AdventAI

A LESSON IN PUNCTUATION.

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 38, No. 42., October 15, 1890

Henry Thompson, a lad twelve years old, sat in his father's study, one day, carefully copying a composition which was to be handed in to his teacher the following Monday. Henry prided himself on his neat handwriting, and especially on his flourishing capital letters; so when he reached the bottom of the page, he surveyed his composition with great satisfaction. His sister Helen, two years older, came in at this moment, and wanted to see it.

“Well, what do you think of it?” he asked, when she had finished reading it, and laid it down.

“I think the handwriting looks very neat,” she replied.

But Henry was not satisfied with this comment, which seemed to him like “damning with faint praise,” so he asked,—

“What makes you talk as if something was the matter with it? What fault do you find with it?”

“It is not punctuated, if you wish me to tell you candidly what is the matter with it.”

“Oh, that is no great matter,” replied he. “It seems to me there is very little sense in those dots and marks.”

“You are mistaken,” said his sister. “There is a great deal of sense in them, and we could not make out the meaning, either in books or letters, but for these marks.”

“Well, I am not going to bother myself about them,” replied Henry, “so long as I spell the words correctly, and write them neatly.”

“But that is not sufficient,” said Helen; “you have made a jumble of your composition by neglecting to punctuate it, although you have spelled the words right. You are writing about the reign of Queen Elizabeth, but by failing to punctuate it, there are several sentences in which the meaning is not at all clear. No one can tell whether they refer to Elizabeth, or to Mary Queen of Scots, of whom you also make mention. You use phrases which may either pass for the end of one sentence, or the beginning of the next. Nothing but punctuation can determine this point clearly.”

“Here, give me back my composition!” said Henry, rather snappishly, betraying a touch of sensitiveness at seeing his writings criticised.

This was the early spring, and Henry was looking forward with great delight to the approaching holidays, which his father had promised him he might spend in the country with a favorite cousin. Bright visions danced before his eyes of the delightful times he would have in the country, going on fishing excursions along the banks of streams fringed by the early green of the willows, or else roaming the forest for the trailing arbutus and other early spring flowers. His father stipulated that he should write to his cousin concerning the visit several days beforehand, and Henry accordingly sat down and wrote the following letter:—

“My dear John,—I hear we are going to have a big circus in town on Thursday next I am going to have a holiday and want to go to your house so please meet me at the train on the 30th inst my father is going on a trip to New York” etc., etc.

In a day or two he received an encouraging reply by postal card: “All right; I’ll meet you on the day appointed.”

Accordingly, on the following Thursday, Henry took the train, and after an hour’s ride, got off at the station nearest to his cousin’s home. He peered about eagerly in the crowd for John, but could see no trace of him.

“I suppose their clock was too slow, and so he did not start in time to meet the train,” said Henry to himself, “but I am sure he will be here in a little while;” and he paced up and down the platform, watching for John’s familiar form and pony. But an hour passed without his coming, and then two hours, and Henry began to feel seriously annoyed and discomfited. The sun was beginning to sink in the west, so it was necessary for Henry to take some decisive step. John lived five miles from the station, and Henry could not find even the roughest wagoner going in that direction. On this ill-fated evening, all were going in a contrary direction, so Henry had no resource except to walk to his destination.

At first it seemed pleasant enough to trudge along through the mild spring air, and amid the tender spring blossoms, but after awhile he began to feel the weight of his satchel and fishing-tackle, and to be pinched by a pair of new shoes he was wearing; altogether it proved a very tedious and fatiguing walk, and he was not a little relieved when he saw the chimney and gables of his cousin’s home loom in sight.

As he approached the house, he noticed with surprise that it was not lighted up, and that it had a singularly quiet and deserted air. He had to knock at the door a dozen times before he made himself heard; at length, however, an elderly man who lived in the back yard, and who did gardening for the family, came round to the front of the house, and when he had at length been made to understand who Henry was, gave him the disheartening information that John, together with the rest of the family, had gone off to spend the holidays with an aunt of his.

“That certainly is strange, when I wrote him I was coming!” exclaimed Henry, astonished and wounded at such a breach of courtesy on John’s part; but the old man was not prepared to furnish any explanation of John’s conduct, nor any excuse for it. It was now bed-time, so there was nothing to do but to remain there that night.

After an early breakfast, furnished by the old gardener, Henry returned to the station, and took the first homeward-bound train, reaching home thoroughly dejected and crest-fallen. His family would have rallied him on his brief and unavailing expedition, had they not seen how deeply he felt the sting of John’s supposed unkindness, and indeed they could not help feeling offended at it themselves, as well as greatly mystified. But two days after the holidays were over, Henry received a letter from John filled with regret and concern, and giving an explanation of his conduct. John wrote:—

“I had no idea, from the way you expressed yourself, that you intended coming here last Thursday. The mistake occurred because your letter was not punctuated. I inclose it back to you, so you may see for yourself how it occurred. I was greatly disappointed, on my return home, to find that you had been here and found me absent. I can only beg that you will come again, at the earliest possible opportunity, and next time make it clearly understood what day you appoint for coming.

“Your affectionate cousin,

“JOHN.”

“Yes,” said Henry’s father, after reading over the letter inclosed, “your letter may be construed into saying, ‘We are going to have a big circus on Thursday next,’ though you simply intend to say, ‘We are going to have a big circus,’ without specifying the time; and you meant the phrase, ‘on Thursday next,’ to form the beginning of your second sentence, instead of the ending of your first. Again, the phrase, ‘on the 30th inst.,’ might be, and indeed was, construed by your cousin to refer to your visit to him, instead of referring to my trip to New York, as you intended it, all of which misunderstanding might have been prevented, if you had paid a little attention to punctuation.

“You are not the only person, Henry, who has suffered inconvenience or damage from defective punctuation, on their own part, or that of others. I have heard of a man’s losing his insurance policy from defective punctuation in the drawing up of the papers, and I have heard of legacies being lost in a similar way. It is almost impossible to form an accurate idea of the meaning and connection of words, unless they be properly divided into phrases and sentences by means of punctuation.”

We need scarcely tell our readers that from this time forth Henry became as conspicuous for his attention to punctuation as he had formerly been for his neglect of it.—Children’s Magazine.