AdventAI

LESSON 11.—THE RIGHT OF DISSENT.

From The Youth's Instructor, Vol. 43, No. 48, November 28, 1895

(December 14, 1895.)

1. What must be the relation of the church to the state before there can be religious persecution? (See note 1..)

2. To whom are all accountable in religious things? Rom. 14:4, 12; 1 Cor. 7:23.

3. Therefore, when men attempt to control us in religious matters, what have we a right to do?—To dissent.

LIBERTY VS. TOLERATION.

4. What is the meaning of the word “toleration”? (See note 2..)

5. What may the government do which grants toleration?—It may prohibit and compel. (See note 3..)

6. What kind of rights do we exercise in worshiping God?—Natural rights.

7. From whom do such rights come?—From God.

8. Can the state, then, properly interfere in the exercise of such rights?

9. What is the province of the state?—To protect men in their rights. (See note 4..)

10. How are governments controlled?—By majorities.

11. Are the majority right on religious questions? Matt. 7:12, 13. (See note 5..)

A WRESTING OF SCRIPTURE.

12. What did the Lord call Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon? Jer. 27:6.

13. When commanded to bow and worship a great image which Nebuchadnezzar had erected, what did three of his subjects say? Dan. 3:16–18.

14. Who were these? Dan. 3:12.

15. Was their course in harmony with the commandment of God? Ex. 20:4–6.

16. How did God interpose, thus showing his approval of their course? Dan. 3:28.

17. What did Daniel do when forbidden by a Medo-Persian decree to worship the God of heaven? Dan. 6:10.

18. What argument did his persecutors bring to bear on the king to secure his condemnation?—That it was the law, and must be enforced. Verses 13–15. (See note 6..)

19. How did God show his approval of Daniel’s refusing to obey the law? Verse 22.

20. What prohibitory command did the Jewish Sanhedrim place upon the apostles? Acts 4:17, 18.

21. In direct conflict with this, what did the angel of the Lord command them to do? Acts 5:19, 20.

22. What are we to conclude, therefore, respecting the authority of earthly governments?—That they have no right whatever to intermeddle in religious things.

23. What scripture is sometimes cited to show that we are under obligation to obey whatever laws men may make? Rom. 13:1.

24. What would such an application of the scripture imply? (See note 7..)

25. What must we, therefore, conclude?—That there is a limit to the rightful authority of the “powers that be”; that they have not the right to require men to do wrong.

26. In any case, therefore, of a conflict between the laws of men and the word of God, whom should we obey? Acts 4:19, 20; 5:29. (See note 8..)

NOTES.

Notes

  1. 1.Before there can be religious persecution, there must be a union of the civil and religious forces,—church and state must be united. The church must get control of and use the <column-break/> power of the state before she can punish those who dissent from her doctrines, dogmas, and dictation. ↩
  2. 2.Toleration.—“The allowance of that which is not wholly approved. Specifically, the allowance of religious opinions and modes of worship in a state, when contrary to or different from those of the established church or belief.”—Webster. ↩
  3. 3.Toleration implies the right of the state to dictate in matters of religion. It implies the right to prohibit. The right to permit implies the right to prohibit. And the right to permit and prohibit implies the right, also, to compel. The right of the parent to say to the child, “You may go,” or, “You must not go,” implies the right to say, “You must go.” If the state has the right to say to its citizens, “You may work on Sunday,” it has the right to say, “You must not work on Sunday.” And if it has the right to say these, it has also the right to say, “You must work on the Sabbath.” “There is a very great difference between toleration and liberty. Toleration is a concession which may be withdrawn. It implies a preference for the ruling form of faith and worship, and a practical disapproval of all other forms.”—Schaff’s Church and State in the United States, p. 14. “The free exercise of religion, according to the dictates of conscience, is something which every man may indeed demand as a right, not something for which he must ask as a privilege. To grant to the state the power of tolerating is implicitly to grant to it the power of prohibiting.”—Appleton’s Cyclopedia of American Biography, Vol. 4, p. 165. ↩
  4. 4.“To protect liberty of conscience is the duty of the state, and this is the limit of its authority in matters of religion.”—Great Controversy, p. 202. “Government exists for the protection of the persons and property of men.”—Macaulay on Mill’s Essay on Government. ↩
  5. 5.Macaulay, in his essay on Gladstone, well said, “Have not almost all the governments in the world always been in the wrong on religious subjects?” Indeed they have, and for the simple reason that they are controlled by majorities, and they are almost always wrong on religious subjects. They are wrong on the subject of the Sabbath, and this manifests itself wherever governments legislate on the question. They favor and defend the Sunday, the papal Sabbath, and not the seventh day, the Sabbath of the Lord. ↩
  6. 6.The argument of Daniel’s persecutors is a familiar one to the people of all ages. They secure the unjust measures they desire, and then demand submission and obedience to these measures because they are the law. “We ask only obedience to law,” is the favorite motto with the advocates of Sunday enforcement. Of course that is all they ask after they get the law they want; but we deny the right of the existence of the law. ↩
  7. 7.To say that because we are told to be subject to the higher powers we are, therefore, bound to obey every law that men may make, would imply that if the state commanded men to murder, they would have to do it; or to steal, they would have to steal; or to lie, swear, dishonor parents, or worship idols, they would have to do all these things. Every person knows better than this. It is evident, therefore, that there must be some limit to human legislation, and the duties which men owe to civil governments. ↩
  8. 8.“When the laws of men conflict with the word and law of God, we are to obey the latter, whatever the consequences may be.”—Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 1, pp. 201, 202. “The question is asked, Shall we not obey the powers that be?—Yes, when they are in harmony with the higher powers that be. God made his law for all the universe. He created man; he gives the bounteous provisions of nature, holds our breath and life in his hand. He is to be recognized, his law honored, before all the great men, and the highest earthly powers.”—Mrs. E. G. White, in Review and Herald, April 15, 1890. ↩