The superior general of the Paulist Fathers, Rev. Dr. Augustine F. Hewitt, is credited by the Catholic Mirror, quoting from the Catholic World, with the following expression:—
We do not cherish any absurd wish that the United States, or any single State, should establish the Catholic religion. There is none so insane as to conspire and plot to bring about the realization of such an impossible scheme.
This is in keeping with the characteristic shrewdness of the papal power. It has gained more in the direction of having its religion established in the United States by pretended unconcern than in any other way. By this means so-called Protestantism has often been thrown off its guard. Rome knows full well that any avowed attempt to have the general government or any state openly establish the Catholic religion would result disastrously to that object.
In this State, a few years ago, a gentleman asked a Catholic priest, “What is your church going to do with the Religious Amendment [to the U. S. Constitution] movement? are you going to vote for it?” “O,” said the priest, “we have nothing to do with that! We leave that to the Protestants; we let them do all that. They are coming to us, and we only have to wait.” So when the Protestant National Reformers shall have extended the principle of a religious government to the desired climax, they will have so far gone into the lap of Rome that the religion so established will be practically the “Catholic religion.”
Again, the shrewdness of Rome in allowing the Protestants to do her work for her, was at another time illustrated in Pittsburg. In this instance a Catholic prelate was solicited to unite in the work of the National Reform movement; but he declined on the ground that it would be a detriment to the cause for Catholics to become identified with it. The reason given was that if Catholics joined the movement it would be a cause of suspicion on the part of Protestants who had not yet identified themselves with the cause.
When the time comes for Rome to reap the fruit, she will not be backward in thrusting in her sickle. In the very disavowal of Dr. Hewitt, quoted at the beginning of this article, he makes the following stultifying admission:—
It is true that the pope says that the church would bring forth more abundant fruits if, in addition to the liberty, she enjoyed the favor of the laws and the patronage of the public authorities. Such a state of religious unity and harmony we must, of course, regard as desirable, but it is only ideal, and there is no practical utility in speculations upon the happy effects it might produce.
To say that the Roman hierarchy will not “conspire and plot to bring about” that which “would bring forth more abundant fruits,” is to deny her entire history. But Pope Leo XIII. is on record with more emphatic language on this subject than his Paulist apologist seems willing to set forth. As long ago as 1885 he published an “Encyclical Letter,” in which he said:—
All Catholics should do all in their power to cause the constitutions of States, and legislation, to be modeled on the principles of the true church, and all Catholic writers and journalists should never lose sight for an instant from the view of the above prescription.
Now we do not suppose for a moment that Dr. Hewitt has “lost sight for an instant” of the pope’s design to have the constitutions of States modeled on the principles of his church. On the contrary, it is quite clear that his crafty denial, on behalf of the hierarchy, of cherishing any such “absurd wish,” is with a view to furthering that very object. Nor do we suppose that the Catholic World and the Catholic Mirror, in publishing such a sentiment, have “lost sight for an instant” of thep. 2 papal design. All these parties are shrewd enough to know that the National Reform spirit in the professed Protestant church is doing Rome’s work for her to better advantage than if the Romanists themselves were to openly espouse the cause. It is because these “Catholic writers and journalists” have not “lost sight for an instant” of the church’s “prescription” that they endeavor to distract public attention not only from the hold she already has on the governments of the nation and of most of the states, but from the further establishment of the Catholic religion in the laws and constitutions. But here is another crafty utterance, well calculated to deceive the unwary:—
It is un-American for the State to ally itself with the sect of the secularists to the exclusion of all other sects, and to discriminate against religious societies as coworkers in the cause of religion and morality. This is not the legitimate separation of state from the church, but hostility of state against church.
But these “Catholic writers and journalists” have always maintained that the Catholic Church is not a sect; therefore it would not be “un-American for the state to ally itself” to that church, for, says Dr. Hewitt:—
We have no doubt that it would be the greatest possible blessing to the nation, even in a temporal and worldly sense, if all, or a majority, of its citizens were to embrace the Catholic religion and live according to its precepts and rules.
Certainly it would not be “un-American” for the state to make any alliance that would bring “the greatest possible blessing to the nation even in a temporal and worldly sense.” And here are some specifications of principles set forth as not “un-American”:—
Our greatest jurists have declared that it is a Christian country. Sunday is recognized and its observance protected by law. Thanksgiving and fast days are proclaimed by authority. Chaplains are appointed in Legislatures, in the army and navy. Colleges under the control of ecclesiastics and institutions of charity have been liberally aided, and among these some institutions under the direction of Catholic authorities. There is nothing in this policy which is un-American. It would be contrary to the spirit and letter of our laws to favor one denomination above others.
But from the Catholic standpoint that church is not a mere “denomination;” it is “the church,” the “universal church.” This is always maintained by every Catholic authority, and from their view it has not been “contrary to the spirit and letter of our laws to favor” the Catholic Church with more appropriations from the public treasury than all the Protestant denominations combined. While “our greatest jurists have declared that this is a Christian country,” it must not be forgotten that Rome has always regarded herself the Christian church, and all others heretics. Then, from her standpoint, a Christian country is essentially a Catholic country. Neither should it be forgotten that when “our greatest jurists” (the Supreme Court) “declared that this is a Christian country,” their opinion was based largely upon a long series of Catholic documents and precedents. The Supreme Court decision, from the premises adopted, might as logically have been that “this is a Catholic nation,” as that it “is a Christian nation.” When Dr. Hewitt, or any other intelligent Catholic writer, disavows a wish on the part of the Catholic authorities to have the United States establish a Catholic religion, Protestants may lay up the assertion with the many other crafty devices by which the aims of the Papacy are accomplished. W. N. G.