AdventAI

DIPLOMATIC LYING.

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 35, August 29, 1895

A WRITER in the Review of Reviews has given a careful sketch of Francesco Crispi. Crispi is conceded to be not only the foremost statesman in Italy, but perhaps the most accomplished manager of governments in the world. His opinion on any subject pertaining to the influencing of men and nations may therefore be taken as authoritative.

Like strategy or spying in war, lying has been held to be a necessity in diplomatic affairs. Between men, truth is a matter of honor; but between nations it has not been considered necessary, or even possible.

Crispi is said to be a disagreeable person with whom to carry on negotiations. Perhaps the following opinions that he expressed to a friend may explain why he has none of the suavity such as is ordinarily expected of the successful diplomat. Crispi said in substance, when the subject of falsehood in politics came up in a conversation:—

“Falsehood in politics belongs to the old school. It is an arm out of date, to be consigned to the arsenal of tricks out of fashion. One should never lie.”

Some one interrupted:—

“But there are great falsehoods, the necessary falsehoods, the sublime falsehoods—the falsehoods which settle difficult questions, which decide the lot of a people.” After quietly listening, the prime minister repeated: “One should never lie.”

“But in presence of an indiscreet question, or a captious one, how shall we avoid the difficulty?”

With an impatient exclamation, Crispi answered, tersely: “Say nothing.”

This conversation was reported to Prince Bismarck, the narrator saying that Signor Crispi absolutely refused to admit falsehood in any case.

“In my opinion,” said Bismarck, “all question of morality apart, falsehood is in itself generally awkward and clumsy.”

Count Herbert intervened: “But pardon, Excellence, in certain cases one would be much embarrassed. You have sometimes to deal with people who ask you questions with an indiscretion which puts you with your back to the wall. What can you do then?”

“Escape the question,” answered Bismarck.

“That betrays the embarrassment.”

“Be silent.”

“That is sometimes an avowal.”

The foremost man in the German empire turned his keen eyes upon the company, and said, closing the discussion:—

“I do not like to lie; falsehood is to me odious.”

Such is the testimony of the most successful of modern diplomatists. We are less surprised at this when we learn that the Italian prime minister is called by those who know him well, a religious man. Religious principle always “tells” on a man’s views of worldly affairs. No one living has been put in a harder or more complicated position than Crispi. If he can manage Italy without falsehoods, surely truth must suffice for our simple lives.

A great modern poet described a truthful man as one who “honored his word as if it were his God.” What a world this would be, if we could say in the words of Holy Writ:—

“My covenant will I not break. Nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips. Once have I sworn by my holiness That I will not lie unto David.”