AdventAI

The Errors of the Educated

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 54, No. 49., December 4, 1906

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—Our French teacher will be back next week, and I suppose we shall have to organize our class for the season. 1.

Mrs. Up-to-date.—I hardly think that I shall join the class this year, for I really feel that I should study English instead; and I haven't time for both studies.

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—Study English! How absurd! Pardon me; but you speak as correctly as I do, and I can detect the slightest error in another's speech. I am sure that you never use bad grammar. 2.

THE HERCULES BEETLE
THE HERCULES BEETLE Restored with AI

Mrs. Up-to-date.—Thank you; but I know that I do not merit your compliment, for although I have given the subject of English much attention, I now see that I am only on the threshold, so to speak, of an understanding of what constitutes correct diction.

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—You ought not to feel that way about it. 3. For my part, I should feel very badly if I thought that I needed the magazine to which you refer. 4. After devoting all the time that we did to grammar when in school, it would be discouraging indeed to think we needed to continue the study now. It is certainly no use to take up English after one leaves school, providing, of course, that one has had the right kind of a teacher. 5. 6. 7.

Mrs. Up-to-date.—Oh! you know, in school we study grammar, but we do not pay much attention to the application of its rules and principles. Then, again, there are many objectionable forms of diction to which no reference whatever is made in any text-book on grammar.

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—Yes; but if grammar does not compass all points involved in correct diction, rhetoric certainly supplements the rules of grammar, so that the ground is completely covered.

Mrs. Up-to-date.—You are right so far as general rules and principles are involved; but we must not forget that these rules and principles are, after all, only general in their application, and that unless we study words, individually, we can never learn how to speak and write correctly.

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—I wish that you would explain your meaning. I don't hardly think I understand you. 8.

Mrs. Up-to-date.—It is like this. As we both know, there is a rule in rhetoric, under Precision, that requires the use of the word that shall best express the meaning; but in order to conform to this rule, one must study words and their uses. Now, no text-book on either grammar or rhetoric can cover this phase of the subject,—the right word in the right place; and in this respect, I find the magazine Correct English most helpful, for it is continually telling us what to say and what not to say.

Mrs. I-know-it-all.—Notwithstanding your enthusiasm, I shall still feel that if one has had a collegiate education,—has studied both grammar and rhetoric under excellent teachers,—and if in addition to this, one's associations are with cultured people, one will be liable to use correct English at all times. 9.

Notes

  1. 1.“Be back” should not be used for “come back.” Inasmuch as “back” denotes direction toward a starting-point, the word “come,” and not “be,” is required to make the expression significant. ↩
  2. 2.“Good grammar” and “bad grammar” are meaningless terms, for the reason that the term “grammar” implies a scientific conformity of thought to speech; hence, some other expression must be substituted; as, “correct English” or “incorrect English,” as the case may require. ↩
  3. 3.“Should” is the better word when mere propriety is expressed, “ought” being more especially used to express moral obligation. Thus: one says, “I should go to the city to-day;” “The child ought to obey his parents.” ↩
  4. 4.“Feel bad,” and not “feel badly,” is the required form. (Compare with “feel sad,” “feel glad,” etc.) ↩
  5. 5.“It is certainly of no use,” not, “It is certainly no use,” is the required form, the preposition “of” being required to express the relationship that exists between the word “use” and the verb “is.” ↩
  6. 6.The conjunction “provided,” and not the participle “providing,” is the required part of speech. ↩
  7. 7.“A” is superfluous after “kind” or “sort;” thus, one should say, “The right kind of teacher,” “The right sort of thing,” etc. ↩
  8. 8.“I hardly understand,” and not “I don’t hardly understand,” is correct. It is the careless speaker who says, “I don’t hardly know,” and “I can’t hardly wait.” The person who makes these errors would feel aggrieved if he were accused of using two negatives. He would never think of saying: “I can’t wait no longer,” and yet it is as incorrect to say, “I can’t hardly wait,” as to say, “I can’t wait no longer;” and “I don’t hardly know what to say,” is as incorrect as “I don’t know no more.” ↩
  9. 9.“Apt” or “likely,” and not “liable,” is the correct word. Thus: apt indicates a natural fitness or tendency; physical tendency or inward inclination; as, “He is apt to catch cold;” “He is apt to go to sleep in church;” “He is apt to study hard;” “He is apt to make mistakes.” Likely is interchangeable with apt when natural fitness or tendency is expressed; as, “He is likely to do it,” or “He is apt to do it.” But when mere external probability is expressed, likely, and not apt, is correctly used; as, “He is likely to come at any moment;” “It is likely to rain to-day.” Liable should never be used interchangeably with apt or likely, as it properly refers only to a possible event regarded as unfavorable; as, “He is liable to have an accident;” “He is liable to die at any moment.”—Correct English. ↩