TYRANNY OF THE U. P. CHURCH

6%

Pacific Press Publishing Company · Oakland, California · Feb 7, 1895

FromSigns of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 6.

Read the full edition

TYRANNY OF THE U. P. CHURCH.

The United Presbyterian Church, as exemplified in a recent action of the synod of Ohio, stands upon a most incongruous platform. While professing to be Protestant, this action shows it to be Roman in fundamental principle. The case, as it appears in the record of proceedings of the session of 1894, is as follows:—
The Committee on the Judiciary, in reference to the appeal of Mr. J. K. Andrews, from the action of the Muskingum Presbytery, respectfully submit the following report:—
Mr. Andrews was suspended by the session of Londonderry Congregation for making determined opposition to one of the principles of the United Presbyterian Church, viz., that the first day of the week is the holy Sabbath, as set forth in the answer to the fifty-ninth question of the shorter catechism.
From this action an appeal was taken to Muskingum Presbytery.
Upon the hearing of the case, on April 3, 1894, the presbytery of Muskingum unanimously refused to sustain the appeal.
From this action of presbytery an appeal was taken to the synod of Ohio, and the records and papers in the case are regularly before the court, according to the law of judicial process.
It is submitted that this case is not to be determined by the law of judicial process, but reaches back of that, and involves, and is to be determined by, fundamental law. That all the steps required by the law of judicial process, necessary to bring a case regularly before the court, have been taken in this case, is admitted. But, that anyone may claim the advantages of compliance with the law of judicial process in any case of actual process, he must stand upon and express his adherence to the fundamental, organic, constitutional law of the church, upon which the law of actual process is based. Again, it is submitted that there can be no defense against the charge, which is admitted by the appellant, but such as will involve “making a plea against the principles of his public profession,” which is in direct violation of the law of judicial process. A plea against his own public profession is not only a virtual but an actual plea against, and denial of, the public profession of the church, and consequently of the truth and righteousness of her fundamental, organic, constitutional law.
The appellant, in adhering to his determined opposition to the fundamental law of the church, as a matter of conscientious conviction, has placed himself without her communion, and beyond the shield of her legal protection, and has no right to claim any privileges that might accrue from compliance with the law of judicial process, while at the same time denying constitutional law upon which the law of process is based.
Therefore, Resolved:—
  1. That the appellant, by his plea against his own public profession, against the public profession of the church, and her fundamental law, can claim no rights under a law that he has renounced, and can have no standing in this court, or any court of the United Presbyterian Church.
  2. That this position can in no sense be construed as an infringement upon the appellant's personal liberty or his rights of conscience.
T. BALPH, D. M. SLEETH, T. F. MOOREHEAD.
Mr. Andrews gave notice of appeal to the assembly. Synod declared that the right to appeal would not be granted.
We give the record in full in order to show that the conclusion which we draw is from the synod's own statement of the case. It is admitted by that body that all the steps “necessary to bring a case regularly before the court have been taken,” but the fact that Mr. Andrews' present position is against his profession as a United Presbyterian, and against the public profession of the church, leaves him without any rights in that tribunal. If he should adhere to the “fundamental law of the church,” which includes the very ground of his objection and cause of his dismissal, then he would be accorded the right of defense. But then he would not need defense, for there would be no charge against him. It is equivalent to saying to Mr. Andrews, “If you recant, you can lawfully come before the synod and defend yourself.” Yet the synod claims that “this position can in no sense be construed as an infringement upon the appellant's personal liberty or his rights of conscience.” Such a claim, such a “position,” outromans Rome. If the principle is good in the synod, it is good in the presbytery, and it is good in the individual church. But Rome is still further outromanned in the refusal to grant an appeal to the General Assembly. And this because Mr. Andrews does not stultify his position by adherence to the fundamental law of the church, of which the point in issue is a part, and thus admit that he is in the wrong. In the U. P. Church, according to this action of the synod of Ohio, a conscientious dissenter from the fundamental law is not entitled to a defense unless he adheres to that law from which his conscience dissents—in other words, until he recants.
But the point in which this church, according to the action herein cited, stands squarely on Roman ground is in the fact that the first-day-of-the-week sabbath is set forth as one of the principles. Not only so, but a trial for denying that it is the holy Sabbath “involves, and is to be determined by, fundamental law.” As the Sunday institution is the badge of authority set forth by the papal church, and was instituted solely on the authority of that church, any church which adopts the institution as a fundamental principle stands logically and actually on Roman ground. The Council of Laodicea, A. D. 364, decreed that the services of the Sabbath should be transferred to the first day of the week, and any who should continue to “Judaize” (keep the seventh-day Sabbath) should be anathematized. And now, in the United Presbyterian Church, one who keeps the seventh day and ignores the Sunday institution, “as a matter of conscientious conviction, has placed himself without her communion and beyond the shield of her legal protection.” The act of publicly questioning the scriptural authority of Sunday observance, and believing that the seventh day of the week should be observed, is the reason given by the Londonderry congregation for suspending Mr. Andrews; and the synod of Ohio decrees that in such condition he has no redress and no right of appeal to higher authority. How many more steps must such a church take in order to step into the fold of Rome?—It has but one step to take, and that is to formally acknowledge the supremacy of the “sovereign pontiff.” It has already acknowledged Roman precedent, and made it a matter of fundamental law.
W. N. G.