state for power, the inevitable next step is to join with Rome. Then, indeed, therep. 3 are many things “in common belief,” and the “mother church” recognizes her opportunity, and will improve it to the fullest. This lack of spirituality in the churches is deplored long and loud by professed Protestant ministers, and the confession is logically followed by orders, associations, and federations for the suppression of evil and corruption. And, in order that there may be harmony in the unity with Rome, it is certain that no plans but Rome’s will be tolerated.
And God’s prophetic word has told us that Rome will succeed in securing the homage and adoration that she seeks (Rev. 13:12), and has pointed out the relation that exists between her and those that do as she does and has done (Rev. 17:5). In view of her judgments the call goes forth: “Come out of her, my people, that ye be not partakers of her sins, and that ye receive not of her plagues.” Rev. 18:4.
Protestants, be Protestants, and beware. The power of the Holy Spirit is not found in the arm of politics nor in the Church of Rome. “Put not your trust in princes, nor in the son of man, in whom there is no help.” Ps. 146:3. “Trust ye in the Lord forever; for in the Lord Jehovah is everlasting strength.” Isa. 26:4. “Christian unity” with Rome means Rome altogether, and “Christian unity” with the state means Rome in the end. “Christian unity” with any save Christ, and working in any way but his way, means utter destruction. L. A. P.