Letters Sent in for Criticism

3%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · March 26, 1907

FromThe Youth's Instructor, Vol. LV, No. 13

Read the full edition

Letters Sent in for Criticism

AFTER Mr. Henry Rose closed his excellent series of articles on letter writing, the editor asked the young people to write letters, allowing the criticisms to be made in the Instructor for the benefit of others. Only a few have had courage or interest sufficient to do this. An honest, fair criticism upon one’s work is something that the most learned men and women are anxious to receive; so those who are just beginning to climb the ladder of knowledge ought to be very glad for any suggestion along any line that will help them to mount the ladder most successfully.
The letters that appear this week have not been carelessly written. The authors have been quite painstaking and thoughtful, but not enough so; for the standard is perfection.
HOLLY MICHIGAN Dec 13 1906
DEAR CHUM—
I will now try and answer your kind and welcome letter, in regard to our young people’s society.
We organized our society eight weeks ago next Sabbath.
We thought it would be best to have our meeting’s separate.
The young lady’s meeting is held in the parlor of the girls home, and ours in the chapel. Our meetings commence at three o’clock and last until four. We have three speakers to talk to us on any subject they choose, each is supposed to talk fifteen minutes.
Every four weeks the societies meet in Union meeting, and have two speakers from each society and we commence our meetings, at two thirty.
We organized our society so as to get practise in public speaking and being able to think what we wanted to say on our feet. We expect to bring in some missionary work in the near future.
We elect our officers, President & Secretary, every four weeks, to take their office the first meeting after the union meeting.
Well I must close and study my Bible lesson.
As ever your chum
HOWARD.
Master Howard Dix has given us an easy, straightforward description of the work of the Young People’s Societies, and I think his friend would be glad to get his letter. It is said that in one of the great insurance suits after the San Francisco fire, the company lost four and one-half million dollars, because of the position of a comma. Our government, too, once lost several thousand dollars because of an error in punctuation; so it may sometime be worth much to the author of this letter to be able to punctuate well what he writes. A period and comma should follow the abbreviation Dec.; a comma should follow 13, and a period should be placed after 1906.
The salutation “Dear Chum” should be followed by a comma and dash at least. Some use a colon.
“I will now try and answer” should be “I shall now try to answer.” The apostrophe should follow the s in ladies, and there should be an apostrophe after the s in the phrase “girls’ home.” The word commence is all right; but begin is considered better than commence, if there is no reason why the substitution can not be made. At the close of the fourth paragraph it would be better to say “at half-past two o’clock” instead of “at two thirty.”
In the fifth paragraph the sentence would be balanced better if it read, “to get practise in public speaking and power to think what we wanted to say while on our feet.” In the seventh paragraph the word and should be used instead of the sign.
Master Howard likes new things, I know, especially if they are better than the old, so does his friend, therefore let him find some new way to end his letter instead of saying, “Well, I must close and study my Bible lesson.” The idea of laying aside the writing of a letter for the study of a Bible lesson may be new to many persons, but the first part of the sentence is familiar to every one.
HOLLY, MICH.
12, 12, 1906.
Miss Lillian Rose,
Loma, Linda, Cal.
MY DEAR LILLIE:—
I have told you about this school and the work here but do not think I have yet told you about our Young Peoples Society and I am sure you will be interested to know what we are doing along that line.
We believe that we have a message to give to the world and we know that the burden will soon fall on us who are now young people; because of this we have banded ourselves together, believing that the training we will receive in our “Self-culture Society” will render us more efficient to co-operate with Christ in the work of spreading this message.
Each Sabbath afternoon at three o’clock we have our meeting. For officers we have a Leader and a Secretary. Each Sabbath we have two or three of the students present a subject, the object being to make them able to “think on their feet.”
We have two divisions to our society,—that is, the young men and young women hold their meetings separately and once every four weeks we have a union meeting.
As this society is still in its infancy we have seen no marked results as yet, but we are trying to get a training in order that we may be efficient workers and we are praying to grow spiritually so that when the time comes for us to step out in active service for our Master we can enter into the work whole heartedly.
Asking you to remember the work here, I remain,
Yours with kindest regards,
BEATRICE HARTER.
In Miss Harter’s letter there should be a comma after the abbreviation “Mich.” It is better to write the name of the month instead of its number. The apostrophe is omitted in the word “People’s”—Young People’s Society. A comma should follow the word “society,” because of the relation of the two co-ordinate clauses. The expression, “but think I have not yet told you,” would be preferable to “but do not think I have yet told you.”
“To think on their feet” is a common expression, and perhaps its meaning is usually understood; but since it is not intended that “on their feet” shall tell upon what subject they are to think, but rather to suggest that persons are to be trained to think clearly and quickly while standing before an audience, would it not be better to state simply that fact, or at least say “think while on their feet?”
The fourth paragraph would be improved by saying: “We have two divisions to our Society, the young men and women having separate sessions. Once a month a union meeting is held.”
Wouldn’t the thought in the fifth paragraph be more directly expressed, if the sentence read, “but we are trying to get a training that will make us efficient workers. We are also praying that we may grow spiritually so that,” etc?
If Miss Harter would sprinkle in a few more commas, in the right place of course, and omit in one or two places the conjunction and, making a new sentence, her letter would merit the word—dear to every true student’s heart—excellent.