AdventAI

Estelle Never Knew

By James Rooks

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 65, No. 28., July 10, 1917

A YOUNG woman who in college had made a specialty of English, was ambitious to secure a high school position where she could teach that branch of study. But as no such position offered itself, and as it was necessary for her to earn a living, she accepted, the year after her graduation, a position as teacher in one of the lower grades of her native town.

Later in the winter, she heard of a position just such as she wanted, in another city of the State, and at once she wrote to the chairman of the school board, applying for it, and sending the recommendations she had secured from her professors at college. Then, happening to remember that this same city was the home of one of her college friends, she sat down and wrote her, telling of her hopes. It was a very hasty letter, so hasty that she did not always have time for the punctuation, and once or twice she rushed from one sentence to the next without the formality of using a capital. Her letter was full of slang. She had always been one of the slangy girls in college. She did not even take time to reread the communication after she had finished it, or she might have discovered some of its flaws, but she thrust it into an envelope and sent it on its way.

The girl who received the letter was pleased with the idea of having an old college friend a resident of the city. As soon as her father came home, she broached the subject. “Father, there’s a friend of mine, an awfully smart girl, who wants to get a position here to teach.”

“Is her name Little?”

“Why, yes. How did you know?”

“She has applied for a high school position. How did you know she wanted to teach here?”

“She wrote me. The letter just came today.”

“Let me see it.”

The young woman hesitated. She had read her friend’s letter hastily, more interested in its purport than its form. But now it occurred to her that itp. 13 was not exactly the sort of letter to show the president of the school board, even though he happened to be her father.

“It — why, you know it was just a personal letter.”

“Certainly, I know it. And that’s why I want to see it.”

She brought it out reluctantly. He spread it open on his knee and began to peruse it. In a minute he arched his brows.

“A little weak on punctuation, it seems.”

“I suppose she was in a hurry.”

Another silence. “H’m! On this first page are two sentences beginning with small letters.”

“Estelle was really brilliant in college, father. There was only one other girl whose themes could compare with hers.”

He turned a page and read a sentence aloud. “What does that mean?”

The daughter blushed. “Oh, that’s the latest slang. When we were in school, Estelle always had an affinity for slang.”

He read on through the letter without further comment, folded it, and shook his head. “I’m very sorry, my dear. But your friend won’t do.”

“O father, don’t decide so quickly. She really is such a good scholar. Professor Blakeman used to think she would make a success as a writer.”

“There are very few prospective literary lights in a high school class, my daughter. But there is not a single pupil in such a class who will not need to know how to write a good letter. With all due respect to your friend’s talents, she herself does not seem to have mastered the art of letter-writing. It is impossible for me to believe that any person who would send out a letter so faulty in construction, without proper punctuation, and with misspelled words, will be a suitable teacher of high school English. In fact, she would never secure a position in any school where I had a deciding vote.”

Estelle’s recommendations came back shortly, with a polite note, saying that the vacancy had been filled. And she never knew how her letter to her old friend had made the recommendations of her college professors worth less than the paper on which they were written.—James Rooks, in Girls’ Companion.