The Right Way to Criticize

20%

Review and Herald Publishing Assn. · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Oct 24, 1916

FromThe Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 64, No. 43.

Read the full edition

The Right Way to Criticize

“I THINK you spoke your piece splendidly, Rob. I was at the very back of the room, you know, and I could hear every single word.”
Rob’s face grew pink with pleasure. His sister Judith, though not grown up by any means, is considerably older than Rob, and he has a very high respect for her opinion. It made him feel happy to know Judith thought he had done so well. And he was glad so many of the boys had heard the ring in Judith’s voice as she praised him.
It was not till the two were alone, that Judith added something she had meant to say all along. “The next time you speak a piece, Rob, I’d be careful not to swing my arm quite so much. It won’t be hard if you just remember.”
“I’ll remember,” Rob promised, and he did not mind the criticism a bit. Judith showed her good sense in praising him where others could hear, and saving her bit of criticism for his ear alone. If all sisters were as tactful and sensible, their suggestions would help their brothers far more than they do.—James G. Cowles.