Court Rules Dawn Timing Decides Locomotive Negligence Case

33%

Court Rules Dawn Timing Decides Locomotive Negligence Case

APROPOS to the value of astronomy, the Scientific American relates a case in which the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia recently decided the question when day begins and darkness vanishes in the morning solely upon the authority of astronomical experts. A young woman had been knocked down by a locomotive on the Reading Road while she was walking over a crossing at Norristown at 6:30 o’clock in the morning of Feb. 14, 1893. The engine did not display a light, nor did it signal with whistle or bell. The company claimed that it was not negligent, because at that hour dawn was breaking, and no light was needed; and the entire case rested on whether or not it was daylight when the accident occurred.
The sun rose on the day of the accident at 6:54 o’clock. Several astronomers and other experts testified that half an hour before sunrise it is as dark as at any time of night. From that time until sunrise light comes so slowly that the point of half-light is reached only seven minutes before sunrise. During the last seven minutes before the sun-up, light comes very rapidly until the full day breaks. The plaintiff’s lawyer claimed, therefore, that at the time of the accident, twenty-four minutes before sunrise, it was pitch dark. The jury rendered a verdict of twenty-five thousand dollars in her favor.