AdventAI

Which Day Did Jesus and the Apostles Keep?

By Carlyle B. Haynes

From The Youth’s Instructor, Vol. 65, No. 51., December 18, 1917

The Sabbath of the New Testament

CARLYLE B. HAYNES

There was an unusually large number present at the tent on the baseball lot on Monday night. It was plain that the discussion of the Sabbath question had created an unusual interest. Brother Harris had promised that on this evening he would read and study every passage in the New Testament that mentioned the first day of the week in any connection, and this brought out many who felt sure the evidence for the observance of Sunday would be found in the New Testament.

In the audience Donald Hunter saw a number of Sunday school teachers, and he noticed one especially whom he had heard saying to another man that there was abundant proof in the New Testament for Sunday keeping. He had pointed out, too, that the minister seemed to be devoting most of his attention to the Old Testament, and that if he would read the New Testament he would find that Jesus always met with his disciples on the first day of the week, and did this so many times that it became a custom of the early Christians to meet on that day.

Tonight Brother Harris read nothing from the Old Testament, but confined himself exclusively to the New Testament. He said:

“While it is clear to all and freely admitted by all that the Old Testament teaches the observance of the seventh day as the Sabbath, it is often claimed that the New Testament introduces another day, the first day, as the Christian Sabbath. We must now examine the evidence which is produced for this claim.

“The best way to arrive at the truth or falsity of this claim will be to study every passage in the New Testament that speaks of the first day of the week. In this way we shall bring together the entire teaching of the Bible on this subject, and we shall certainly learn whether the first day has taken the place of the seventh day.

“The first time the first day is mentioned in the New Testament is in Matt. 28:1. This verse is the introduction to the account of the resurrection of Christ, and contains the historical record that he rose on ‘the first day of the week.’ The verse was not written to give any information about a change of the Sabbath, but to give the facts concerning the resurrection. While the first day is mentioned here, it is given no sacred name or title. It is not called ‘the new Christian Sabbath,’ or ‘the new Sabbath,’ or ‘the Lord’s day.’ It is called merely ‘the first day of the week,’ and is plainly considered by Matthew as one of the working days of the week, the first of them. There is clearly no evidence here for Sunday observance.

“The second time reference is made to the first day is in Mark 16:1, 2. It will be seen that this passage is the same historical record of the resurrection by another writer, who agrees with Matthew that Christ was raised on the first day of the week. Mark does not give this day any sacred title or name; he does not say it is now to be observed as the Christian Sabbath in honor of the resurrection of Christ; he is entirely silent with regard to any sacredness belonging to this day; he mentions it in his gospel simply because he cannot write the account of the resurrection without speaking of it.

“Instead of proving that the first day is the Sabbath, this verse makes it clear that it is not. Mark speaks of two days, ‘the Sabbath,’ and ‘the first day of the week.’ One day is given a sacred title; the other has no sacred title. One day is a holy, sacred day; the other is merely one of the ordinary week days, the first. And let it be noticed that when ‘the first day of the week’ comes, the Sabbath is then past. If one prefers New Testament teaching to Old Testament teaching concerning the Sabbath question (though they both teach the same thing), here it is. The New Testament clearly teaches that the day just before the first day is the Sabbath, and that when the first day comes the Sabbath is past.

“The third time this day is mentioned is in Mark 16:9, and here again the first day is spoken of as an ordinary week day, without any special honor.

“The fourth time the first day is mentioned is in Luke 23:52-56; 24:1. Here we have the account of the resurrection of Christ by another writer, Luke. Again the day of the resurrection is given no sacred title. It is spoken of as one of the week days, ‘the first day of the week.’ Not the slightest hint is given that it is to be considered as different from the other week days. In this passage the day of the crucifixion is called ‘the preparation.’ This was Friday. The next day, the seventh, is called ‘the Sabbath day according to the commandment.’ And the day following the seventh day is merely ‘the first day of the week.’

“From this passage it is clear which day is the Sabbath of the New Testament; it is that day which is between the sixth day and the first day of the week, the seventh day, known as Saturday, ‘the Sabbath day according to the commandment.’

“The fifth time the day is mentioned is in John 20:1. Here again, by another writer, is the same historical record of the resurrection. But there is no Sunday sacredness here. This verse does not call the first day by any sacred name or title any more than the previous verses we have studied. It is merely ‘the first day of the week.’ That is all.

