AdventAI

Papal Encyclical Criticized as Crafty and Jesuitical

From The Youth's Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 12, March 21, 1895

The last papal encyclical is long and of most crafty and subtle contents, and, as the Christian Instructor calls it, “a deceitful, Jesuitical document, from beginning to end.” The Church Standard says in regard to it, that “if Leo’s infallibility is to bear the strain of his interminable proclamations, encyclicals, etc., it will have to be very infallible indeed. Fortunately for the infallibility, it is not held to include matters of fact, only the comparatively unimportant matters of ‘faith and morals’ [as Catholics hold them]. The pope may blunder to any extent in statements of fact or of history; but, though his judgments of faith and morals may be founded upon the most egregious blunders of that sort, they are nevertheless to be accepted as infallibly true. That is the limitation, and a very convenient one it is. The attempt of Pope Leo to establish himself on a specially friendly footing in the United States, on the ground that the Spanish bravos of South America were Roman Catholics, must strike the American Protestant of average intelligence, and even the Anglican, as a rather heavy papal joke. Americans are not all that they might be, but they have free common schools as yet, in which they learn at least a little elementary history,”—sufficient to see the difference between papal assertions and genuine historical facts.