AdventAI

NEW YORK CITY AND THE SUNDAY LIQUOR LAW.

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 34, August 22, 1895

The city of New York has been convulsed for several months over the question of selling liquor on Sunday. It is not the question of liquor-selling and drinking of itself that is agitating the minds of the citizens of New York, but it is the Sunday-selling that is being discussed. In that city, as in many others, the law discriminates in regard to what may or may not be done on Sunday. The municipal laws of New York City, by the license of liquor-selling in thousands of saloons, virtually says that liquor-drinking is not wrong, is not a crime of itself; it is only wrong and a crime when done on Sunday! This is made clear from the fact that people are at full liberty to buy all the liquor Saturday evening which they think they will need on Sunday, and drink it as freely as they please on that day. The members of popular clubs can also drink as much as they please on Sunday, taking care, of course, that the liquor is bought some other day!

By this it is evident that those who made the laws, and those who enforce them, think that liquor-drinking is all right on Sunday, but that the selling of liquor on that day is a crime! In other words, a man who buys liquor on Sunday, but does not drink it at all, is much worse than a man who does not buy on that day, but does drink it every day! A liquor law of this kind is not a liquor law at all; it is simply a Sunday law, and its design is to honor Sunday—to discriminate between Sunday and the other days of the week, rather than to prevent liquor-drinking.

The people see this feature of the law, and many of them think that they are unjustly discriminated against, and so New York City has been, and is now, very much stirred up over this matter. This stir is not over the laws, for the laws are now as they have been for years, but lately, the police, acting under the instruction of the city authorities, are making a great effort to enforce the laws, and to prevent the sale of liquor on Sunday.

Much liquor is undoubtedly sold unknown to the authorities, and in Brooklyn, just across the river from New York, the saloons are open Sunday for the New York trade. The agitation over this question has increased to such an extent that the whole State is interested, and the probability is that the next legislature will grapple with the question of the liquor traffic, especially in its relation to Sunday.

Liquor-selling and drinking is a great evil every day, and it is the duty of every citizen to do all he can by voice, influence, and vote to curtail as far as possible the sale of liquor, not on one day only, but upon all days alike. If it is wrong upon Sunday, it is equally wrong upon Monday. Still it is very doubtful if at the present time public opinion is sufficiently against it to prohibit it altogether. Liquor-drinking is something that never can be entirely cured by law alone; it is so deeply rooted in the carnal appetite, that it is stronger than law; and while its grosser evils may be checked by law, nothing but the grace of God will ever purify a people from such evil indulgences.