GROWTH OF INDUSTRIAL LIFE

9%

GROWTH OF INDUSTRIAL LIFE.

9.— THE WORKER AND HIS PAY.

A great deal depends on the reward which the laborer gets for his labor. Nobody works for nothing. Play is done for its own sake. In play the pleasure which comes from bodily or mental activity is the end sought; the amount and direction of the activity are controlled by the desire to get the most delight possible. But work is a putting forth of energy for the accomplishment of a purpose, and the direction and amount of the activity are controlled by the demands of the purpose, without regard to the enjoyment or discomfort which we find in the work itself. Therefore some purpose beyond the mere exertion is always in the mind of any man who labors; nobody works for nothing.
A laborer toils to get his living. He carries out the purposes of others, not his own. An artist, an author, a statesman, a merchant, works directly for his object. His interest is in that object, and he strives to attain it as fully as he possibly can. But the interest of the laborer is in his pay. The man who casts locomotive wheels cares nothing about locomotive wheels, nor locomotives, nor railroads, nor transportation. He does care about his weekly wages. Therefore the relation of the pay to the product of the work is important to those who employ as well as to those who are employed. The closer the laborer’s object, the pay, and the employer’s object, the product, can be brought together, the greater will be the interest of the laborer in his work.
There are three interests which an employer desires a laborer to have in his work,—the interest in doing as much as he can, the interest in doing what he does as well as he can, and the interest in doing it with as little loss and waste as possible. We may call these the interests in quantity, in quality, and in care.
There are also three ways of paying the laborer for his work. The most common of these is what is called the wages system. The pay has nothing to do with the work done. Of course, if a man is a very bad or very slow or very wasteful workman, he is usually discharged; and if he is an uncommonly good worker, he may be promoted, but usually all the workmen are paid the same amount day by day for the same kind of work.
The worker for wages does not own the product or any share in it. He does not own the material in which he works. He does not always own his tools. Therefore he has no interest in how much he does,—for his pay is only so much anyway,—nor in how well he does it, nor in how carefully he uses his material and his tools. His interest is very far from that of his employer, because the pay has little to do with the product.
Another system is one much used in shoe factories, knitting factories, in printing establishments, in carriage and furniture shops, and in other industries where it can be employed: it is the piece-work system. The workman is paid according to the number of pieces he turns out. The pay is settled by the amount of work done. This brings the laborer’s object nearer to that of his employer. He is made to take a great interest in the quantity of work done. His zeal to produce as much as possible is a real fault of the system. It is not balanced by any interest in either quality or care, and therefore the work is very likely to be imperfect. So expensive has this system proved, and so unsatisfactory, that it has been abandoned in many trades.
A system which has been very little tried, but which has reason on its side, and which has proved very satisfactory in some cases, is one which brings the interests of the employer and employed as nearly together as it is possible to be done. It is the system which is known as coöperation. The worker has an ownership in the product and an interest in the profit. His pay is not settled until the goods are sold. If they are good goods, and bring a high price, so much the better for his pocket, and therefore he is interested in the quality of his work. If they can be made cheaply, the profits will be larger, and again he will get a larger amount of pay; therefore he is interested in the care with which he works. And again: the more there is to sell, the larger will be the income, and the larger his share of it. He has therefore a well-balanced interest in quantity, quality, and in care.
Theoretically, this is the ideal system. It is the most perfect when tested by the standard of right and wrong. It is the most perfect, also, when tested by the standard of self-interest. There have been a few difficulties in the way of carrying it out, however. One of these is the fact that a wholly satisfactory plan for trying on the theory has not been found. Another objection, which is less easily got out of the way, is that the working men themselves take little interest in it, because the difference it makes in their wages is not very great. But, like all other things which are true in theory, it is also bound to prove best in practice, whenever it can be given a fair fitting-in to the present order of things.
C. B. MORRILL.