AdventAI

ABELARD

By C. B. Morrill

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 31, August 1, 1895

The name of Abelard is among those indelibly stamped upon the intellectual history of Europe, where it stands for the rise of the universities. Abelard was the father of the University of Paris, one of the first and for a long time the greatest of universities. The story of his life would interest us for this reason alone, even if its course were not disturbed by the sad and romantic incidents which have made it so famous. It is the story of a great genius ruined, a genius profoundly affecting the world, yet producing nothing which could be called its own, and leaving to posterity no legacy but its influence.

Abelard’s birthplace was Pallet, near Nantes, in Brittany, where he was born, it is thought, about 1079. His father was Berenger, a gentleman of noble family, educated according to the highest standards of that day, and devoted to his profession of arms. Peter, surnamed Abelard, the eldest of his children, was early put under tutorage, as were his brothers, that he might receive culture due to learning before taking up the study and practise of the art of war. Such, however, was the love of study which the child developed, that he determined, in spite of all persuasion, to give his life to the pursuit of knowledge.

The instruction of that day was almost entirely elementary. Three centuries before, Charlemagne had found himself at the head of an empire composed of barbarous and disunited tribes, with no common system of law or government, and either wholly untouched by civilization, or touched only by its vices. In this soil he sought to plant such seeds of Roman learning and Roman civilization as could be gathered up after the storms of the barbarian invasions. To his court he assembled, from the monasteries where alone the lamp of science was still kept burning, a few scholars, chief among whom was Alcuin, an Englishman. To Alcuin the emperor intrusted his task of reviving the classical learning. We may stretch terms sufficiently, perhaps, to say that Alcuin was Charlemagne’s minister of education. Since even the emperor could not write his own name, Alcuin suggested that the study of orthography should be made first in the program, to be followed by the trivium,—grammar, rhetoric, and logic,—the language studies; and that upon the trivium should follow the quadrivium of sciences,—arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music. But the fate of the arts and sciences might have remained very uncertain if it had rested in the hands of soldiers, kings, and turbulent courts. Fortunately for posterity, the church had an interest in keeping alive the knowledge of Latin. The Fathers had written in Latin, and it had come to be considered as the only tongue fit for the expression of sacred truth. Therefore all lights in the church were expected to use the language with ease and grace; and to use it with ease and grace it was necessary to study the writings of its greatest masters. So, though the church was for a long time opposed to learning as dangerous to faith, it still kept intact, from a sort of necessity, the body of science which it had received from Rome.

As a result of this interest of the church in learning, there arose schools in connection with many bishoprics and in many monasteries. These schools confined their teaching in the main to the trivium and the quadrivium. The papacy had indeed declared against learning; but there was not at that time the unity which now exists in the Catholic Church, and the overlordship of the pope was mainly a theory which men talked about, but which they acknowledged in fact only when it suited their interests to do so. Some of the leading episcopal schools added to the elementary studies the study of dialectics, or the art of reasoning and disputing; and to the study of dialectics was united in time the study of philosophy and of theology. The schools became firmly established in the face of the dislike of the early popes for knowledge; and, once established, the papacy saw in the schools a source of great power, and at once grasped for it. Study and schools were encouraged at all opportunities. The popes themselves were, at this period, men of learning and great keenness of mind, the men who did most to elevate the papacy to supremacy, and they could see what advantage the monopoly of intellectual training would give them.

These were the conditions which prevailed when, in his twentieth year, young Peter—he was not yet called Abelard—came to Paris. He had already seen something of the intellectual world of that day, having traveled about considerably among the schools of France. He called himself a “knight errant of philosophy,” a name which is still applied by historians to that large tribe of wandering scholars, scholares vagantes, which were a feature of medieval life. There was in Paris a professor of philosophy, of considerable note, William of Champeaux, by whose fame Abelard was attracted. He became a hearer. It was the fashion then for professors to debate with any opponent who might present himself. William of Champeaux was the champion of the realistic philosophy. Abelard had been the pupil of Roscellinus, one of the leading voices of the nominalist school. One day not very long after his arrival, the young “knight errant” disputed with his professor. The dialectician was pleased with the young debater, and took him to board. The nearer view which the pupil thus obtained was not to the advantage of the teacher. Abelard found out the extent of his master’s resources, and the reverence in which he had held him fell away. What had at first been a trial of the pupil’s skill became an open warfare, with the younger man in the advantage. Abelard opened a school at Melun, a few leagues from Paris. This school grew so rapidly that he moved to Corbeil, about nine miles from the city, and at last “pitched his camp,” as he said, “on the heights of Ste. Geneviève,” just outside the walls.

From his position upon Ste. Geneviève, Abelard began to bombard the camp of William of Champeaux at the school of Notre Dame. The audience of the master began to melt away like the snow, while that of his pupil grew in proportion to the growth of his reputation. As for his reputation, it traveled to the farthest parts of France, and from all sides pupils gathered to the school of Ste. Geneviève. To the power of his logic was added the charm of his delivery and the spell of his personal presence. Of the first, Roscellinus testified that Abelard was the acutest logician of his age; and there are witnesses who say that his voice had a wonderful sweetness, that his words were like honey, and that his face and figure were proud, handsome, bold, and commanding. These gifts of nature were irresistible in that age; Abelard became the hero and the idol of his pupils.

In the midst of these successes and arduous labors, the health of Abelard gave way, and he retired to his native Brittany. There he lived, chafing, in forced seclusion from the conflict he loved, till such time as his physicians would permit his return to Paris. When he returned, he found William of Champeaux in the enjoyment of his early popularity; but, instead of renewing the warfare, Abelard became once more his pupil.

Not for long, however. His appearance in Paris awakened all the old enthusiasm. His former pupils begged him to lecture. Relations between him and his master became again hostile. He began to lecture again. At once his hall was crowded with eager listeners. He had refuted Anselm of Laon, one of the leading theologians of the day, to whose school he had been attracted. In the self-confidence thus gained, he added lectures on theology to those on philosophy. His success in theology proved to be equal to, if not greater than, his success in philosophy had been. His popularity rose higher than ever, and his pupils were numbered by thousands.

Of Anselm, Abelard has left us a description which might characterize many teachers of the middle ages. He had gone to Anselm’s school because of his reputation; but he was disappointed in him. “From afar,” said Abelard, “he was a fine tree thick with leaves; on a nearer view, he was without fruit, or bore only the dry figs of the tree that Christ cursed. When he lit his fire, there was much smoke, but no light.”

William of Champeaux was at length driven out of Paris. Abelard refuted his sophistries so completely that he was obliged to retire from some of his positions, and even signed, voluntarily, the retraction of some of his propositions. This step was fatal to his influence. His followers deserted him. He was forced to retire to the monastery of St. Victor, outside of the city, to hide his chagrin. He left his professorship to a disciple of small abilities, who of his own will resigned it to Abelard, and took a place among the followers of that prince of reasoners. Thus Abelard’s victory was complete, and he marched triumphant into the episcopal school of Notre Dame.

C. B. MORRILL.