END OF THE INCOME TAX

25%

S. D. A. Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 6, 1895

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 23.

Read the full edition

END OF THE INCOME TAX.

THE income-tax law, which was a creation of the last Congress, and whose constitutionality has been a matter of discussion, has at last been entirely annulled by a decision of the United States Supreme Court. Reference has been made before in these columns to the divided condition of the court at the time of a previous sitting. May 20 what is apparently a final decision was handed down by Chief Justice Fuller, in which the whole law was declared to be unconstitutional, and therefore void. Four of the justices sustain Justice Fuller, and four dissent; so the court stood four against five. Justice Fuller held that it was a direct tax, and that the general government has no right to levy a tax of that nature until the States, upon application, had refused the sum required of them. There are two constitutional ways of governmental raising of money,—one by direct taxation, the other by duties on imports and excises. The first is to be used by the States, the last by the general government. When the federal government needs more money than it can procure by duties and excises, it can appeal to the States to raise sums according to their representation in Congress. This was not done, but the government attempted to raise money by a direct tax upon such people in the States as had an income of four thousand dollars per annum.
Justice Harlan, especially, delivered a very vigorous dissent. He and Justice White both declared that very grave consequences might follow the destruction of the law. Justice Jackson sided with the minority; Justice Shiras had changed his mind, and supported the chief justice. About eighty thousand dollars have been raised by this means, which will have to be refunded. The officials to whom the collection of the tax was committed have received directions to send to Washington, under seal, all their papers, documents, and records.
Exit the income tax!