“This day is mentioned the sixth time in John 20:19. And here, at last, we have the record of a meeting of the disciples on the first day. This verse has been made the basis of the claim that the disciples had met together in order to inaugurate the first day as the new Christian Sabbath in honor of Christ’s resurrection on that day. But this claim cannot be true. In the firstp. 9 place the disciples did not believe at this time that Christ had been raised from the dead. This is the same meeting spoken of in Mark 16:10-13 and Luke 24:36-40. Hence it cannot be true that they were establishing a new Sabbath in honor of an event which they did not believe had taken place. Nor was this a religious meeting. They ‘were assembled for fear of the Jews,’ not for worship. They were afraid the Jews would find them, and treat them as they had treated Jesus, so they had all gone home (Acts 1:13), and locked the doors. No evidence here for Sunday keeping.

“The seventh time the day is mentioned is in Acts 20:6-8. Here is a religious meeting on the first day, but it was on the dark part of the first day, for ‘there were many lights in the upper chamber,’ and Paul preached to them ‘until midnight.’ Now, the only dark part of the first day of the week is that part we now call Saturday night. The days of the week of the Bible were not reckoned as we now reckon days. Bible days began at sunset and ended at sunset, while our days begin at midnight and close at midnight. Hence this meeting was on Saturday night, not on Sunday. It was held at this time because the next day Paul was to leave these people, and this was a farewell meeting. No evidence for Sunday sacredness here.

“The eighth time the day is mentioned is in 1 Cor. 16:1-3. From this passage the claim is made that the early churches were accustomed to meet on Sunday and take a collection. But the passage says no such thing. This is not instruction to hold a weekly meeting, but for ‘every one’ to ‘lay by him in store.’ Their gift was to be placed in a public offering, but to be laid by ‘in store’ at home, and would then be gathered by Paul when he came. It was a special fund for the relief of the needy saints at Jerusalem, not a regular weekly collection. It was made up on the first day of the week, not because that was the Sabbath, but because it was the first working day. After the brethren had kept the Sabbath, and returned to their work on the first day, the first thing they were to do was to cast up their accounts to see how God had prospered them the previous week, and as he had prospered them, they were to lay aside their portion ‘in store’ until Paul came, and he would either take it or send it up to Jerusalem. There is no evidence at all in this passage for Sunday sacredness.

“These are the only passages that mention the first day in the New Testament. It is spoken of but these eight times. And these passages contain no command to keep the first day; there is no record of its ever having been appointed as the Sabbath; there is no record of its being made holy; there is no record of any sacredness being attached to it; there is no promise of blessing for its observance; the apostles did not keep it; Christ did not keep it; the early Christians did not keep it; in fact, there is nothing in all the Bible that gives the slightest hint of a Sunday institution. Sunday keeping is a practice without Bible authority, and should therefore at once be discarded by all Bible Christians.

“And now it will be interesting to notice that the disciples were accustomed to preach constantly on the Sabbath, instead of the first day. Read Acts 13:14-16; 13:42-44; 16:11-13; 17:1-3; 18:1-11. That Jesus himself was accustomed to observe the Sabbath is plain from Luke 4:16, 31.

“Thus it will be seen that there is much evidence in the New Testament for the observance of the seventh day, the true Sabbath, and absolutely no evidence for the observance of the first day. The introduction of Sunday observance into the Christian church is of later origin than the times of the apostles, and authority for it cannot be found in the Bible.

“Therefore I again appeal to you Christians that you discard this anti-Scriptural practice of Sunday keeping, and follow Jesus, follow the apostles, and follow the Bible in keeping holy the seventh day of the week, the true Sabbath of God.”

As Donald passed out of the tent he heard old Deacon Sewell, of the Methodist Church, say to his wife, “Mother, how strange it is that we have lived so long and have not before this learned these things. The minister has made things so clear that I am convinced we have been wrong in keeping Sunday.”

There seemed to be many others who held a similar opinion to the deacon’s. Mr. Hunter, Donald’s father, carefully looked up the scriptures that had been used, and as he closed the Bible his face was set in determined lines.

As for Donald, he was already convinced. There never could be any other Sabbath than the seventh day for him. But he was glad that his store of knowledge was increasing every night. He wanted greatly to learn all the truth, so that some day he would be prepared to tell it to others as clearly and convincingly as did Elder Harris.