WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH?

3%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Nov 6, 1917

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 65, No. 45.

Read the full edition

WHO CHANGED THE SABBATH?

Donald Hears the History of the Change of the Day
CARLYLE B. HAYNES
WHEN Donald Hunter awoke on Saturday morning, the first thing he thought of was that this day was the Sabbath. He had been fully convinced the night before, after hearing the sermon of Brother Harris about the Christian Sabbath, that this was the right day to keep, and he wondered what he ought to do on the Sabbath.
After breakfast some of his young schoolmates on their way to the baseball lot hailed him, and urged him to come with them, as they were to play a regular game that day and wanted him to pitch. Standing on the back porch he told them quietly that he could not play on that day, as he now believed it was the Sabbath. They went out of the yard silently, but he heard a jeering laugh as they joined the other boys on the street, and knew he was the cause of it.
Most of the day he spent with Brother Harris and the tent master, who told him that on the following Sabbath they would begin to hold a Sabbath school in the tent. Donald was very glad for this and said he would attend it.
The largest crowd of the entire series of meetings was in attendance at the Sunday night meeting in the tent. Elder Harris had promised to speak that night on the change of the Sabbath, and tell when this change had been brought about, by whom, and the authority for it. The preacher said:
“We shall hold a criminal trial here tonight, and I am going to ask this great audience to act as the jury. I shall be the prosecuting attorney and bring the evidence before you. We shall try to convict the criminal who brought about the change in the observance of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week.
“Now in a trial it is customary to hear first the charge against the prisoner. The charge in this case which we are to try is made by the Lord, and it is this: God charges the Roman Catholic Church with having tampered with his law in changing the Sabbath.
“This charge will be found in Dan. 7:25. You will remember in our study of the prophecy of this chapter we found that the little horn on the fourth beast represented the Roman Catholic Church. Of this little horn, or of that church, the Lord says in this verse, ‘He shall speak great words against the Most High, and shall wear out the saints of the Most High, and think to change times and laws.’
“Another version makes this last expression read, ‘He shall think to change the time in the law.’ This law, of course, refers to the law of God, the ten commandments.
“This prophecy in every part has been fulfilled by the Roman Catholic Church. It has spoken great words against God in its claims to forgive the sins of men. It has worn out the saints of the Most High in the terrible persecutions of Christians during the Dark Ages. But this is not all that it would do. It would actually attempt to lay its impious hands on the very law of God, and tear from its place in the heart of that law the Sabbath commandment, and substitute another day in its place. This is God’s charge.
“This expression, ‘He shall think to change the time in the law,’ can refer to but one thing, for there is but one time mentioned in the law of God. The first, second, third, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth, and tenth commandments make no reference at all to time. But the fourth commandment mentions time, it mentions a day, the seventh day, and declares that day to be the Sabbath of the Lord.
“It is the Sabbath commandment, therefore, to which the Lord refers when he predicts of this power that it would ‘think to change the time in the law.’ Here, then, is the definite charge made by the Lord himself that the Roman Catholic Church would attempt to make a change in the Sabbath.
“The very fact that this charge is made by the Lord himself ought to be enough to win a verdict of guilty from every member of this audience who accepts the Bible as the word of God. Some witnesses will not tell the truth, but when the Lord speaks we can always depend on his word, and we know he tells the truth. So when he declares that the Roman Church will attempt to change the Sabbath that ought to be sufficient for every person in this tent tonight.
“But we have additional witnesses to bring before this jury. Permit me to direct your close attention to their testimony.”
The speaker then read a large number of extracts and quotations to the audience from various histories, commentaries, and encyclopedias, showing conclusively that the seventh day, Saturday, is the Sabbath according to the Bible. He said that none of this testimony was from a witness who might be prejudiced in favor of his side of the case, for none of it was from witnesses who observed the seventh day as the Sabbath, but all of it was from those who kept the first day as the Sabbath. In each case he gave the name of the book, the name of its author, and the number of the page from which he read. And all the books he read from were of such a character as to be recognized by the audience as authorities on the subjects of which they treated.
