Baptist Ministers Criticize the Flood of Hymn Books

33%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Feb 28, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 9.

Read the full edition

Baptist Ministers Criticize the Flood of Hymn Books

AT the Baptist Ministers’ Meeting in San Francisco last week, Rev. J. Downie read a paper justly criticising the “multitude of hymn books that pour down upon the churches every year.” Here is a specimen utterance:—
“Amidst all this poetizing and music-grinding there is one prominent feature which is to me very reprehensible—the parodying, imitating, mutilating, and altering that go on—the meddling and muddling, the rending and mending, the matching and patching. In no trade is there so much gerrymandering nor so much cobbling as in this. Around every inspired hymn or heaven-born tune there is built a mass of flimsy, gimcrack imitation ones.”