CORTLAND was prosperous. The majority of the citizens felt well satisfied with existing conditions. A few farsighted men and women, however, claimed that a much greater prosperity awaited her if she would forever banish the liquor traffic, and that she was even committing an unpardonable crime against her own citizenship by permitting the traffic to exist. But the wets said, “Not so. When you destroy the liquor traffic, you destroy the revenue. City government cannot be carried on and necessary improvements made without this revenue. Besides, abolishing saloons will hurt business and increase taxes.”
This question was discussed vigorously at a town meeting. One who had taken a prominent part in the opposition argument, left the meeting determined to fight prohibition to the finish, though he himself was an abstainer.
On returning to his office he sat thinking over plans for carrying out his resolution, when he fell asleep and dreamed that he was accosted by a man of unusual physique and surprising intelligence. As they conversed he learned that the stranger was a representative from Mars, sent here to learn what he could of conditions in our world. As they talked together they heard the screams of a woman in distress. While seeking to determine their source, a fair-haired baby girl came out of a near-by house and cried, “My papa is hurting my mamma!”
The men hastened over, and found that the husband had just choked his wife to death on her remonstrating against his cruel treatment of their three-months-old baby.
“Tell me,” said the Martian, “what could lead a man thus to harm his own household?”
“Drink. Alcoholic or intoxicating drinks, such as whisky, rum, and beer, when drunk in sufficient quantities, make men commit crime.”
“By accident, I suppose, this man drank this vile stuff?”
“No, for almost two years he has been under the influence of liquor a large share of the time. Before he began to drink he was one of our leading business men, upright and industrious, a devoted husband and father; but he unwittingly fell into a trap set by a certain saloon keeper to catch him as a patron, and he has since rapidly gone to the dogs. He seems to have no self-control. He is a shame to the community.”
“How is it that a man is allowed to sell such deadly substances to his neighbor?”
“Men will drink liquor, and men will sell it; so the town regulates the sale by licensing certain persons to sell it. In this way the sale is better controlled, and the town gets so much clear money out of it.”
“It may be clear money; but it certainly is not clean money. Why do you speak of controlling the business when such tragedies as we have just witnessed are possible, and you yourself say many others are perpetrated?”
“I mean we limit the sale to a few men by charging them a high license. We limit the hours of sale; and forbid its sale to minors and to drunkards.”
“How many saloons do you have in this place?”
“We have one hundred, and each pays $1,200 into the city treasury. This $120,000 helps out considerably in our expenses and improvements.”
“Your town, then, has licensed one hundred men to do their utmost to sell stuff that makes other men commit horrible deeds against their own families, such as we have just witnessed? Is this the province of civil government?”
“Of course, all who drink do not do such things.”
“But such results are not only probable, but are expected, are they not?”
“Yes, I suppose it must be expected that some drunkards will be made wherever liquor is sold, and that some of them will commit crime.”
“This is certainly an anomaly in government,—licensing that which destroys government. Does a man know what he is doing when under the influence of liquor?”
“No, it seems that often he is irresistibly impelled by the liquor to commit the deed, but does not sense what he is doing.”
“Why should not the saloon keeper and the town voters be held responsible for the deed even more than the man who committed the crime? What will be done with this man who has just killed his wife and maimed his three-months-old babe?”
“He will probably be imprisoned for life or hanged.”
“What will become of the afflicted babe and of that angel child who gave the alarm?”
“I suppose they will be cared for in the city orphanage. I was told the children have no relatives who can assume the burden of their care.”
“You will pardon me, but I should like to learn what other crimes men have committed under the influence of the stuff you permit one of your citizens to sell to the rest.”
“I read of them, but as they do not directly concern me, I do not remember them.”
Just then an acquaintance of the business man came up, and after a few words of general conversation, the Martian said, “Friend, tell me what use alcoholic liquors serve.”
“Sir, as beverages they serve no good use whatever. The alcohol, the intoxicating element in hard drinks, in its pure form has mechanical and scientific uses; but when taken internally it is only an evil. I have given much study to this question, and I will tell you frankly that the liquor traffic is our nation’s greatest curse. It causes at least 75 per cent of the nation’s crime; 60 per cent of its poverty; 50 per cent of the defectives; and 30 per cent of the insanity. There are more than 800,000 liquor-orphaned children in this country, and thousands upon thousands of little ones die yearly from the alcoholic sins of their parents, and 2,500 are smothered to death by their drunken parents.”