“And now,” the preacher said, “we shall see if we can secure the confession of the guilty party. From now on I shall read nothing from a Protestant source. I have here a number of Catholic publications—books, catechisms, and magazines. I wish this jury to hear what the Catholic Church has to say about the charge which is made in the Bible about the change of the Sabbath. First I read from ‘A New Catechism of Christian Faith and Practice,’ written by Rt. Rev. James Belford, D. D., published in 1909, pp. 86, 87:
“‘Question.— What is the third (fourth) commandment?
“‘Answer.— Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day.
“‘Ques.— What day was the Sabbath?
“‘Ans.— The seventh day, our Saturday.
“‘Ques.— Do you keep the Sabbath?
“‘Ans.— No; we keep the Lord’s day.
“‘Ques.— Which is that?
“‘Ans.— The first day, Sunday.
“‘Ques.— Who changed it?
“‘Ans.— The Catholic Church.’
“My second Catholic witness is Father Walter Drum, S. J., of Woodstock College, Maryland, and I quote from an article by him entitled ‘Recent Bible Study,’ appearing in the Ecclesiastical Review of February, 1914, Vol. 59, No. 2, pp. 230-232:
“‘The observance of Sunday thus comes to be an ecclesiastical law entirely distinct from the divine law of Sabbath observance, the prescriptions of Gen. 2: 2, 3 in regard to the Sabbath having nothing whatever to do with the law of the church about Sunday, the Lord’s day. Catholics should observe the law of the church, not by the Old Testament observances of the Sabbath, nor by the dictates of Protestants or of Jews, but by the prescription of the church herself. The author of the Sunday law is the only one who has a right to interpret that law; and that author is the Catholic Church.’
“‘Again, this writer, on page 236, says: ‘They (the Protestants) deem it their duty to keep the Sunday holy. Why?—Because the Catholic Church tells them to do so. They have no other reason.’”
Brother Harris read many other extracts from Catholic sources, all agreeing with the testimony of the two witnesses which have here been quoted. Then the preacher said:
“‘The case is closed. The testimony is all in. I want now the verdict of this jury. Will all who say that the verdict is guilty please indicate it by holding up the right hand?’ There was a stir all through the big audience, and almost instantly scores of hands were raised. Brother Harris had proved his case, and practically the entire audience was convinced that the Catholic Church had changed the Sabbath.
“‘Now will those whose verdict is ‘Not guilty,’ hold up their hands?’ asked the preacher. Two lone hands were held up in the rear of the big crowd, causing a laugh to run through the audience. But Brother Harris seemed to be expecting something of the kind, for he said:
“‘Well, that hangs the jury, and makes it impossible for us to pronounce sentence, which is just as well, for sentencing this criminal belongs to God and not to us, and it will not be long until God himself will pronounce judgment upon this anti-Christian system.
“‘Now, from what has been said, we can all see that God deliberately charges the Roman Catholic Church with the crime of tampering with the divine law in changing the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday. The voice of history deliberately testifies to the truth of the charge. The Roman Catholic Church deliberately confesses itself guilty as charged. And thus the Roman Church stands before the world convicted of laying impious hands upon the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, the Sabbath of the Lord, and tearing from its place in the very heart of the law of God, the fourth commandment, and putting in its place a spurious and counterfeit sabbath, which is no sabbath at all, as it rests solely on the traditions of that church and not in any sense on the Word of God.
“‘It is evident, therefore, that the Protestant churches in observing Sunday, have left the true ground and basis of Protestantism, the Bible, and are following the Roman Church in accepting doctrines and practices which are not founded on the Bible. On this point Catholics can truthfully accuse Protestant Sunday keepers of inconsistency.
“‘The duty of every true Protestant is to cast away this unscriptural practice and doctrine of Sunday observance and to follow the Bible, to follow Jesus, to follow the apostles in the observance of the true Sabbath, the seventh day of the week.’”
After the meeting little crowds and groups of people gathered on the street and discussed the sermon. Donald heard many say, “Well, he certainly made out his case. He certainly proved who changed the Sabbath.” Many were silent in thought as they went to their homes. That a deep impression had been made, could be plainly seen. Donald’s father and mother were unusually silent as they returned home.
On entering the house, Mr. Hunter opened the big Bible, turned to Daniel, and lingered long in study after the others had retired. If they could have looked in just before he went upstairs, they would have seen him kneel and pray earnestly for light on this great question, while the tears ran slowly down his face.