The last United States Congress passed what is now known as the income-tax law, hoping from it to derive a large amount of revenue, which would be necessary because of the general lowering of duties on foreign imports, resulting from the Wilson bill. This law provided that all incomes amounting to four thousand dollars or over, annually, should be taxed. It was the expectation of those who were instrumental in making this law that it would secure to the government the sum of one hundred million dollars annually.
Since the law was passed, the internal revenue department, through its agents in the several States, has sent blanks to all persons who are supposed to have an annual income of four thousand dollars or more, that they might fill them out, and thus the officers of the revenue would be put in the way of collecting the tax; but many people whose incomes were sufficiently large to come under the provisions of this law refused to submit to it, and some thought the law itself was unconstitutional, and they contested in the courts the right of the government to draw money out of the people by a direct tax. The cases of some parties were finally taken to the Supreme Court of the United States for decision upon the constitutionality of the law, and that body, which is the highest court in the United States, hasp. 147 given all the decision it can give, for the justices which comprise that court appear to be hopelessly divided in regard to the matter.
The following is a synopsis of the position or positions the court holds in regard to this law: All the members of the court who were present held that incomes derived from state and municipal bonds cannot be subject to the tax, because it would be contrary to the Constitution. Six of the justices held that incomes arising from real estate cannot be taxed by the general government, for the same reason. Four of the justices,—half of them, Justice Jackson being ill and not present,—think the whole law unconstitutional. As they are equally divided upon the general features of the law, the tax will undoubtedly be collected in those cases except where a clear majority of the court held it to be contrary to the Constitution. Great dissatisfaction seems to prevail among the common people, that wealthy men are exempt, while men of less means are to be taxed. The general impression now is that the Supreme Court, instead of clearing up the question, has made it more difficult; and as it is, the expected hundred million dollars will not very likely be secured, and some other way of raising money will have to be devised.