[We begin a new department in this issue. If you wish it to become a regular feature of the paper, then send to the editor any question relating to good form or social ethics that you may wish to have answered.]
WHICH is better, to talk over among ourselves the faults of our friends, or to speak to them about their mistakes, or breaches of good form?
A. E. V
This question was asked of one long connected with our work, and he said very expressively: “I have known of many things people have said about me, but I cannot recall a single instance where a person has come to me and helpfully pointed out a fault. How I wish they would do the latter way!”
Some of us have been more fortunate than this, for there are those who are sufficiently friendly and courageous to tell a person directly his fault. All are not backbiters.
Perhaps there would be more who would be willing to tell another his faults, if there were more who had enough good sense and grace to accept criticism in an appreciative spirit.
Earmarks of Egotism
A man with gray hair has remembered for long years the friendly criticism of a college chum. The first-mentioned young man was an honest, upright, ambitious youth, fresh from his uncle’s farm. He had done nothing of which he was ashamed, and so in writing a recommendation for himself, he wrote one that was true, but bore the earmarks of plain egotism.
On showing the recommendation to his friend, he was told that it would not do to send such a letter. That while all he had written was true, and the friend himself could add to it, that the man to whom he was writing did not know him, and it would sound to him too egotistical to prove acceptable. So in response to a request the chum wrote a recommendation, straightforward and businesslike, but not overcomplimentary.
This young man saw that the criticism was just, and has always felt grateful for the friendly counsel of his chum.
A Cynic and Oversensitive
A young woman was once told by a matron that she was the worst cynic she ever met. This was a hard saying, but the young woman did not resent the charge, but accepted it as true, and tried to profit by it.
Another person told this same young woman that she was too sensitive ever to do good work in the world. She now holds a prominent place in our work, so she must have accepted this criticism in the same spirit as she did the former.
Oversensitiveness is a serious fault. If one thinks everything another says is directed at her personally, she will always be in trouble, and life will become a burden to herself and she an annoyance to her friends. Immunity from hurts and slights is to be cultivated.
Sacrilegious in Conversation
Another young woman profited by the criticism of one who had told her she was sacrilegious, meaning that she used Bible language and sacred terms in a frivolous manner. This is growing more and more common; but it is none the less wrong. One should never quote the Bible or use sacred terms in a flippant, careless way. It betrays great thoughtlessness and irreverence.
Personally Reminded
A well-meaning young man in one of our academies began to sharpen a pencil in the church during the intermission between Sabbath school and the following service. His Bible teacher observed the act, and stepping from the pulpit to the pew where the young man was seated, told him it was not proper to do that in the church. It was enough of a shock to the young man to deter him from ever again sharpening a pencil in church, but the criticism, or reproof, was appreciated.
Too Boisterous, Too Exacting
A man of long experience in the social and business world relates the following pertinent incidents:
“A young man, a friend, told me that I should be less boisterous in my laughing. I had been repeatedly complimented on my hearty, manly laugh. I therefore thought he was simply jealous; but later I came to see that he was altogether right, and I was very grateful for his stinging but friendly criticism.”
“Ten years ago a minister told me I was too exacting in dealing with my help. I did not feel that I was. I thought I should be even more so than I was, but I began to watch myself in this particular, and in a short time made improvements that all recognized, and for which I am indeed grateful.”
Not Enough Snap in Work
A compositor in one of our large printing offices said that his foreman once revealed to him confidentially that one of the reasons he was not advanced in his work faster was because he was dreamy and not so energetic as he should be. He did good and faithful work, but he needed to put more snap into it. This statement, the young man claimed, had helped him to get a truer picture of himself. “For example,” he said, “you have a mental picture of me. I have one of myself; but more than likely yours is truer than my own; so if I can get your picture, it is better for me. This criticism helped me to get my foreman’s picture of myself, and has been of great help to me.”
Lapses in Spelling and Pronunciation
A young woman in a request to her fiancé to make a typewritten copy of a letter for her, suggested that the second syllable of opportunity is spelled por. He realized for the first time that in his letters to her he had been misspelling the word. A hint was sufficient to work a reformation.
At a Sabbath school teachers’ meeting the leader used the word “belligerent,” making the “g” hard. After the meeting a friend suggested to him that when he reached home he “should put that ‘g’ to soak.” The unique suggestion impressed the correct pronunciation.
Sarcastic, Judged Motives
A young man holding a responsible position was told by a friend that his official letters were sarcastic. He had not realized this; so an immediate effort was made to correct the unbusinesslike habit.
Another man was told by a friend that he had the unfortunate habit of impugning the motives of others. We may know that persons make mistakes, but we cannot know that their motives are wrong. He accepted the criticism as just, and says that “a hopeful reformation, at least, has been made.”
I have come to believe that in general people consider it a real favor to be told their faults. Not that it is pleasant medicine to take, but the results are salutary. Even to the most sensitive it is preferable to the backbiter’s method. F. D. C.