“The traffic murders in cold blood thousands of wives and ruins tens of thousands of girls yearly, besides bringing untold sorrow and trial upon hundreds of thousands of other women. It debauches boys and girls, wrecks manhood and womanhood, digging 100,000 drunkards’ graves annually. It is responsible for a large share of the preventable sickness and death. Tuberculosis, our most fatal disease, carries off two hundred out of every 100,000 of our population annually. This disease costs the nation in loss of earnings, through sickness, in possible earnings stoppedp. 10 by death, and in expense of sickness, $1,000,000,000. No small proportion of this expense and suffering would be averted were it not for alcoholic liquors; for it is estimated that ten out of every one hundred deaths from tuberculosis are due directly or indirectly to alcohol.”
“The traffic seriously interferes with the efficiency of our workmen, and is the direct cause of thousands of accidents; it is the chief cause of nonsupport, divorce, and immorality.”
“It depletes each year our State and national treasuries to the amount of $2,500,000,000 directly and nearly $3,000,000,000 more indirectly.”
“These are some of the material aspects of the problem, but the woes and heartaches from every place where the saloon exists are unutterable and indescribable.”
“Why, then, is such a traffic allowed to exist?”
“Simply because some men care more for money than for life. They, of course, make themselves believe that they have legitimate excuses for condoning the traffic; but these have all been proved absolutely futile, as all know who have given careful study to the question.”
“How is it about the revenue being necessary to compass city and State expenses?”
“That idea is absurd. The money involved in the tragedy that just occurred here gives a concrete illustration of my contention. The burial of the wife, the care of the children, the trial and imprisonment of the father, will amount to no small sum. This, with the care of all the other victims of the liquor traffic, costs the city at least $175,000 annually. Our citizens spend more than $2,000,000 for the drink. It surely is not good policy to spend $2,175,000 for the purpose of getting back $120,000, in revenue, or license fees.”
“I will cite one other concrete example of the cost of crime. A citizen of one of our counties bought a quart of whisky, got drunk, and went out and killed a man. It cost the county about $5,000 to send the murderer to the penitentiary. The circuit court set aside the verdict, and sent the case back to the lower court for a new trial. It cost the county about $6,000 more to put the man behind the bars at Columbus. Two years later the governor pardoned the murderer. The fellow went back to the county and bought another quart of whisky, got drunk, and killed another man. It cost the county $5,000 more to send him again to the penitentiary. Once more the circuit court reversed the decision and sent it back on error for a new trial. The defendant asked for a change of venue, and the case was heard in another county. It cost the first county approximately $8,000 more to send the man finally to the penitentiary for life. The two quarts of whisky cost $24,000 for prosecution and trial of the drinker.”
“This is only one illustration of the great expense accrued in dealing with liquor-produced crime. People fail to consider the real cost of crime in dollars, else they could not voluntarily vote to license an institution that is directly responsible for three fourths of all crime. Our national expenditure for liquor directly and indirectly is conservatively estimated to be $5,000,000,000. Our revenue from the liquor traffic the last year was only $223,948,646.09. Yet our liquor friends insist that the government could not exist without the revenue from the traffic.”
“The revenue idea is a myth; mercantile and other business loss said to be due to prohibitory legislation is as great a fake as the revenue plea. Twenty-four States, thousands of towns, cities, and business corporations testify that business conditions improve under prohibition of the liquor traffic; in fact, wherever prohibition is given but half a chance, it makes good. We can financially well afford to eliminate every vestige of the liquor traffic; and certainly there is no question but that moral and spiritual benefit would result from its annihilation. The silver dollar before the eyes of the liquor sympathizer and dealer is the only thing that keeps the traffic alive in this enlightened age. Some X ray or other scientific ray will surely in time be discovered that will allow these to see right through the dollar the real status of the traffic. Then the death lance will be thrown. The liquor traffic will be no more.”
The force with which the orator delivered this desired death blow was sufficient to arouse the sleeper from his dreams; and although on first opening his eyes he glanced about for his companions, he soon realized that he had been dreaming. But he could not shake off the feeling that the dream was but a presentation of facts. He was pricked in his heart as he reviewed the points of the dream. He went to his library and took down some books which he had not cared heretofore to read. Study and serious thought tore away all the silver scales from his eyes, and he saw men as men, as brothers, to be protected rather than exploited for private gain. He had a new vision, a new dream. His vote at the next election was the one vote that saved Cortland from the maw of the insatiable liquor traffic. The drys won!